TUF 9 Finale Review
Event as a whole: B+
Since it was on cable: A
Dollar actually surprised me a bit taking it to Dent throughout the entire first round. Dent was FAR from impressive on the show and guys like Mark Miller and Richie Whitson seem more deserving of a shot in the UFC in my opinion. Dollar's inexperience cost him this fight as he should have continued his over-aggressive striking assault.
Dent: Needs to train hard and improve his striking. Next opponent - UFC newcomer or Rob Emerson
Dollar: Needs experience outside of the UFC before coming back. Or Roli Delgado
Nick Osipczak vs. Frank Lester
Lester is a true fighter with the heart of a lion. His skills simply do not match his heart yet. Osi was decent on the show and this was an even match-up which slightly favored him because he's more well-rounded and technically sound. Lester actually did well in scrambles and obviously worked on his game since the show. The better fighter won, though, and Nick used one stright punch and knee to set up the RNC.
Osipczak: I underestimated him coming in. He belongs in the UFC at the bottom of the chain and needs more experience. Next - Newcomer or Peter Sobotta
Lester: Heart can only take you so far. Needs fights out of the UFC.
Mike Ciesnolevicz vs. Tomasz Drwal
Not much to say here. Basically a meaningless fight as Mike C missed weight and both guys lacked intensity. I'm not sure why Drwal was going for takedowns when he had a big advantage striking. Either way Mike C looked uninspired (or injured) and eventually got hurt and finished in the first. Drwal was one of my favorite prospects, but he still has failed to deliver 100%.
Mike C: Don't know what was wrong tonight. Just an off night or injured? Next - Eliot Marshall
Drwal: Up the ladder a bit even though it wasn't overly impressive. Next - Eric Schafer
Brad Blackburn vs. Edgar Garcia
Really close fight. Round 1 Garcia, Round 2 Blackburn, Round 3 ??. Blackburn usually starts out nicely and fades. He has obviously worked his cardio and it helped him in this one. I was surprised Garcia chose to stand and strike with Blackburn. What surprised me even more was Garcia actually getting the better of it some of the time. Either way - it was a good fight for both guys and they both will be back.
Garcia - Deserves a win and should get someone he can beat. Next - Jesse Sanders or newcomer.
Blackburn - Who would have expected him to be 3-0 in the UFC? He was on a roll later in the IFL and has evolved as a fighter. His main weakness is the fact that opponents ALWAYS know his gameplan. Next - Marcus Davis (sweet huh?)
Melvin Guillard vs. Gleison Tibau
As much as Rogan and the crowd disliked the Blackburn decision - I have to say this one was much more questionable....and by questionable I mean total garbage. I'm not a fan of either guy and expected a good fight. What we got was a stalemate and a robbery. Both guys surely deserve to be in the UFC - this was just an unfortunate dud.
Tibau - A threat to everyone in the division when he is on. Next - Mark Bocek
Guillard - If he can fend off a guy like Tibau this much and actually land his shots - he is always dangerous. Next - Thiago Tavares
Very entertaining fight that was a must win for Daddy. His spot in the UFC was not in jeopardy after the losses to Florian, Sanchez, and Penn. All it did was prove he is not top 4-5 in the UFC yet. He finally changed camps and added to his game and it showed tonight. He dominated early and faded the last minute or so. Diaz was too content and patient on his back. Stevenson isn't one to usually make fatal mistakes unless he is gassed or hurt. Diaz did nothing to hurt Joe and was just the worse fighter that night.
Diaz - Two fight losing streaks are bad - it will take 4 in a row to get him the boot though. Next - Terry Etim
Stevenson - Back on track and better than ever with Jackson behind him. Climbing the ladder again. Next - Joe Lauzon/Cole Miller
Neither guy excited me too much coming into the fight and neither guy overly impressed me coming out. It wasn't the most entertaining fight and it wasn't terrible. It was just overshadowed by other fights after it. Unless they evolve I don't see either guy making too much of a push at 155.
Winner: As much as I dogged him, he deserves another chance. He has skills and needs to put it all together. Next - Junie Browning
Pearson: Tough guy who looked pretty well rounded. He is nowhere near ready to be thrown to the wolves. He is a TUF winner who needs to be brought along slowly. Next - George Roop
On paper this fight was to be a barn burner. It delivered 100% and was just a sneak peak at the great things to come later in the night. Rogan said it best calling this a "Chris Lytle type of fight". That's all that needs to be said. Burns is a warriors and would have had this fight had he not gassed out in the second. Props to both guys - it was a pleasure to watch.
Burns - Guy has serious skills and needs to work on cardio a bit. Next - Rory Markham
Lytle - Put him against anyone and it will be entertaining for sure. Next - Ben Saunders
Damarques Johnson vs. James Wilks
While this fight did not go the way I thought it would, it was still fun to watch while it lasted. Johnson showcased a good chin and a lot of heart hanging on as long as he did after being hurt. Wilks absolutely upped his game and trained hard and to me is the best prospect of the season by the looks of it. I completely underestimated his skills and look forward to seeing him in action in the UFC.
Johnson - A fan favorite and exciting fighter. Needs an easy fight. Next - Newcomer or Jonathan Goulet.
Wilks - Can't say enough about him. Impressed me to no end. Next - Newcomer or Ricky Story
On paper this is a fight of the year candidate. On screen this was a complete freak show that I couldn't turn away from. Oh, and that was before the fight even began. The first round was fireworks and was already passed all expectations. Round 2 slowed a bit, but also evened up the fight more. Round 3 was good and picking a winner was nearly impossible. Sanchez did more damage and was more aggressive with sub attempts and strikes and was close to finishing the fight at one point. I think he clearly deserved the win.
Guida - What hasn't been said? Iron chin and a warrior even though he looks to control fights without finishing. Next - Tyson Griffin II?
Sanchez - If he can get his weight cutting perfected he will be a monster at 155. I don't think he is 100% ready for a title shot, but he will likely get it. Next - Frankie Edgar or winner of Penn/Florian.
Flame on, or agree. Whatever floats your boat. Excuse typos and whatnot.
The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.
0 recs |
13 comments
Comments
I would give this event a thumbs up but the horrible decision in the main event, left me with a sour taste. This is back to back Fight Nights in which a guy has been robbed they have to start doing something about these judges they are costing guys money and fame by not knowing how to score fights.
by Raker on Jun 21, 2009 2:53 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Are you open to the possibility that someone other than you saw a fairly even striking exchange in the third round followed by Sanchez just missing getting Guida’s back and keeping him in a kimura position for the rest of the round without Guida being able to do anything?
Couldn’t that lead to a close 29-28 score for Sanchez? And with the first round verging on 10-8 a 29-27 score for Sanchez?
"Japan panics about the rise of "grass-eating men," who shun sex, don’t spend money, and like taking walks."
Did they all get married?
- Ubernoober
by SamCupitt on Jun 21, 2009 4:34 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
that would ignore Clay geting the takedown and landing some strikes from the top to finish off the round, there is almost no way to see that third round for Diego imo. Also the for someone to give out a 10-8 you better dominate the entire round, Sanchez didn’t Clay took him down in the first and gnp him and survived and returned fire the rest of the round. Is it possible for someone to have honestly scored it for Diego sure, but after seeing it a second time to me it’s clear just how badly Guida was robbed.
by Raker on Jun 21, 2009 5:06 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I don’t know if he was robbed Guida’s ground and pound wasn’t exactly devastating and at one point Diego was doing way more damage from his back I wouldn’t have argued with a draw though. I think this fight showed that Florian vs. Sanchez 2 is going to be nothing like the first fight.
by drano on Jun 21, 2009 5:24 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I've watched the fight three times now
And I give the decision to Sanchez, FOR SURE. In fact, I was SHOCKED that one judge scored the fight in Guida’s favor. Love the Carpenter and everything he brings to the Octagon but Diego won that fight.
V-I-K-I-N-G-S! Skol Vikings, Let's Go!!
by TheViking83 on Jun 22, 2009 7:38 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
(Demarcus) Johnson – A fan favorite and exciting fighter.
He’s a fan favorite? When did that happen?
by mythbuster on Jun 21, 2009 11:51 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
When he became the only USA member to make it to the finals. I was at the show and it baffled me as well.
by xposipx on Jun 21, 2009 12:56 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I see your point
However, they were chanting U.S.A., not De-Mar-cus ;)
by mythbuster on Jun 21, 2009 9:00 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Both fighters are American =P
A man should never waste an opportunity to keep his mouth shut.
by iiowyn on Jun 22, 2009 10:06 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Who has chosen to become an American citizen and has served in the US Military. He is both British and American.
A man should never waste an opportunity to keep his mouth shut.
by iiowyn on Jun 22, 2009 12:26 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Did he become a citizen?
I did not know that.
by mythbuster on Jun 22, 2009 12:36 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs















