Bloody Elbow: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: A nation of fighters Bar-right-arrows



The Debt of Kalib Starnes

Jake Rossen has a very interesting piece this morning where he attempts to lay out the case of what, precisely, fighters "owe" fans, "owe" their competitor and ultimately, what they "owe" the sport when they compete. Notable quote:

Did Starnes "owe" spectators a willingness to engage against Quarry even though he suspected he'd be concussed? Isn't that a masochistic attitude to take? Don't they put people on medication for that type of behavior?

"Yes" to all of the above. Welcome to the cranially irresponsible world of prizefighting.

There is a tacit agreement every combat athlete makes when he commits to a fight -- that he'll do his very best to win the bout. That doesn't preclude them from defending themselves, but it does mean that one can't assume the disposition of a drugged puppy simply because some hurt is coming their way.

Consider Tito Ortiz, a fighter whose persona has generally grated this particular member of the audience. Facing Chuck Liddell in 2004, Ortiz's prior training sessions with his opponent had congealed on his brain. From reports, he was unable to ever take Liddell down and was batted about like a tethered balloon standing.

Despite overwhelming evidence that he wouldn't be able to exchange successfully with Liddell, Ortiz gamely trudged forward, doing his best to evade damage while meting out his own. It didn't work -- Ortiz was struck down early in the second -- but he tried. He gave effort. He fought. Didn't shy away from Liddell the second time, either, even after he had tasted his own blood.

Nobody wins a fight going backwards. And if victory is the ultimate endgame, whatever a fighter does and however he does it should be predicated on putting one foot in front of the other. It might leave a cut, a bruise or a slightly engorged brain. Damage is the currency of combat.

There is a point where a motivated performance gives way to manic, misplaced courage. The Japanese fighters are famous for engaging against warhorses that -- because of size or skill -- could easily turn them into premature assisted care residents. Other fighters are obstinate in playing to their opponents' strengths to prove they have what it takes. Not healthy.

Show up, be in shape, try your best without taking foolish chances: not complicated arithmetic.

Fair enough. But what do the fans owe the fighters? Aside from the obvious "respect" and "adoration", I also think patience is due. Most importantly, while "reverence" would be too strong a word, something above respect and below reverence might fit the bill. Fans need to remind themselves exactly what it is that these fighters are actually doing for entertainment purposes. No one needs to boo-hoo the torment that fighters suffer through as its their choice to do so. But they do need to acknowledge it and they need to, inasmuch as they can, come to terms with how deep a sacrifice that is and how fatiguing that process is over the long run.

Fighters have to show up ready to fight and short of the kamikaze, they have to give their all. Fans, conversely, need to acknowledge and honor the sacrifice and commitment of fighters who hold up their end of the bargain. Over the long run, that will lead the newer or uninitiated fan to the patience and quiet respect smarter, more experienced fans already have.

0 recs | Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Re: The Debt of Kalib Starnes
In this situation, the fans more than paid their due to Kalib with the rock star greeting he got when introduced. His performance thereafter -- particularly the slurs he tossed at Quarry's cornermen -- was disgrace personified. A Samurai would've hari-kari'd himself after that performance. I don't expect that level of honor madness from Starnes, but an excuse free apology would be a nice start.

by Kid Nate on May 5, 2008 11:58 AM EDT   0 recs

Re: The Debt of Kalib Starnes
How about not coming out for the third round?  If he hadn't realized by that point, like everyone else watching, that he wasn't going to win and was really injured like he says he was then he could have saved us all five minutes of our lives and stayed on the stool.  I would have had more respect for him and he might still have a future, Duran did.

by riley on May 5, 2008 3:00 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"All men are frauds. The only difference between them is that some admit it. I myself deny it." -- H.L. Mencken

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Keith Jardine to face Luiz Cane at UFC 97
Small
Fedor Emelianenko Responds to Freddie Roach's Comments
Danatar8211_small
King Mo Addresses His Subjects
Small
The Real Threat To USA Wrestling? Title IX
Nk2_small
Measuring Affliction's Success

Recent FanPosts

Blue_you2_small
Roger Huerta to Leave UFC After Next Fight
Small
Ricardo Almeida vs. Matt Horwich at UFN 18 in April
Nk2_small
Fedor Emelianenko, His Legacy, and the UFC
Small
Did UFC 92 crush UFC 91 in PPV Buys?
Small
Quinton Jackson Enters Guilty Plea, Granted Plea Bargain
Bloodyelbow_small
How UFC 96 is Looking So Far
Sports_pridefightingchampionshipslogo_1__small
Alessio Sakara out, Dan Miller in Against Jake Rosholt
Small
Mike Swick Busted for Traffic Violations in Phuket, Thailand
Small
Goulet expected to fight McCrory in Montreal at UFC 97

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter