Lift the Ban Watch Do-Over: Vancouver Really May Be One UFC and Done With MMA
I botched it pretty bad with my earlier post about Vancouver -- but thanks to feedback from readers much more informed than I (thanks Emma May and who me), I've now read two Vancouver Sun stories from earlier this month that make me even less confident that the UFC or any regulated MMA will ever return to Vancouver.
From the Vancouver Sun, July 8:
Ongoing insurance and indemnity issues surrounding professional mixed martial arts in the city of Vancouver could well see the two-year trial of regulated MMA pass with only a single professional event having been held, according to Vision Vancouver city council member Dr Kerry Jang and licensing staffer Tom Hammel.
"I think it's possible," said Jang when asked whether the legal issues dogging the sport in Vancouver could see the trial period end with barely any testing having actually taken place.
City assistant director of licensing Tom Hammel confirmed to Sun reporter Jeff Lee Wednesday that it is entirely possible that, during that entire two year trial period, the city won't license any MMA events against which they can study the outcomes.
Said Jang, "We're waiting for reports on the UFC event that just took place. We need to gauge how residents feel in the neighborhood. some people complained that there should be a more visible police presence instead of undercover officers. There was an issue with a beating - unrelated to the UFC, but the perception was there."
The story goes on to outline the ways that the local government has basically made it impossible for local promoters to put on MMA shows with a flurry of catch-22 style government barriers to entry.
Then there's this one from the Vancouver Sun, July 9th:
City council fired the head of the Vancouver Athletic Commission on Thursday after city staff and others complained about his conduct during the recent debate over allowing an Ultimate Fighting Championship event.
Citing a lack of confidence in Mirko Mladenovic, the council appointed Dave Rudberg, a longtime city bureaucrat, to replace him as head of the commission when it reconvenes later this month.
...
(Mladenovic) said he was aware that staff and others had complained about his conduct, but said that appeared to be an excuse to bounce him from the commission.
"I've been on the board for three terms. I am only into this one four months. What has changed? What has changed is they wanted to kill UFC and I approved it," he said.
So my larger point remains, the UFC's damn the torpedoes approach to getting MMA regulated, is sometimes a net negative that actually sets back the sport. I fear that the second UFC in Germany will be the last.
UPDATE: Thanks to this FanPost from MattParker117 I see that that the UFC is considering going back to Vancouver in 2011 but has not been in contact with local authorities. They might be in for a rude shock, per MMA Weekly:
"We're busy working on our upcoming shows (San Diego, Oakland, Boston, and Indy) and haven't really focused on Vancouver," Marc Ratner, UFC Vice President of Regulatory Affairs, told MMAWeekly.com on Friday.
"When we start working on our 2011 schedule we'll contact the City Council and the Commission and see what they need for us to return."
...
The company has been in recent discussions with other Canadian cities, looking to expand its efforts in the Great White North."(We) talked with the Manitoba, Calgary, and Edmonton Commissions last week," said Ratner, who said those municipalities were "absolutely" receptive to running UFC events in their cities.
The UFC also opened offices in Toronto in June, which will likely speed expansion into Canada. There will likely be multiple events in multiple Canadian locations in 2011, whether or not Vancouver is one of them.
34 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
IMO the Vancouver issure is MUCH more important than Germany. We need the UFC in Canada, Germany? Not necessarily, at least not right now. And the fact that a beating is being associated with the UFC being there that night (even though it had no connection at all) is ridiculous. If there had been a Justin Bieber concert at the arena that night would Vancouver ban all teenage pop music? Then again maybe that would be a good thing.
They need MMA in southern Ontario
It’s such a huge market for the UFC, and who knows how what happens in Vancouver will impact what will or won’t happen in Toronto. It’s certainly a story worth keeping an eye on.
"I thought I was getting raped by Freddy Mercury."
- Tank Abbot
on his decision loss to Dan Severn in 1995
except
Germany is absolutely CRITICAL to the UFC’s long term strategy of international expansion. They know better than anyone that the MMA boom in the U.S. is fragile and could fade. They NEED large secondary markets like Germany as a safe haven. Canada is too close not to be impacted by a collapse in the states.
Follow me on Twitter @KidNate
For those wondering why Germany is so important, they need to realize it has a GDP almost three times as large as Canada. And if you get Germany, the neighboring nations should follow, giving you another market on par with all of North America. It’s the golden apple for Zuffa.
Starting in Germany and moving out into the rest of the EU may of just hit a wall head on but they can still try to move into the rest of the EU and hope that helps Germany move in the right direction. Poland for instance isn’t a wealthy country but Poles do seem to be taking to the sport better, same with Scandinadians and kickboxing is already big in the Netherlands which is helping MMA along there. They may just have to change their focus in Europe considering how messed up things are in Germany with this.
Nominal GDP IMF 2008 millions of USD

That graph is a bit old but it makes a real point in terms of the gross domestic product distribution in the world and why the US market is so darn important. Only the combined EU has a greater GDP and the number two country on the list Japan only has about 1/3 the GDP the US does. To establish a secondary worldwide market the UFC is going to have to get a foot into all the major players (and that does seem to be what they are trying to do).
Here is the whole IMF list for 2009 (Canada sits at 10). The World Bank and the CIA factbook also have GDP list but the differences are minor.
Rank Country GDP (millions of USD)
1 United States 14,256,275
2 Japan 5,068,059
3 People’s Republic of China 4,908,9822
4 Germany 3,352,742
5 France 2,675,951
6 United Kingdom 2,183,607
7 Italy 2,118,264
8 Brazil 1,574,039
9 Spain 1,464,040
10 Canada 1,336,427
11 India 1,235,975
12 Russia 1,229,227
13 Australia 997,201
14 Mexico 874,903
15 South Korea 832,512
16 Netherlands 794,777
17 Turkey 615,329
18 Indonesia 539,377
19 Switzerland 494,622
20 Belgium 470,400
21 Poland 430,197
22 Sweden 405,440
23 Norway 382,983
24 Austria 381,880
25 Republic of China (Taiwan) 378,969
26 Saudi Arabia 369,671
27 Venezuela 337,295
28 Greece 330,780
29 Iran 330,461
30 Argentina 310,065
31 Denmark 309,252
32 South Africa 287,219
33 Thailand 263,889
34 Finland 238,128
35 United Arab Emirates 229,971
36 Colombia 228,836
37 Portugal 227,855
38 Ireland 227,781
— Hong Kong 210,731
39 Czech Republic 194,828
40 Israel 194,825
41 Malaysia 191,463
42 Egypt 187,954
43 Singapore 177,132
44 Nigeria 173,428
45 Pakistan 166,515
46 Chile 161,781
47 Romania 161,521
48 Philippines 160,991
49 Algeria 140,848
50 Hungary 129,407
51 Peru 126,766
52 New Zealand 117,795
53 Ukraine 116,191
54 Kuwait 111,309
55 Kazakhstan 109,273
56 Bangladesh 94,507
57 Vietnam 92,439
58 Morocco 90,815
59 Slovakia 88,208
60 Qatar 83,910
61 Angola 68,755
62 Iraq 65,838
63 Croatia 63,188
64 Libya 60,351
65 Ecuador 57,303
66 Sudan 54,677
67 Oman 53,395
68 Syria 52,524
69 Luxembourg 51,736
70 Slovenia 49,217
71 Belarus 48,973
72 Bulgaria 47,102
73 Dominican Republic 46,743
74 Azerbaijan 43,111
75 Serbia 42,879
76 Sri Lanka 41,323
77 Tunisia 40,168
78 Guatemala 37,302
79 Lithuania 37,254
80 Lebanon 33,585
81 Uzbekistan 32,816
82 Kenya 32,724
83 Ethiopia 32,319
84 Uruguay 31,528
85 Costa Rica 29,318
86 Burma 27,553
87 Latvia 26,247
88 Yemen 25,131
89 Panama 24,711
90 Cyprus 23,603
91 Jordan 22,929
92 Côte d’Ivoire 22,497
93 Tanzania 22,318
94 Cameroon 22,223
95 El Salvador 21,100
96 Trinidad and Tobago 20,380
97 Bahrain 20,214
98 Estonia 19,123
99 Bolivia 17,627
100 Bosnia and Herzegovina 17,133
101 Uganda 15,736
102 Ghana 15,513
103 Paraguay 14,668
104 Honduras 14,268
105 Afghanistan 14,044
106 Zambia 13,000
107 Senegal 12,738
108 Nepal 12,615
109 Equatorial Guinea 12,222
110 Albania 12,185
111 Iceland 12,133
112 Jamaica 11,903
113 Botswana 11,630
114 Democratic Republic of the Congo 11,108
115 Gabon 11,016
116 Cambodia 10,804
117 Georgia 10,737
118 Brunei 10,546
119 Mozambique 9,831
120 Republic of the Congo 9,532
121 Namibia 9,459
122 Macedonia 9,238
123 Mali 8,965
124 Mauritius 8,761
125 Armenia 8,714
126 Madagascar 8,551
127 Burkina Faso 8,105
128 Malta 7,955
129 Papua New Guinea 7,907
130 The Bahamas 7,335
131 Chad 6,854
132 Benin 6,672
133 Haiti 6,558
134 Nicaragua 6,151
135 Laos 5,598
136 Moldova 5,403
137 Kosovo 5,352
138 Niger 5,261
139 Rwanda 5,245
140 Tajikistan 4,982
141 Kyrgyzstan 4,570
142 Malawi 4,570
143 Zimbabwe 4,397
144 Guinea 4,394
145 Mongolia 4,203
146 Montenegro 4,114
147 Barbados 3,595
148 Fiji 3,060
149 Mauritania 3,029
150 Swaziland 2,983
151 Suriname 2,962
152 Togo 2,865
153 Guyana 2,024
154 Central African Republic 1,986
155 Sierra Leone 1,877
156 Eritrea 1,873
157 Cape Verde 1,768
158 Lesotho 1,602
159 Maldives 1,357
160 Belize 1,336
161 Burundi 1,321
162 Bhutan 1,269
163 Antigua and Barbuda 1,178
164 Djibouti 1,049
165 Saint Lucia 973
166 Liberia 876
167 Guinea-Bissau 826
168 Seychelles 767
169 The Gambia 736
170 Solomon Islands 657
171 Vanuatu 635
172 Grenada 615
173 East Timor 590
174 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 567
175 Samoa 558
176 Saint Kitts and Nevis 557
177 Comoros 532
178 Dominica 362
179 Tonga 313
180 São Tomé and Príncipe 191
181 Kiribati 130
The Gilbert Islands won’t be around too much longer anyways.
After years of fruitless appeals for decisive action on climate change, the tiny South Pacific nation of Kiribati has concluded that it is doomed. Yesterday its President, Anote Tong, used World Environment Day to request international help to evacuate his country before it disappears.
Water supplies are being contaminated by the encroaching salt water, Mr Tong said, and crops destroyed. Beachside communities have been moved inland. But Kiribati – 33 coral atolls sprinkled across two million square miles of ocean – has limited scope to adapt. Its highest land is barely 6 feet above sea level.
yeah, i'm really curious what's going to happen the next time the UFC comes over to germany again
i doubt that they’ll be using the same arena again, one of the owners has distanced himself from the event after it was booked.
Go big red!
If Germany and parts of Canada are no no's
Then what states/countries do you think they should be focusing on?
by ImmortalTechnique92 on Jul 24, 2010 10:14 PM EDT reply actions
Southern Ontario and New York
Those still have to be the top two markets on the UFC’s wish list.
"I thought I was getting raped by Freddy Mercury."
- Tank Abbot
on his decision loss to Dan Severn in 1995
I would think
Brasil and the UK need to be focused on as well.
by ImmortalTechnique92 on Jul 24, 2010 10:21 PM EDT reply actions
they've got the UK
started but the UK alone isn’t a big enough economy to do what they need to do. Brazil is too small economically to be more than a secondary market. Could be a sweet secondary market and it’s got a growing economy, but it’s still small potatoes compared to Deutschland.
Follow me on Twitter @KidNate
I bet Pat Barry kicked that tree.
There's no depth to my shallowness.
by Earl Montclair on Jul 24, 2010 10:22 PM EDT reply actions
“So my larger point remains, the UFC’s damn the torpedoes approach to getting MMA regulated, is sometimes a net negative that actually sets back the sport.”
Disagree. I think it’s simply the nature of politics up here in the great white north. I actually think the UFC’s aggressive, proactive approach is a good thing in Ontario/BC. There’d be even less pressure to legalize MMA in Ontario if the UFC sat back and took a less aggressive approach, imo.
WTF?
“There was an issue with a beating – unrelated to the UFC, but the perception was there.”"
What kind of bullshit reasoning is this? If a house burned down the night of the event, would that have smeared their perception of the UFC? This kind of false logic and erroneous association must be maddening to deal with if you are a sane person.
I would argue that trying to draw parallels between a beating and a fire on this topic is equally erroneous.
There's no depth to my shallowness.
by Earl Montclair on Jul 24, 2010 10:38 PM EDT up reply actions
Nate I want you to put “Thank you DirtyML” in this post somewhere and a big smiley face.
Also a heartfelt apology, a song dedication on a radio station and a short TV commercial would also be a nice addition.
Vancouver
There is one Vancouver councilor in particular who sits on the board of the PNE who will not allow professional MMA events to be held in that facility. He was the reason the Vancouver MMA Expo was cancelled, if you remember that fracas. This was the same councilor who tacked on the indemnity and insurance clause immediately after council voted to sanction MMA in December (this councilor voted against sanctioning, of course).
The PNE is really the only viable option for medium sized promotions such as the MFC. There have been a number of promotions including the MFC and Shine, and some others who have approached city council to have “the UFC deal.” They’ve been alternately told that they will not be permitted use of the PNE (despite the fact that the law which passed to sanction specifically allows for pro MMA in city owned buildings which the PNE is). Or these promotions calls have been flat out ignored while council “figures stuff out.”
As for Mirko the fired VAC head, yes he was passionate. He was an important part of bringing the UFC to Vancouver. But he is also a hothead who made choices that got him in hot water. I’ve sat in on VAC meetings. He brought it on himself.
I guess it is a good thing that the hat/bandanna stealer made a killing at 115.
There's no depth to my shallowness.
by Earl Montclair on Jul 24, 2010 10:59 PM EDT reply actions 2 recs
What does the UFC's "Damn the Torpedos" approach to regulations have to do with this?
I didn’t see your hypothesis addressed in this column at all and none of the evidence presented backs up your assertion.
Cause there's only one, and that's me
You understand? for all that fighting, you understand
That sucka think he good, that sucka think he can whoop me
And i know he can't whoop me, Ay boy, the n**** whole style is chump
by S.C. Michaelson on Jul 24, 2010 11:13 PM EDT reply actions
the aftermath of UFC 115
led to the firing of the athletic commissioner and even higher hurdles for regional mma promoters trying to work in the area.
That’s a pretty clear example of the UFC’s approach making things worse, not better IMO.
Follow me on Twitter @KidNate
What was the "aftermath"?
Forgive me, I’m not sure what you’re talking about.
Cause there's only one, and that's me
You understand? for all that fighting, you understand
That sucka think he good, that sucka think he can whoop me
And i know he can't whoop me, Ay boy, the n**** whole style is chump
by S.C. Michaelson on Jul 24, 2010 11:25 PM EDT up reply actions
Mirko got himself fired. Nice guy but… he earned his dismissal.
by Emma May on Jul 24, 2010 11:31 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
Although I will say… it’s interesting to consider your other point. If sanctioning hadn’t been jammed through to basically make way for the UFC, and instead was based solely on the legitimacy of the sport and with local pro promotions in mind, who knows if the situation would be as difficult now for smaller promotions trying to bring shows here.
The beating was a supposed gay bashing
where the blame was put on UFC 115. Which is stupid beyond belief. Right now, Vancouver is hosting the annual “Festival of lights,” which is an annual fireworks event. On the first night of the fireworks, they had these incidents:
“We’ve had 280 liquor pour-outs, four arrests for public intoxication, a number of violation tickets, about nine drug seizures and then three different weapons were seized — some bear spray, a couple of batons,” said Const. Jana McGuinness.
Because you need batons and bear spray just in case the children go apeshit over bright colours, right?? This was a relatively relaxed and quiet night during a family event of all things. At the end of the day, MMA will always have a stigma attached to it. As long as bureaucrats continue to have a hate on for MMA, it will always be difficult, because these are the kinds of people who cannot make an impartial judgment on anything, and instead will continue to try to impose what they consider to be entertainment and morality on the population. We gotta get these bums out.
by pud333 on Jul 24, 2010 11:57 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Rather than a supposed gay bashing, it was an actual gay bashing. And it took place after UFC 115 outside a residence located very close to GM Place. We simply don’t know whether the bashers attended the event or not, since they haven’t been caught.
Even if these punks did attend UFC 115, the event itself shouldn’t be blamed, of course. But citizens are concerned about young men getting crazy after watching live MMA so it’s not that surprising there would be speculation about it.
by Emma May on Jul 25, 2010 12:15 AM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
Pretty sure I saw where they did catch the guys….. yep here is the article. The problem is the guys who were attacked made a big deal about the UFC event, they were the ones who blamed the fights for the attack in interviews and made a big fuss about the UFC.
Vancouver Police announced charges Thursday against four men in two separate attacks on gays in Vancouver’s downtown core in recent weeks.
Both attacks are being investigated as possible hate crimes, Const. Jana McGuinness said.
She said brothers Parminder (Peter) and Ravinder (Robbie) Bassi were arrested at their Richmond home Wednesday and charged with assault causing bodily harm in connection with the June 12 beating of partners David Holtzman and Peter Regier. Both victims, who were attacked outside their Keefer Street condo, suffered concussions, cuts and bruises.
And, McGuinness said, VPD members nabbed two other suspected gay bashers after a Davie Street assault early Thursday.
She said a 30-year-old man was walking with friends around 2:45 a.m. when they passed a group of men and women on the sidewalk.
“Suddenly one of the men from the group turned and verbally confronted the victim. Words were exchanged and without warning, the victim was allegedly punched in the face by his attacker, knocking him to the ground,” McGuinness said. “As he lay on the ground, the blows continued and a second man allegedly joined in, repeatedly punching the victim.”
She said “disturbing comments were made about the sexual orientation of the man as he was being punched.”
Two 21-year-old Vancouver men, Alexandre Tchernychev and Aaron Alexander Hahn, have been charged with assault causing bodily harm.
Neither man has a criminal record, though McGuinness said VPD have had dealings with both.
“The victims suffered facial injuries.” McGuinness said.
McGuinness said it is critical that the public continue to report hate crimes and to aid police in their investigations of them.
In the Holtzman-Regier case, McGuinness said police got many tips from the public, especially after video footage of the suspects was released June 18.
“It is so important that people get on the phone immediately and report these crimes to police,” she said.
“The arrests are coming because we are getting the support and help of the public and we have victims who are willing to report these crimes.”
Peter Bassi, 30, is charged with two counts of assault causing bodily harm, while younger brother Robbie, 27, is facing a single count. The brothers will appear in Vancouver community court July 5, McGuinness said. Neither has a criminal record.
“The public responded in an incredible way,” she said. “The investigators were able to identify these two men from the information that came in from the public.”
McGuinness said all the evidence gathered related to the attack being a hate crime has been forwarded to Crown. If accepted in court, it can become an aggravating factor at sentencing.
After the June 12 assault, the victims speculated that their attackers were likely at the Ultimate Fighting Championship event at GM Place that night.
But McGuinness said police have not been able to determine one way or the other if the brothers were in fact at the UFC match.
“So far, nothing has come to light to make that connection for us,” she said.
“We left no stone unturned. The investigators worked non-stop over the last two weeks and it involved a lot of interviews, including interviews with the two accused.”
Despite UFC 115 Success, Vancouver MMA Scene in Turmoil
As you may recall, much of the talk surrounding UFC 115 was whether the organization would ever return to Vancouver following its first show. High insurance rates and a lack of provincial support, led many to believe that until things changed for MMA in Western Canada, the UFC (or another professional organization, for that matter) would think long and hard before holding another event at GM Place or any other arena in British Columbia.
A month later, the MMA scene in Vancouver became a little hazier, as Vancouver Athletic Commission chairman Mirko Mladenovic, a supporter of MMA, was impeached and replaced by Dave Rudberg. Why was he fired? Well, The Vancouver Sun reported that “city staff and others complained about his conduct during the recent debate over allowing an Ultimate Fighting Championship event.”
Moreover, there is a growing concern among MMA supporters in Vancouver that the two-year trial period for MMA in Vancover, which began in December 2009, might expire with only one major MMA event ever taking place in the Olympic city.
No one has been covering this story better than The Score’s Paul Lazenby, and MMA Fighting spoke to the fighting analyst about some of the issues surrounding MMA in Vancouver and the sport’s future in Western Canada. The interview is below.
Ariel Helwani: Why was Mirko Mladenovic impeached?
Paul Lazenby: My impression is that Mirko was impeached for forcing the issue of the UFC through, and also for the fact that in spite of being a politically active person, he’s not all that politically correct. To be blunt, Mirko can be very abrasive and also very prone to forcing his own ideas upon people even when he doesn’t particularly know what he’s doing. I will always give him credit for championing the cause of MMA in Vancouver, but the guy stepped on many toes (mine included), and I’m not surprised that he’s been booted.
AH: Is the new chairman, Dave Rudberg, good or bad for MMA in Vancouver?
PL: I don’t know whether Dave Rudberg is going to be good or bad for MMA, but if what Mirko has said about Rudberg being a good friend of Licensing Department Assistant Director Tom Hammel is true, then we’re doomed, since Hammel was one of the primary opponents of MMA in this city during the fight to get UFC pushed through.
AH: Both Marc Ratner and Tom Wright have said that the UFC will only return to British Columbia if the sport is sanctioned provincially. Do you think that will happen any time soon?
PL: The provincial and municipal governments have been batting this issue back and forth for a long time now. I don’t dispute that having a provincial commission is the way to go, but it’s very frustrating to keep hearing that the province and city are each trying to pawn responsibility off on the other, resulting in the sport getting stuck in a quagmire. While we wait for the province to get its finger out of its a**, we could easily continue to run MMA events under VAC sanction as was previously (and successfully) done by World Freestyle Fighting, Elite Fighting Championships, bodogFIGHT, UFC and others.
AH: What, if any, backlash was there towards the UFC following last month’s event?
PL: The only backlash following UFC 115 is that of the Vancouver fanbase against the municipal government. The event couldn’t have gone better. I spoke with members of the Vancouver Police Department and they told me that there were no problems inside the arena, and nothing on the streets afterward that they wouldn’t have encountered on a normal Saturday night. However, city council is grasping at straws, trying to find anything negative to justify blocking further events. Councilor Kerry Jang said of an incident of gay-bashing that happened in the general vicinity of the arena: ‘There was an issue of a beating — unrelated to UFC, but the perception was there.’ In my opinion, the local government is going to continue with its old, cowardly practice of making excuses to conduct further ‘evaluations’ and ‘risk assessments’ so that they can back-burner MMA forever without ever having to actually say ‘no.’
AH: When do you think the UFC will return to Vancouver?
PL: No time soon, by the look of it. Until politicians put their personal bias/arrogance aside and let the actual facts about MMA dictate their actions, I won’t be holding my breath for any kind of professional mixed martial arts activity in Vancouver.
http://www.mmafighting.com/2010/07/15/vancouver-mma-scene-remains-in-turmoil/

by 


















