FanPost

Pettis Meets Melendez in Battle over 27 Lineal Titles

Hello there lineal title fans! This Saturday, the UFC offers up some great lineal title action with a combined 30 titles on the line, culminating in the main event where UFC Lightweight champion Anthony Pettis puts 27 lineal titles on the line. If Gilbert Melendez is successful in wrestling the gold from Pettis, he'll own 27 of 60 active titles in the weight class, good for 45% unification and 3rd place on the overall leaderboard. Most impressively, Gil would have 48 lineal titles for his career across 2 weight classes. This would pass Anderson Silva (21) on the all-time list of fighters who have held titles in more than one weight class. It would also put him 2nd on the Career Lineal Title List behind only Cain Velasquez (49).

For those who may be new to this series, I track 425 lineal titles across 85 promotions (past and present). 151 fighters can currently claim the title of "Lineal Champion." What that means is that they "beat the guy who beat the guy" (or girl). Regardless of what the promoter decides to do with their organizational title (strip the champ, go out of business etc.), the lineal belt lives on and can only change hands in the cage/ring.

Before we dive into the details, here's a quick reminder of the rules that I follow when tracing these lineages:

Rules:

1. All titles trace back to the given promotion's inaugural championship, unless specifically noted

2. Only bouts contested within the weight class for which the belt was created are counted in the lineage. (See Rule 3 for exceptions)

3. WMMA belts will be allowed to "migrate" to different weight classes due to more frequent weight class changes by female fighters

4. If a title dead ends due to change of weight class or retirement, the next title issued by the promotion will be considered. I will refer to each issued title as an "iteration" of the belt (1st iteration, 2nd iterations, etc.)

5. No Contest rulings will always be respected (i.e. Diaz vs Gomi: Diaz tested positive for marijuana, so the fight does not effect the lineage)

6. TUF fights are exhibitions and will generally not count in the lineage of a title. TUF 20 for the Strawweight title may be an exception if it comes into play

Lineal Titles of Anthony Pettis:

1. Ironheart Crown

Lineage: Phil Johns (1999) → Jens PulverDin Thomas → BJ Penn → Jens Pulver → Duane LudwigTyson GriffinFrankie EdgarGray Maynard → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

2. UFC

Lineage: Jens Pulver (2001) → Duane Ludwig → Tyson Griffin → Frankie Edgar → Gray Maynard → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

3. Gladiator Challenge

Lineage: Juliano Prado (2001) → David GardnerJavier Vazquez → Alberto Crane → Roger HuertaKenny Florian → BJ Penn → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

4. Ring of Fire

Lineage: Leonard Garcia (2001) → Roger Huerta → Kenny Florian → BJ Penn → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Traces back to LW tournament at ROF 2 won by Leonard Garcia. That same night, a separate LW champion was crowned, Eric Payne, but his title dead ends

5. TKO

Lineage - Duane Ludwig (2003) → Tyson Griffin → Frankie Edgar → Gray Maynard → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

6. Rumble on the Rock

Lineage: BJ Penn (2003) → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

7. WEC

Lineage: Gilbert Melendez (2004) → Mitsuhiro IshidaCaol UnoShinya AokiJoachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

8. SportFight

Lineage: Dennis Davis (2004) → Jake Short → Roger Huerta → Kenny Florian → BJ Penn → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

9. Reality Fighting

Lineage: Kurt Pellegrino (2004) → Satoru Kitaoka → Katsuya Inoue → Akira Kikuchi → Shinya Aoki → Joachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

10. Shooto Americas

Lineage: JZ Cavalcante (2005) → Shinya Aoki → Joachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Earliest iterations of Shooto Americas titles were awarded at various other promotions' events. This one traces back to a 2005 HookNShoot event where JZ Cavalcante won the inaugural title.

11. Extreme Challenge

Lineage: Rich Clementi (2005) → Caol Uno → JZ Cavalcante → Shinya Aoki → Joachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

12. IFC

Lineage: Roger Huerta (2005) → Kenny Florian → BJ Penn → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

13. Icon Sport

Lineage: Kultar Gill (2005) → Daisuke Sugie → Josh ThomsonClay Guida → Gilbert Melendez → Mitsuhiro Ishida → Caol Uno → Shinya Aoki → Joachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Traces back to original SuperBrawl LW title (later changed their name to Icon Sport)

14. Strikeforce

Lineage: Clay Guida (2006) → Gilbert Melendez → Josh Thomson → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Strikeforce also issued a US version of the title won by Josh Thomson in 2006. This version of the belt was unified with the World title by Josh Thomson in 2008 so I just track it as a single title

15. Cage Fury Fighting Championship

Lineage: Al Buck (2006) → Jim Miller → Gray Maynard → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

16. EliteXC

Lineage: KJ Noons (2007) → Jorge Masvidal → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

17. IFL

Lineage: Ryan Schultz (2007) → Mizuto Hirota → Kazunori Yokota → Satoru Kitaoka → Mizuto Hirota → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

18. K-1 Hero's

Lineage: JZ Cavalcante (2007) → Shinya Aoki → Joachim Hansen → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: 2nd iteration, 1st dead ends at Kid Yamamoto who moved down in weight

19. Spirit MC

Lineage: Kwang Hee Lee (2007) → Eiji Mitsuoka → Satoru Kitaoka → Mizuto Hirota → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Spirit refers to this as a WW title, but bouts are contested at 154 lbs

20. National Association of Boxing Commissions (NABC)

Lineage: Deividas Taurosevicius (2007) → Ryan Schultz → Mizuto Hirota → Kazunori Yokota → Satoru Kitaoka → Mizuto Hirota → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: National Association of Boxing Commissions used to crown MMA champions at various Regional Promotions: Cage Fury Fighting and Legends of Fighting

21. PFC

Lineage: Shad Smith (2007) → Nam PhanBilly Evangelista → Jorge Masvidal → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

22. Dream

Lineage: Joachim Hansen (2008) → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

23. WAMMA

Lineage: Shinya Aoki (2008) → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

24. Ring of Combat

Lineage: Jim Miller (2008) → Gray Maynard → Frankie Edgar → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

25. Cage Force

Lineage: Mizuto Hirota (2008) → Kazunori Yokota → Satoru Kitaoka → Mizuto Hirota → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

  • Note: Traces back to 2nd iteration, 1st dead ends at different weight class

26. WVR - Sengoku

Lineage: Satoru Kitaoka (2009) → Mizuto Hirota → Shinya Aoki → Gilbert Melendez → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

27. Tachi Palace

Lineage: Gabe Ruediger (2010) → Joe LauzonGeorge SotiropoulosDennis SiverDonald CerroneNate Diaz → Benson Henderson → Anthony Pettis

Lightweight Lineal Pie:

Below, you will notice that Donald Cerone also holds an impressive chunk of the pie with 11 active lineal titles in the division. This includes the two oldest active titles in IVC and Shooto, which were both established in 1999.

lineal_pie_LW.0.PNG

Lineal History Lesson (Lightweight Edition):

History of Lightweight Lineal Kings
Champion Titles % Unify
Anthony Pettis 27 45% 2014
Anthony Pettis 27 47% 2013
Benson Henderson 27 47% 2013
Gilbert Melendez 16 32% 2011
Gilbert Melendez 14 29% 2010
Shinya Aoki 13 31% 2009
Tatsuya Kawajiri 9 21% 2009
Kazunori Yokota 9 21% 2009
Eiji Mitsuoka 9 21% 2009
Sergey Golyaev 9 24% 2008
Takanori Gomi 9 38% 2006
Mitsuhiro Ishida 9 38% 2006
Marcus Aurelio 8 33% 2006
Takanori Gomi 8 38% 2005
Takanori Gomi 4 19% 2005
Hayato Sakurai 3 14% 2005
Joachim Hansen 3 14% 2005
Yves Edwards 3 14% 2005
Tatsuya Kawajiri 3 20% 2004
Vitor Ribeiro 3 25% 2003
Joachim Hansen 2 17% 2003
Takanori Gomi 2 29% 2002
Dokonjonosuke Mishima 2 50% 2000
Marcio Barbosa 2 50% 2000
Caol Uno 2 67% 1999
Rafael Cordeiro IVC - 1999 (Earliest Active)

Big Ten Titles of the Lightweight Division:

Criteria for Selection of Big Ten Titles
1 Significance of title to division when first installed
2 Significance of the inaugural champion crowned
3 Significance of lineal path title follows over time
Lightweight 1. IVC - Rafael Cordeiro (1999) 6. Pride FC - Takanori Gomi (2005) Anthony Pettis (60% Unification) Donald Cerone (40% Unification)
2. Shooto - Caol Uno (1999) 7. Strikeforce - Clay Guida (2006)
3. Ironheart Crown - Phil Johns (1999) 8. EliteXC - KJ Noons (2007)
4. UFC - Jens Pulver (2001) 9. Dream - Joachim Hansen (2008)
5. WEC - Gilbert Melendez (2004) 10. Bellator MMA - Eddie Alvarez (2009)

Lineal Leaderboard:

# Name # of Titles Unify Big 10
1 Cain Velasquez 37 74% 100%
2 Georges St. Piere 31 56% 80%
3 Anthony Pettis 27 45% 60%
4 Chris Weidman 25 49% 70%
5 Jon Jones 21 51% 90%
6 Jose Aldo 20 42% 60%
7 Ronda Rousey 18 67% 90%
8 Donald Cerrone 11 18% 40%
9 Mighty Mouse 8 32% 70%
9 Dominick Cruz 8 21% 40%
9 Patricio Freire 8 17% 20%
10 Bibiano Fernandes 6 18% 20%
10 Vitor Belfort 6 12% 20%
10 Jacare Souza 6 12% 10%
11 Cyborg Justino 5 100% -
11 Claudia Gadelha 5 31% -
11 Ben Askren 5 9% 20%
12 Jessica Aguilar 4 25% -
12 Marlon Moraes 4 13% 10%
12 Gegard Mousasi 4 10% 0%
12 Vitaly Minakov 4 8% 0%
12 Rick Glenn 4 8% 0%
13 Michelle Waterson 3 60% -
13 Conor McGregor 3 6% 20%
13 Miesha Tate 3 11% 0%
13 Emanuel Newton 3 7% 0%
13 Alexander Gustafsson 3 7% 0%
13 Tyron Woodley 3 5% 0%
13 Khabib Nurmegomodov 3 5% 10%
14 Fourteen tied with 2 each 2 - -

Upcoming Unification Bouts # Date
Bibiano Fernandes vs Dae Hwan Kim 7 titles 5-Dec
Jon Fitch vs Rousimar Palhares 3 titles 13-Dec
Alexander Gustafsson vs A. Johnson 5 titles 24-Jan
Miesha Tate vs Sara McMann 4 titles 31-Jan
Chris Weidman vs Vitor Belfort 31 titles 28-Feb
Ronda Rousey vs Cat Zingano 20 titles 28-Feb
Jacare Souza vs Yoel Romero 7 titles 28-Feb
Emanuel Newton vs Liam McGeary 4 titles 28-Feb
Dominick Cruz vs TJ Dillashaw 10 titles TBD
Other Titles on the Line # Date
Michelle Waterson vs Herica Tiburcio 3 titles 5-Dec
Igor Subora vs Brandon Vera 1 title 5-Dec
Anthony Pettis vs Gilbert Melendez 27 titles 6-Dec
Ashlee Smith vs Raquel Pennington 1 title 6-Dec
Borys Mankowski vs David Zawada 1 title 6-Dec
Robbie Lawler vs Johny Hendricks 2 titles 6-Dec
Gota Yamashita vs Yuki Kondo 1 title 6-Dec
Mamed Khalidov vs Brett Cooper 1 title 6-Dec
Rafael dos Anjos vs Nate Diaz 2 title 13-Dec
Matt Mitrione vs Gabriel Gonzaga 1 title 13-Dec
Stipe Miocic vs Junior Dos Santos 1 title 13-Dec
Anthony Birchak vs Ian Entwistle 1 title 13-Dec
Claudia Gadelha vs Joanna Jędrzejczyk 5 titles 13-Dec
Sheymon Moraes vs Josh Hill 1 title 13-Dec
Xian Ji vs Yadong Song 1 title 19-Dec
Hector Lombard vs Josh Burkman 1 title 3-Jan
Jon Jones vs Daniel Cormier 21 titles 3-Jan
Patricio Freire vs Daniel Straus 8 titles 16-Jan
Donald Cerrone vs Myles Jury 11 titles 18-Jan
Conor McGregor vs Dennis Siver 3 titles 18-Jan
Norman Parke vs Gleison Tibau 2 titles 18-Jan
Konstantin Erokhin vs Viktor Pesta 1 title 24-Jan
Tyron Woodley vs Kelvin Gastelum 3 titles 31-Jan
Jordan Mein vs Thiago Alves 1 title 31-Jan
Thales Leites vs Tim Boetsch 1 title 31-Jan
Ian McCall vs John Lineker 1 title 31-Jan
Stephen Thompson vs Brandon Thatch 1 title 14-Feb
Cain Velasquez vs Fabricio Werdum 37 titles TBD
Vitaly Minakov vs Alexander Volkov 4 titles TBD

Sources
1 http://wrestlingdata.com/index.php?befehl=titles&kategorie=5
2 http://www.sherdog.com/events
3 http://www.mixedmartialarts.com/mma.cfm?go=stats.home
4 http://www.tapology.com/search?term=
5 http://www.wikipedia.org/
6 http://www.mmalinker.com/wiki/

\The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.

In This FanPost

Events
Fighters