clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Did Chris Weidman have a more impressive run to the title than Jon Jones?

Bloody Elbow's Mookie Alexander examines the UFC careers of champions Chris Weidman and Jon Jones, and asks which run to the title was better.


Jon Jones and Chris Weidman were not even professional MMA fighters in January 2008. Today, they're both UFC champions, each having charted their own torrid and dominant path toward their respective belts.

Over the course of five years, MMA fans have witnessed two special talents in the sport go from blue chip prospects to the elite of the division. Jones needed fewer than three years of pro fighting to capture the light heavyweight crown, while Weidman needed only four to become the middleweight champ. Weidman's UFC debut came just 2 weeks before Jones' title fight against Mauricio Rua. "Bones" has more fights under his belt, has fought on a more frequent schedule, and is on his way to becoming the greatest 205 lbs fighter of all time. Weidman is lined up for a rematch against Anderson Silva, and if he manages another victory over "The Spider" he could very well put himself in a position to be one of the greatest middleweights in MMA history.

Let's have a look at how each man fared in the UFC before becoming a champion, and ask ourselves "Who had the more impressive run to the title?".

Chris Weidman

Age of UFC debut: 26

Wins: Alessio Sakara (UD), Jesse Bongfeldt (SUB), Tom Lawlor (SUB), Demian Maia (UD), Mark Munoz (KO), Anderson Silva (KO).

Losses: None

Finishing rate: 66%

Weidman replaced the injured Rafael Natal on less than three weeks notice vs. Alessio Sakara. He was already regarded as a high-level prospect by Bloody Elbow scouts back in 2010. Despite the short notice fight, Weidman closed as a 2-to-1 favorite over Sakara, and he easily beat the veteran by unanimous decision. After dominating and submitting Jesse Bongfeldt and Tom Lawlor, Weidman was brought in at the last minute to fight Demian Maia at UFC on Fox 2 in January 2012. Despite a massive weight cut in a much shorter time span, Weidman both made weight and beat Maia in what was otherwise an ugly fight. He was given a headlining spot on Fuel TV against Mark Munoz later that July, and he delivered a brutal knockout that lasted the duration of "Hey Jude" repeated 500 times.

Instead of fighting Tim Boetsch at UFC 155, Weidman pulled out after suffering a torn labrum, and after completing surgery he was granted a title shot vs. Anderson Silva. Despite concerns about ring rust, his health, and whether or not he actually deserved it based on beating Mark Munoz, he left Las Vegas on Saturday night as the UFC middleweight champion. It was a history-making moment for him, and now we await to see if he can a) Beat Anderson in a rematch, and b) Become a dominant champion in a weight class whose only form of continuity at the top came from Anderson Silva.

Here are some facts about Weidman's UFC career thus far:

  • He has finished all of his opposition (4) when given a full training camp. They've each also come within the 7 minute mark.
  • The win over Demian Maia is the only fight in which he lost at least one round on two scorecards. Inexplicably, Marcos Rosales scored round 1 of Silva/Weidman for Silva, and that's the only other time any judge has scored a round for Weidman's opponent.
  • He (obviously) is the first man to KO Anderson Silva and give him a UFC loss.
  • At 29, he's the 2nd youngest champion in UFC middleweight history. Dave Menne won the first 185 lbs title at UFC 33 at the age of 27.

Jon Jones

Age of UFC debut: 21

Wins: Andre Gusmao (UD), Stephan Bonnar (UD), Jake O'Brien (SUB), Brandon Vera (TKO), Vladimir Matyushenko (TKO), Ryan Bader (SUB), Mauricio Rua (TKO)

Losses: Matt Hamill (DQ)

Finishing rate: 62.5%

Like Weidman, Jones had his UFC debut come on short notice. Bones replaced Tomasz Drwal against Andre Gusmao and took a unanimous decision win at UFC 87 in August 2008. His impressive (if not wild) debut merited a main card appearance against Stephan Bonnar at UFC 94, where he unleashed a vicious spinning elbow to Bonnar's head in one of his greatest highlights. Jones hung on late for another decision victory, and then went on an astonishing display of dominant performances that included submitting Jake O'Brien unconscious, breaking Brandon Vera's orbital, and stopping Ryan Bader with consummate ease.

It was after the Bader fight that Jones was all lined up for a title shot, but he received it earlier than expected when Rashad Evans injured his knee and was unable to fight Shogun for the LHW championship at UFC 128. By then, Jones' dominance had been established to the point where Shogun went from a favorite against Rashad to an underdog versus the challenger. On March 19th, 2011, only six weeks after beating Bader, Jones demolished the champion in one of the most lopsided title fights in UFC history, forcing a TKO stoppage in the 3rd round after punishing Shogun from start to finish. Unlike Weidman's win over Silva, there's no debate or need for a rematch any time soon or on this planet. Jones has successfully defended his title five times and will go for his sixth this September vs. Alexander Gustafsson.

Some notable tidbits from Jones' UFC performances up until the win over Shogun:
  • Jones became the youngest champion in UFC history at 23 years old.
  • Believe it or not, Jones opened and closed as a betting underdog against both Gusmao and Bonnar.
  • After losing round 3 to Stephan Bonnar, Jon Jones did not lose another round (but he did lose to Matt Hamill by DQ) against anyone he faced leading up to his title bout with Rua.
Having profiled both champions, which one do you think had the better UFC resume leading up to capturing their respective titles? Personally, I think I would give a slight edge to Jones based on how utterly superior he proved to be against opposition that is overall superior to Weidman's. His seemingly effortless beatings of Vera, Matyushenko, Bader, and Shogun propelled him into the conversation of top 10 p4p fighter, and his title defenses have cemented his status as one of the best in the world.

That said, Weidman knocked out the consensus greatest fighter of all-time, a possibility that largely wasn't entertained by those who believed Weidman would beat Silva. He also beat a former #1 contender in Maia (who is now a threat at welterweight) and pulverized a top 10 opponent in Munoz. Jones' only win over a (then-) top 10 opponent prior to the Shogun fight was against Ryan Bader. His resume is impressive and is likely to expand with more top names at 185 lbs.

Whatever your opinion, I think fans should be highly appreciative of both Jones and Weidman and what they've accomplished in their short MMA careers. It is quite possible that these two will be the undisputed torch bearers for greatness once Anderson Silva and Georges St. Pierre are no longer at the top of the sport.

SBN coverage of UFC 162: Silva vs. Weidman