Why Blame Herschel Walker When MMA Itself Is a Freakshow?
I want to tell you about my perspective on Herschel Walker's involvement in MMA not as a fan, but as someone trying to embed themselves into the larger sports media in a top ten media market in the United States.
Initially I had little interest in any of Walker's MMA endeavors. I wasn't opposed to them per se, but adopted an insouciant attitude in anticipation of what I knew would be low-level MMA. Provided Coker treated Walker as the neophyte that he was (meaning his opponent was equally green), I didn't see any cause for acclaim or blame.
But then something strange happened.
Folks who never talk about MMA in the DC sports media establishment began to talk about it...to me. I started getting emails about Walker, reading columns about him and hearing him discussed on the radio. I started hearing them talk about it even in casual conversation. I got Twittered and Facebooked about it as well. Friends who never watch MMA even asked me about it. In fact, at a bar on a Sunday evening after the bout, I not only heard two patrons talking about the fight, but one asked the other whether they had read the article about his fight on CNN.com. UFC 100, for all its acclaim, never even came close. At least not in DC.
For those like me interested in moving the needle as it relates to MMA coverage in mainstream sports media establishments, Walker is a godsend. If I am to ask myself what I can do to grab the attention of editors at The Washington Post or producers at 106.7 The Fan, Walker is by far my best option. Why? Because we are talking MMA not on MMA's terms, but on their terms. We are introducing MMA into the discussion on grounds where they feel comfortable doing so. Some of you will object to that as retreating from a true image of MMA. I don't disagree entirely, but would only respond with the following: trying to convince them about the beauty of MMA on MMA's terms is infinitely more difficult than using a little carrot with the stick.
Based on my experience, the trick to getting people of power in traditional sports media to pay attention is not to shout them down for their bias or age. It's to view them as potential allies. It's to recognize the special nature of their power that would be of tremendous benefit to us. And, most importantly, it's about understanding how they view MMA. That informs our judgment about what we must do to alter their beliefs from the position from which they begin.
The MMA community often thinks of soft-handed freakshow fights as detrimental to the sport in the eyes of the casual observer. The reality is, when handled correctly, it has precisely the opposite effect.
All of this led, inevitably, to the most grotesque geek show of them all: the idea of pitting disparate styles against one another and mopping up the blood afterward. This is what is slightly ironic about MMA’s current attitude toward the sideshow: As a sport born from a circus atmosphere, it doesn’t leave itself much room for comment.
...
Rather than bemoan the oddities of combat sport, it might be more pragmatic to see how they act as fuel. When Carnera circulated, boxing had taken a nosedive after the departure of Jack Dempsey. Lump of nothing that he was, Carnera nonetheless reignited passion for prizefighting. The UFC of the 1990s was nauseating, but it self-corrected and evolved into something special. If it weren’t for the morbid curiosities of the paying public, Frye and White wouldn’t have jobs.
Anomalies continue to intrigue us. Brock Lesnar had a decorated career as an amateur wrestler, but did the hundreds of thousands of people buying his first few fights expect to see a clinical demonstration of a pin fall -- or a grunting man-rock tossing people over the cage padding? And didn’t the athletes appearing underneath Lesnar benefit financially from his participation? As a sponsor paying an athlete to wear your brand, do you want his ass-billboard on a card headlined by Lesnar, or by Thiago Silva?
The danger in criticizing the Herschel Walkers of the combat sports world is that it ignores the basic human interest story. We watch fights because we have an emotional investment in the outcome, and that investment is tenfold if the athletes participating have endeared themselves in other endeavors. If you grew up watching Walker play football, you’re probably going to be intent on seeing him fight. If Jean-Claude Van Damme actually has a muay Thai match -- as he’s alleged to have set up for later in the year -- he will attract a sizable number of people who can quote "Bloodsport" chapter and verse.
The lesson is not that all freakshows are created equal, but that over time products can be improved and palates refined. What begins as a mess often causes enough of a spark to eventually burn away the unessential and produce something of value. As Rossen correctly underscores, MMA itself in America began as a freakshow, but the melee of circus bouts and proposed alligator pits nevertheless homed in a core concept of hand-to-hand fighting that has matured, endured and blossomed into a sophisticated, respectable version of its former self.
MMA is viewed by many members of the traditional sports media as a freakshow. They can and often do have respect for its athletes and are conceptually aware MMA is a sport, but many have yet to emotionally commit to that idea. Whether or not Strikeforce, Walker and his fight with Nagy are the forces who are going to adjust those attitudes is certainly debatable (although with Walker's repeated defense of MMA, he makes a strong case for himself). What is not up for debate, however, is how celebrated figures who are historically revered by program directors, producers and editors across the sports media establishment have the unmatched ability to force aforementioned influencers to pay attention to MMA.That is not up for debate. I have witnessed it up close and personal and there isn't a Sengoku fight or fighter on the books that could even come close to matching the former Heisman Trophy winner's ability.
Will some of those influencers watch a Herschel Walker fight and leave with the impression MMA is little more than a freakshow even more reinforced in their minds? Probably. Some stalwarts cannot be budged. Most reasonable people, however, will begin to notice the differences. They'll notice some fighters are strikers, some are grapplers, some appear to be exceptional athletes and sometimes the action is riveting. And that's progress. A common mistake among hardcores is that in order to properly respect MMA one must become a hardcore fan him or herself. Not true. A little progress in the hands of the powerful is not to be scoffed at, and a little more coverage in the mainstream sports press helps MMA position itself alongside other traditional sports. And with that positioning comes more of the trimmings enjoyed by other sport's leagues that we all so desperately crave.
As we move forward, let us be mindful of our origin. We cannot surrender our standards and principles - those that have brought us closer to our self-identification as sport - for cheap entertainment that could undermine validity, but we must also be mindful of our evolution. We must be aware of how those in positions of power who can help us turn MMA into what we want it to be and where it needs to go can, over time, have their views adjusted. The recipe for change involves many ingredients, all of them both sufficient and necessary. But before we can demonstrate the potency of this dynamic sport, we have to have the most essential ingredient of them all: their attention.
Herschel Walker is no Fedor, but Fedor is no Herschel Walker.
8 recs |
36 comments
|
Comments
Walker has caused people that refused to even look at MMA…look at MMA. That’s good enough for me.
by HarmlessNinja on Feb 9, 2010 2:43 PM EST reply actions 4 recs
i’m fine with walker doing what he’s doing, and i don’t mind strikeforce using him as bait for mainstream sports fans. if anyone was blaming walker for anything they were wrong to do so. my personal problem with his debut was that the overall card was weak and didn’t offer much in terms of top tier talent. i think if you’re going to risk pissing off your regular fans with such a low level fight you better guarantee the rest of the card is so amazing that you’re pissed off regulars and you’re new mainstreamers want to stick around for what happens next. strikeforce may have done that to an extent, but they had the resources to do much better.
i think strikeforce dropped the ball, to an extent, on walker’s debut. but we as mma fans should embrace and educate the new fans the same way we did for brock’s fans and kimbo’s fans.
I’m not sure I agree. The Showtime card was basically free and other than the Lashley fight, the main card fights were exciting. All six of the fighters were mid to high level.
by HarmlessNinja on Feb 9, 2010 2:58 PM EST up reply actions
I agree Mr. Ninja
I watched the Strikeforce card with 7 other people that all seemed to enjoy the card. Maybe I’m a freak but I was very intrested in the Walker fight and I have been watching mma since UFC 1.
by KING FEDOR on Feb 9, 2010 3:11 PM EST via mobile up reply actions 1 recs
“a man who can pass a physical, can display a reasonable aptitude in the gym to defend himself and is understanding of the risk involved shouldn’t be the victim of elitist bashing.”
I totally agree with this. I never had a problem with Walker fighting, or even fighting a guy of equal or lesser ability. It just bothered me to see him placed so prominently on a card in his first fight, whereas a guy who was being built up for a title shot two fights ago was relegated to the prelims. Let’s not forget that Walker only looked as impressive as he did because his opponent was utterly hopeless.
If it helps Strikeforce in the long run then I suppose whatever works, works. I’m curious to see if those who tuned in to watch a 47 year old TKO a guy by punching him in the shoulder will do so next time when there are no “novelty” fights on the card.
Get rid of the ramp!
Agreed, and I wish guys like Jay Glazer would convey this to fans instead of mocking it.
Follow me on Twitter @lelandroling
"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe." - Albert Einstein
by Leland Roling on Feb 9, 2010 2:56 PM EST up reply actions
insouciant
Stop making me feel dumb, Luke.
by MMAInFeRioRiTy on Feb 9, 2010 2:55 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
Rec'd infinity
Herschel is the man…please don’t hate….every word that comes out of his mouth regarding our beloved sport is 100% respectful towards all of the athletes and the sport itself……..how could that ever hurt MMA’s image??
and maaan could that dude play football….
by NeilLomaxFan on Feb 9, 2010 2:58 PM EST reply actions 3 recs
I don't think anyone's ever questioned his attitude
I think a lot of people see signing novelty fights as a problem with Strikeforce, not with Walker’s desire to compete in MMA.
Walker has been nothing but a class act the whole time, IMO.
Get rid of the ramp!
let me go ahead and rec you, sir
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
I have no problems with Walker.
As a fan who wants to see good fights, it’s annoying when a fight like that is on the main card when it probably should be on the undercard, but I also understand why SF did what they did, and it makes sense. The more eyeballs on MMA, the better.
You have to be the man... you have to be very, like, alpha male with her. You know? Decide what you do and everything. So, show her who's the boss, you know? - GSP
If it can get more attention on the real stars of this sport I am all for it
Most of these guys that come in and can garner the big media attention will never be relevant in actual mma(top 25 in a weight class) save for Brock but in my eyes if Herschel Walker can get more people to see Nick Diaz or maybe later Fedor than I think it’s a good thing.
Same with Kimbo Slice I think if he can get more attention to a card that is headlined by the 2 best lhw’s in the world and more people get a chance to see Shogun and Machida it is a good thing.
I think its understandable. You feel emotionally invested, as the sport grows immensely in such a short period of time that investment grows too. In addition to this, the sport gets knocked from some quarters building a natural defensive mentality of trying to protect it and since its still a niche sport, the wish to see it prosper further. Yes, this can mean they lose sight of where they came from, but I think its more to do with where they want it to go.
by -Sam on Feb 9, 2010 3:16 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
can help us turn MMA into what we want it to be and where it needs to go
What do we want MMA to turn into? This is an honest question.
I am. I think. I will. - Ayn Rand
It seems “we” want mma to be the next poker or nascar…Sell the sport out for ratings and viewers, be a fad, then start to fall off but by then “we” will be able to claim mma was popular and mainstream for a time and everyone still knows about it, even if the sport becomes a joke…
basically just like all sports, baseball owners let players use roids/HGH because it sold tickets, hockey changed rules so more goals would be scored and brought in the post OT shootout so there is always a winner (which apparently we in America “need”). NFL changed rules so QB’s can’t even be touched now, unless of course it helps the Saints win because that’s a good story so they are allowed to kill Favre. Also don’t let defense’s actually play defense. NBA stopped calling traveling and has let the sport turn into a one and one game, as opposed to a team sport. MLS changed all their salary cap rules to allow LA to sign Beckham, and not only that, their other star player Landon Donovan was only the cap as well and MLS said fuck it, it’s LA, we’ll let them have 2 players over the cap and just makeup rules on the go as long as we get viewers and ratings. Nascar went away from old tracks and schedule, changed qualifying, has FOX making a mockery of the sport with its “coverage”, changed the cars, changed the way the championship is won, all things hardcore nascar fans hate. But it brought ratings and money, which is what everything in sports is about now. Hell, FIFA allowed France to blatantly cheat to qualify for the World Cup because they wanted France to be in the tournament.
“Profits are important but the sport must take precedence over the business” – Pete Rozelle said that in the days, before I was born, when apparently sports were sports, and legit sporting contests.
mma as it is, is basically the purist sport left in the World, and that’s with all the flaws of freakshows, officiating, judging, promoters, etc…but still, with two opponents, one and one, it’s the purest form of sport, the day will inevitably come when the sport is sold out for money/profits, but just as I still watch all the other sports I listed above, even though I hate what they’ve become, I’ll always watch mma…just hope that people don’t push to have the sport sold out quicker than it needs to be
How many folks watched this “freak show” but act as if they are above it. If it really is above these mma" purist "they could always turn the tv off or leave the room while Walker was fighting. This is similar to complain about the rubbernecking at an accident when your stuck in traffic the tapping your brakes when you get to the accident to take a look
by KING FEDOR on Feb 9, 2010 3:28 PM EST via mobile reply actions
I was disinterested in the fight
because I have no vested emotion in Walker and didn’t care about his opponent. I loved the Super HLUK tournament. Quite frankly, I want to see Semmy Schilt vs. Stefan Struve for tallness, style matchup, and alliteration.
"Someone is WRONG on the internet. What do you want me to do? LEAVE? Then they'll keep being wrong!"
-Randall Munroe
by pdl on Feb 9, 2010 3:33 PM EST up reply actions
At what point do we as MMA fans accept that MMA will never be an American past-time.....
There is alot of talk in the MMA community regarding the future of MMA and its place in mainstream sports. This is taken to the extreme by Dana Whites persistent desire and dedication to make the UFC the #1 sports medium in the country/world etc… While I respect this ambition and hope one day it comes true; do any of you really think this will ever happen? I for one consider myself a huge fan of MMA and follow the majority of promotions out there, but I really believe that MMA has gone about as “mainstream” as it is going to go. I hope this is not the case but its my honest opinion. As a whole, society just does not accept blood sports as an acceptable form of entertainment these days. Some people just don’t want to see people beating each other up, cut up and bleeding all over the place a’la penn vs. diego. In conclusion, I’ve tried for the past 4 years to get my close friends interested in UFC fights and MMA in general, but unless I buy the pay per view myself or we go somewhere to watch the event (and beer is available) they really just don’t care. These guys all love football, basketball, baseball etc… but MMA is just not on their radar. Also, I personally love everything about Herschel Walker’s venture in to MMA so far, and hope he continues for another couple of fights. Like others have said before, I had my dad and other friends calling me asking about Walker and his fight etc.. It was pretty cool talking about MMA to people that either had no idea what it was, or had a general negative opinion about it before.
by lovernotafighter on Feb 9, 2010 3:35 PM EST reply actions
agreed a sport based on a ppv scale will never be accepted by the american public
network tv is the future of the ufc not ppvs
ppvs give the ufc a nice profit now but the sport has just about reached it max of where it can go on the ppv format
ppvs suck for fans cause they make them pay such a huge amount of money for sporting event and in my opinion it was ppvs that killed boxing especially when they ran out of draws in the heavyweight diivision after tyson and lewis quit
im hoping the ufc on versus card is a intro to getting the ufc on nbc the vs card is stacked and should draw huge amounts of viewers
I’ll admit I was against Herschel Walker being allowed to fight. That was only because of his age and past medical history. In his first few interviews after announcing a foray into MMA he didn’t seem to get it. I didn’t think he understood what it took to compete in MMA seriously and with his age and mental health issues I was worried about the precedent it would be setting to sanction guys like him to fight.
Now come fight time and the week leading up to it he really impressed me with the interviews he did. He sounded more articulate about the sport and quite frankly put it in a good light about the safety of competing in MMA as compared to other sports. So I felt better about him being allowed to fight. Still worried about him getting KO’d and suffering a concussion but as long as he is passing strict medical physicals by Athletic Commissions then I’m not against it any more.
Just BE.
Herschel has never had a problem competing on this highest stages the world of sports has to offer, why would you think he wouldn’t take the sport seriously? even the most brief of looks into Herschel’s past would tell anyone that he’s just a weird dude with phenomenal athletic ability. He takes competition extremely seriously and won’t do anything if it’s going to make him look foolish.
What is a godsend is both the way Walker was looked upon before MMA and the way he handled the attention. Jose didn’t carry the same weight because he lacked both the rep preceding him and the attitude going in. Even my father looks up to Walker because he is such a specimen. No weight training was something he preached to me as a kid because of Walker. “You don’t need it” he said. Then Walker carrying himself as a realistic humble first timer did wonders to win me over. Training at AKA, taking a reasonable fight. Coming in looking good. It wasn’t anywhere near the freakshow it could have been. People that don’t know a thing about MMA know Walker as an athlete that could have competed at a high level in any sport.
Some people think I am a dumb, ugly human being, but really I am a beautiful ape, with exceptional verbal skills.
by szucconi on Feb 9, 2010 3:55 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
Herschel is my hero.
I’m so glad people have started to take this stance, though. It’s the same thing with a whole lot of different subjects, as I’ve noted before, that for some damn reason the MMA “hardcores” like to draw a line in the sand and demand that you stand on one side.
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Feb 9, 2010 4:23 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
So
Nobody should complain about Kimbo anymore either.
"I will do nothing lightly. When I walk, I will walk heavily. When I fight, I will fight with conviction. When I speak, I will speak strongly. When I love, I will love with everything"
Most people’s issue with Kimbo was how EliteXC was booking him as their main event and trying to feed him too us as something he obviously wasn’t. Strikeforce definately didn’t push Walker in that manner or book him to headline over multiple title fights.
by who me on Feb 9, 2010 5:00 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
The real tell on this will be if any these people who paid attention to this due to Walker’s involvement actually tune into an event he isn’t on now. The object here seemed to be to use Walker’s fame to bring in new viewers but if Walker’s fans don’t transfer over to the sport in a significant way then really what did it accomplish? Guys like Lesnar and Kimbo do huge numbers but they also have helped bring up the sport in general in terms of viewership and exposure too, it remains to be seen if Walker will have that kind of effect for Strikeforce. He may be a game changer or his fight may just of been a human interest story for aging football fans, we really don’t know yet. One thing Walker does have going for him in this regard is that he does show a hell of a lot of respect for the sport.
There is a fine line to walk in doing these kinds of fights. Heck you can look at how Strikeforce handled Walker and Lashley as two separate sides of this. I’m pretty sure no matter how anyone feels about Walker in MMA, it was obvious which fight on that card was the actual freakshow.
by who me on Feb 9, 2010 4:52 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Your concerns sell MMA short
in the sense that they imply MMA itself may not have enough merit to appeal to average football fans who tune in. MMA is very relatable to football fans, and I have no doubts thousands of people saw this fight and the event around it and will be interested in seeing more.
It is my belief that MMA is a sport great enough that nearly any attraction that brings eyeballs in is a good thing.
Its not about merit at all, it’s about the fact that you just can’t expect that getting people to sit down and watch a little bit of MMA will transfer into automatic fandom from them. It’s not that I am saying more eyeballs is a bad thing, it’s just that doesn’t automatically equate to this actually meaning anything or changing anything for the sport. We won’t know the effects Walker had until we get down the road and see.
ya, but we can make some safe assumptions.
I am a football fan, you’re probably a football fan, in fact most(Americans) reading this on some level is probably a football fan. Now if this were say, Pete Sampras or someone who brings in a more, for lack of a better word, cultured audiance, then maybe we’d have room for skepticism, but in general “football fan” is your average everyday beer drinking American everyman, and this is just the kind of demographic to instantly relate to MMA. The guys who like Bloodsport and Rocky movies, used to watch Tyson, and are the reason banal action run of the mill flicks like Taken were so well respected and why Superhero explosion fests continue to rake in gagillions of dollars.
Men punching eachother is an easy sell to these guys. I promise.
by Wolfgangsta on Feb 11, 2010 11:42 AM EST up reply actions
I can understand someone being concerned about MMA appearing as a “freak show”. Especially concerning things that have happened in the past, some unwanted crossover in appearance with Pro-wrestling and the actual freak shows that are booked.
But Hershel Walker took the sport seriously and came in as skilled as he could considering and in damn good shape to fight. He might not be a title contender, but he doesn’t pretend to be. He was also helping out charity and was bringing positive attention to MMA.
"A champion is someone who gets up when he can't." - Jack Dempsey
Luke's best article ever.
great stuff.
I have been arguing the value of a Jose Canseco vs Hershel Walker fighter under this same rationale. MMA was already a freakshow to the mainstream “human cockfighting” singing Tony Kornheisers of the world, and this potential fight wouldn’t make or break that perception with anyone, but what it would do is move the needle tremendously in the sports world, like no other fight before it.
MMA fans around here puke in their mouth at the idea of these two fighting, but what most don’t understand is how stronglythe entire sports world despises Jose Canseco. This fight provides the perfect scenario where sports media and the American public at large to become emotionally invested in an MMA bout. Walker is the perfect hero. Canseco the perfect villian.
Jim Rome, the Inside the NFL crew and Sportscenter crew already acknowledged that Jose is just doing this as a cashgrab and isn’t serious, while Walker is serious about the sport. That premise would be largely understood by the viewing public going in. That would lessen the full on “freakshow” feel to the fight. Canseco would be transparently seen for the jerk that he is.
If promoted right, on a card with Fedor, the best in the world, and entertaining strikers like Le and Manhoef, a fight like this would expose more people to legitimate mixed martial arts(note – not “ultimate fighting”) and the merits of the sport would do the rest. This would instantly generate huge amounts of coatail press for Strikeforce, Fedor, MMA and help break the UFC brand stranglehold that holds the sport down.
No one can deny the warm and fuzzy feeling in the bellys of the millions of viewers the world over that would result from Walker standing over a battered and bruised Jose Canseco.
Maybe that feeling would be enough to keep them coming back for more?

by 





![Strikeforce Diaz vs Noons 2 poster:
Nick Diaz vs KJ Noons [WW Title]
Sarah Kaufman vs Marloes Coenen [135 lbs Title]
Matt Lindland vs Luke Rockhold
"JZ" Cavalcante vs Josh Thomson [Rumored]
This Fan Shot was promoted to the front page by Nick Thomas.
Strikeforce: San Jose coverage](http://cdn3.sbnation.com/fan_shot_images/140245/san_jose_oct9_670x169_small.jpg)













