Can Frank Mir Do It Again?
via media.ufc.tv
I have always been a big fan of Frank Mir (12-3-0) even in some of his matches I didn't think he would win. He has one of the best ground games in the heavyweight division. And for a big guy has always looked very impressive in BJJ.
Since starting his MMA career, Mir has only had two fights outside the UFC. His first two. Mir won a decision over Jerome Smith at a HooknShoot in his pro debut. In his second he submitted Dan Quinn via triangle choke. Then the UFC picked him up and he's been here every since.
Mir has submitted 6 of his opponents. Of these 6, Brock Lesnar (3-1-0) has lasted the longest at 1:30 of the first round. Only two of his fights have went past the 2nd round (Jerome Smith and Dan Christison) both of which he won by decision. The three he lost have all been by TKO.
Mir has never been submitted and has fought a total of 45.5 minutes in his 13 fight UFC career that spans seven and a half years. WOW! Thats an average of 3.5 minutes per fight.
Lesnar's 3 fights in the UFC have lasted a total of 24.5 minutes. An average of 8.16 minutes per fight. If Lesnar makes it to his 13th fight for the UFC (which I doubt he will) how much more time will he rack up? I know this really has nothing to do with their ability (except maybe finishing ability) but still Mir has been very impressive.
So, to answer my own question "Can Frank Mir Do It Again? " I have to say that I 100% beleive LESNAR WILL TAP!!!
If you don't think Mir will win then how will Lesnar beat him?
The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.
67 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I want Mir to win, but in regards to this question, it depends on how much Brock has improved
As a person who trains in MMA (striking and BJJ to be specific), I know first-hand how much size and strength plays. I am only 155 lbs, and the other day I was rolling with gi with someone who was 90 lbs more than me. Needless to say, my partner was able to pass my guard with ease just using strength (effortlessly pushing down on one of my knees while I was in full guard to break the guard). He also effortlessly benchpressed me off of him when I had side-mount. However, with Mir being a legit Blackbelt, that experience goes A LONG WAY in BJJ. It is all about feeling (and that experience just strengthens those stabilizer muscles), and Mir most likely can feel when he has something (on the ground) whether it be an arm, leg, or neck. Of course with strikes added in, it is a whole different story. It comes down to Brock’s growth though, and Brock’s size alone can compensate for much of his inexperience.
also
the size difference betwen lesnar and Mir isn’t that big. Mir usually comes in at 240 or so. Say Lesnar weighs 280 on fight night (having cut to 265) his size advantage isn’t that significant.
I think he’ll have a significant strength advantage but it’s a long way from your experience with the 240lb guy who you trained with.
Too true
Obviously, Lesnar is not 90 lbs more than Mir. And like I said, the difference from a BJJ Blackbelt to (I’m guessing here) Brock Lesnar, who I am guessing is a blue belt, is a huge difference. However, this is MMA and not pure BJJ. Nonetheless, I honestly see this fight ending in Mir submitting Lesnar. Lesnar is dangerous on the feet as far as power, but he does not have the technique (Mir’s technique on the feet isn’t the best in the division, but he has more experience in martial arts in general compared to Lesnar). I can honestly see Lesnar going back to his strongest point in his wrestling and taking down Mir. From there I can see Mir submitting Lesnar. Obviously, this is only how I imagine the fight to go, and the actual fight can go much differently.
by chrisbboy82 on Apr 24, 2009 12:32 AM EDT up reply actions
Lesnar’s BJJ coach says he’s a purple belt.
by Derek Suboticki on Apr 24, 2009 2:19 AM EDT up reply actions
True.
But I think he’s training under Rodrigo Medeiros, so I think it’s safe to say that it’s a legit purple belt. Plus, add his wrestling and physical abilities, and you have a very solid grappler. Not too hard to imagine that in the 3 years he’s been training that he’s a purple belt by now.
My Jiu Jitsu teacher (Cameron Diffley from Legion BJJ, Team Forrest BJJ coach on TUF: Griffin v. Page) has always said that wrestlers already have a huge leg up on other newcomers to the sport, because they already have takedowns, understand leverage, and know how to put/ keep your weight on an opponent.
The only question is whether or not Brock’s submission defense, as well as top control/ GnP is advanced enough to avoid getting caught in a leglock/ armlock/ choke/ etc.
I think the real X factor in this fight is the standup- who will take control of it, and if Brock starts losing in the striking game, whether or not he can get Mir down without being subbed.
I, for one, am very intrigued by this matchup.
Supporting all Las Vegas MMA.
'09 is the year of the FW's.
by ElliotMatheny on Apr 26, 2009 8:57 PM EDT up reply actions
I agree that Lesnar’s size advantage tends to be overblown. Mir has faced plenty of big guys. What he hasn’t faced is big guys who move like Lesnar.
Lesnar’s size is nothing special. There are lots of big powerful guys in MMA. It is his speed and quickness, coming from a 280 pound body, that is special. The guy moves like a cat.
Lesnar can't lose
If he wins, he wins.
If he loses, it will be someone else’s fault (for example, the referee).
Mir trains with Maia. Thus, anything is possible.
Lesnar should win. Simple as that. And I kinda hope he does. You need that unbeatable force at Heavyweight, no matter what the sport.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
There already is an unbeatable force at HW.
This guy

Supporting all Las Vegas MMA.
'09 is the year of the FW's.
by ElliotMatheny on Apr 26, 2009 9:00 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
This one is really hard to call. Lesnar has mad potential but right now I think Mir is the better all-around fighter, has much more experience, and has been through much more adversity. Also, this may be nitpicky, but Randy was doing a very good job against Brock before he got knocked out. Yes, Brock won the fight and he deserves credit for it but he did not like being popped in the face AT ALL. Randy was bringing it and some people have found it convenient to forget that. I think Mir should come out aggressive like he did against Nogueira and like Randy did against Brock. And it’s funny because people are acting like Brock won the first fight. Controversy or not, Brock tapped. It should still be a very interesting fight.
Randy was doing a very good job against Brock before he got knocked out.
What fight were you watching? Randy had like one good moment and that was it. Brock was basically just walking right through him the entire time.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
Randy was manhandling Brock up against the cage – and yes Randy did tag him the face a few times.
"My job is a decision-making job, and as a result, I make a lot of decisions." --George W. Bush, The Decider, Lancaster, Pa., Oct. 3, 2007
There’s a huge difference between “manhandling” and “clinching”. Randy was clinching, not manhandling. Randy hit him clean about five times and none of it mattered to Brock. It was whatever to him.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
I could ask you the same thing. Brock won the fight decisively but to act like it Randy wasn’t even competitive is just wrong. Couture was much more competitive than Herring and aside from the final result, Mir as well. And the beef many people have with Brock is not that he was in the WWE (although you know as well as I do that if he wasn’t such a big wrestling draw, he wouldn’t have had anywhere near the push he received when he signed with the UFC). It’s that he has all of this hype as an unbeatable monster but if you watch any of his four fights, that isn’t what comes across in the cage. I see a guy with loads of potential and that’s about it. In my opinion, it’s the BJ syndrome in that most of his mystique is built upon what he’s capable of doing or what he could do as opposed to what he has actually done. Mir’s beaten him before I haven’t seen anything from Lesnar to suggest it can’t happen again.
Can you imagine Brock putting you in a rear naked choke…. You would disappear and if he squeezes hard your head will probably just pop off.
You would disappear and if he squeezes hard your head will probably just pop off.
That or you’d just shit yourself so bad he’d rip your head due to your bodily fluids making contact with his greatness.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
by FlyByKnight on Apr 23, 2009 1:06 PM EDT up reply actions 3 recs
I don’t understand. This post deserves recs.
One vote for green.
Spinning out solid gold, like Rumpelstiltskin.
Not gonna
"My job is a decision-making job, and as a result, I make a lot of decisions." --George W. Bush, The Decider, Lancaster, Pa., Oct. 3, 2007
by lovingmma25 on Apr 24, 2009 10:21 AM EDT up reply actions
This one ain’t getting out of the 1st one way or another. I’ve got Brock by TKO.
Keep firing Assholes!
Akiyama is the Japanese word for Sexify.
i second that
I'm the kind of girl who loves to watch a GOOD fight!
--------
Join the DC Area UFC Meetup Group
http://www.meetup.com/DCUFCGroup
Ditto
"I see him beating Anderson Silva. I see him picking him apart. Him at a 131 years old...(trails off)." - Tito on Belfort at Affliction:DOR
by Rundownloser on Apr 23, 2009 1:48 PM EDT up reply actions
DAMN
Lots of people think he’ll tap again… I don’t see it. I see a TKO victory for Brock. No reason he would make the same mistake
Probably not.
It’s a fight – things can happen. But I have Brock eating a Mir punch and turning into a counter that puts Mir’s head into the third row.
by Derek Suboticki on Apr 23, 2009 4:13 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
This is the page I am on.
Over hand right from Lesnar. Mir feeling like he is underwater until ref. stoppage. Lesnar 1st round TKO.
"Stop smiling you are about to be punched in the face !"
People like Fly who constantly support Brock Lesnar, saying things like how “legit” he is need to come clean that they’re WWE fans and admit that they’re secretly thrilled that the same guy who was F5ing people like the Rock is now a UFC champion.
“Nuh-uh, he’s legit man. NCAA heavyweight champ, great athlete, ton of potential- when he’s more experienced will be better than Fedor…”
No dude, he’s a very good wrestler, a huge man and an outstanding athlete – that is what has propelled him to where he is now. Of course he is learning to be proficient in other disciplines but is unlikely to ever have great standup or beautiful submissions; he’s a beast with a smothering top game and massive power, and that’s fucking hard to deal with – particularly in the HW’s where the weight class covers such a wide weight range.
And don’t overstate his accomplishments. He beat Heath Herring, a guy who was beaten soundly by Jake O’Brien who also took him down for three rounds and ground and pounded him – only Jake is about 45 pounds lighter and a less accomplished wrestler on paper. He then beat Randy, and while Randy is a great fighter who used his technical skills pretty well in that fight (like pressing Brock against the fence, neutralising a lot of his power, and getting up from a takedown without taking damage) he was unable to find his range standing and ended up getting knocked out by an arguably lucky punch. In any event, Brock could have been in the WWE without any MMA experience and it still would have been a difficult fight for Randy fighting the much larger, stronger wrestler.
“Whatever dude, you can hate him but he’s gonna be unbeatable when he learns Jiu Jitsu and standup”.
Nope. He’s going to be a tough opponent – that’s clear. For fuck sake, Mark Coleman who is 44, miles past his best, and has no cardio, had a very legitimate chance at beating Shogun in their most recent fight. It doesn’t matter that Shogun was out of shape; it was clear that a fighter who has elite wrestling and is savvy about submissions is going to be tough because they’re going to control where the fight goes, but that is it. Brock has phenomenal physical gifts, but take his nuts out of your mouth and get off the hype train; Randleman was certainly no less the athlete but clearly he wasn’t unbeatable.
Brock will probably beat Mir this time. He controls where the fight goes, will almost certainly gain top position, and can stay in Frank’s guard and brutalise Mir with ground and pound. People who assume Frank will catch him don’t realise how difficult that is going to be from a practical perspective. Further down the line, if Brock faces strikers who aren’t accomplished wrestlers in their own right he’s going to take them down and ground and pound them. But don’t act like it’s more than it is. Brock is just proof that particularly at heavyweight, where most people can’t match his size, let alone his athleticism, a big wrestler, who has power and is a great athlete, only needs passable skills in BJJ and striking in order to be a dominant fighter.
by wrens on Apr 23, 2009 6:35 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
It worked for Matt Hughes. He was considered a huge welterweight with the exact same skillset (less some of the punching power).
Spinning out solid gold, like Rumpelstiltskin.
That was before fighters were more well rounded, to be fair
Brad Ziegler had a scoreless inning streak. Brad Ziegler had not met BJ Upton.
There aren't really any 'rounded' HWs though
Obviously there’s Fedor. But I mean within the UFC there aren’t any really rounded heavyweight.s
In every division the only really well-rounded fighters are the champs plus one or two of the top contenders. I.e. WW – GSP, Jon Fitch, Josh Koscheck?, Mike Swick are pretty rounded.
LW – BJ Penn, Kenny Florian, Diego Sanchez
So you’re basically saying he’s just a huge, athletic wrestler with power. I have no problem with that.
by Derek Suboticki on Apr 23, 2009 7:09 PM EDT up reply actions
^this
Brock can be dominant in the HW division (or Carwin) simply because of his excellent wrestling base. Honestly the person who has the best chance against Brock right now is Mir because stylistically Mir is the worse thing for Brock. Someone who routinely submits much bigger people from guard.
But Brock has loads of potential and he will be a force for the next 5 years or so.
I’d like to add that Coleman did not have a full training camp for his last fight either
"My job is a decision-making job, and as a result, I make a lot of decisions." --George W. Bush, The Decider, Lancaster, Pa., Oct. 3, 2007
by lovingmma25 on Apr 24, 2009 10:23 AM EDT up reply actions
Don't get me wrong...
I am glad you all liked my post and want to discuss it, but do we have to have the BE on BE crime?
Dude, I get suckerpunched every time Lesnar comes up. No worries.
by Derek Suboticki on Apr 23, 2009 8:39 PM EDT up reply actions
Anything can happen but Lesnar can’t become a world class MMA grappler in a matter of months. I’m sure he’s improved but he doesn’t have any advantage in this fight that he didn’t in the previous. I think Mir will do a good job keeping the fight in the feet for a round or so, use his kicks to keep Lesnar at bay, and then in the mid to later rounds he will work the takedown and get a top-side submission.
LOL at this analysis. Mir will avoid TDs by kicking Lesnar? That’s an awful gameplan. And later, Mir will take Lesnar down and sub him from the top?
If Mir trades with Lesnar, he will find out quickly he doesn’t like getting hit with Lesnar’s power. Throwing lots of leg kicks will get Mir taken down repeatedly, and Mir will not take Lesnar down.
Of these 2 guys, it’s Lesnar who’s shown the better cardio in a longer fight.
Kicking a guy is the LAST thing you want to do if your goal is to avoid takedowns.
Mr. Shark tried that on Lesnar and Brock simply caught the kick, took him down, and pounded the shit out of him. Ditto for Cro Cop versus Gonzaga. One of the primary drawbacks of kicks is that they leave you very vulnerable to takedowns.
Am I the only one who had never even heard the name Brock Lesnar before his first MMA fight was announced?
no evil, i never heard of brock lesnar before his mma schtick. i think he could win cause hes a big powerful MAyawn, but experience goes a loooooooong way
good luck in life!
Experience does go a long way, which is why Mir won the first time. However, a green noob to the MMA game also made that same experienced fighters face look like a truck hit it. Now fast forward to today, where that same noob is going to be much more composed and not be as likely to leave himself open to an easily captured submission.
I hate Frank Mir, and hope Brock knocks his ass completely out…….I don’t want to see a TKO.
Whats with asking "whats with the (insert name here) hate?" questions on here lately?
I’ve seen Maia, Paulo Thiago, Lesnar, Koscheck…… why do people care why people may hate these guys?
Just curious…
by Gunslinger20 on Apr 24, 2009 7:50 AM EDT up reply actions
I don’t mind confident, even cocky people….but in my eyes Mir gives off a smugness in whatever he does. He has that look when he’s commentating for the WEC, guest starring on inside MMA, or some random interview. I know people like that in real life, and it just irks the hell out of me.
In fairness, part of my desire to see Mir lose is to have Brock win. While he is very raw talent at this point, he has shown a surprising amount of skill. I left my opinion about him unmade until after his Randy fight. People can blabber all they want about not liking him because he didn’t deserve a title shot, but I’d be willing to bed that 98 percent of those people don’t like him because he was in the WWE. I could care less about any of the pro wrestling circuits, in fact I think they are rather retarded. I’m NOT going to use that as a basis to say if someone has any skills or not, or any business in fighting in our beloved sport. The bottom line is he’s an athlete, a very impressive athlete especially for someone his size.
I saw someone say in another of the posts regarding Lesnar that he actually didn’t improve in any of his fights. I (as well as others) think he has, but I think the single most important thing that he has improved on is his eagerness to jump in when it’s not warranted. He seemed VERY composed in his last fight…and that’s a major thing he did not have in his Mir fight.
Do I think Mir can win…yes he can. Not only because this is MMA and anything can happen, but he is a skilled submission artist as well. Do I think his standup is all of a sudden world class? No. His attacks seemed to center on a couple combos the he used repeatedly over and over again. I think he also ended up looking much better than he really was because Nog ended up acting like a human punching bag and alot of Mirs slow punches made it through. Lesnars stand up looked pretty good against Randy IMO. Randy is notoriously hard to hit (just ask Tim Silvia), and Brock kept his composure the entire time…..probably knowing it was only a matter of time until one of them connected.
Randy even clocked Brock a few good times….one of them upon leaving a clinch (I think)….and it didn’t look like it phased him at all. He also got cut…..but that didn’t seem to bother him. He checked the cut with his fingers, but that’s no big deal.
Bottom line is, I hope and think Brock will win.
They will both have their hands full, that’s for damn sure.
However, I don’t see how the average duration of either man’s past fights have a damn thing to do with this. Brock has a grand total of four pro fights, three of them in UFC. Anyone can tell you that’s too small a sample to make any kind of conclusions on. Besides, how come it is suddenly relevant to compare Mir’s sub W’s to all Lesnar’s fights? Mir has 15 pro fights before Lesnar II. He’s 12-3. How come only the six subs are relevant? The guy has gone the distance only once (Christinson, UFC 61) so true, he either stops or (not very often) gets stopped, I’ll give you that. Then again, all three of his losses (Freeman, Cruz, Vera) have been first-round TKOs to strikes. Brock was well on his way to being #4 until Mazzagatti… well, was Mazzagatti.
If you’re going to get all statistical on us, at least give the impression of impartiality.
by Monday Morning Martial Artist on Apr 24, 2009 12:37 PM EDT reply actions
I think something that everybody tends to forget is that if Lesnar keeps winning and becomes the huge name that (most) people expect him to be, there is the possibility that this could convince Fedor to come to the UFC, for at least one fight. He has stated himself before that he would like to fight Brock, and everyone knows that Fedor is starting to run out of opponents outside of the UFC. Not to stir shit up to much, but I think alot of the new HW blood in the UFC might, in time, be a considerable challenge to Fedor and give him some real troubles, as well as other elite HWs. Guys like Lesnar, Carwin, Velasquez and Dos Santos are going to be the future of the sport need to be promoted as such, so these are the fights in the long term we should be shooting for. The only way to do this is for them to continue facing the most elite competition. It also gives incentive to the “elites” like Arlovsky, Barnett, Sylvia, Cro-Cop, etc. who have become lackadaisical and one-dimensional in there age to start upping there game and take training a little more seriously, which could also help them getting employed by Zuffa again (well, everyone except Barnett). Honestly, in my personnal opinion, whether you like the guy or not, Lesnar winning against Mir is the best thing for the UFC and as fans will only benifit us in the long run.
Mir definitely has the chops to pull this off,
but if it does not happen early I do not see how he gets a sub late as sweaty as Lesnar gets.
Arguing on the internet is like being in the special olympics, even when you win you are still retarded.
I myself couldn't care less if the "GREAT" Fedor ever steps into the octagon.
He wouldn’t hang anyway.
by Wookalarman on Apr 24, 2009 3:12 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
It will be telling if Brock attempts to keep it standing or chooses to take Mir down. This should tell us how comfortable Brock is in top position against a BJJ heavyweight. He will have trained this position, so he should have a good idea of whether he can control Mir on the ground without putting himself at risk, or not. A standing battle I see going like Carwin v Gonzaga, Mir as the better boxer, overcome by sheer power and explosiveness. But I havent seen any of Mir’s fights before his first with Lesnar, so I may be underestimating Mir. How is Mir’s chin?
No matter how comfortable Lesnar feels in top position,
I do not see him wanting to spend too much time there against Mir.
Arguing on the internet is like being in the special olympics, even when you win you are still retarded.
His best bet is sitting in half-guard and putting pressure (read: weight) on Mir’s pinned leg just to keep Mir from going for triangles, armbars, or things of that nature.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
I think that Brock has become very comfortable on the feet
recently & that is where he will the win this fight. He may finish via GnP, but his power standing is what better scare Mir.
Arguing on the internet is like being in the special olympics, even when you win you are still retarded.
Oh no doubt. I was talking about when the fight hits the ground what Lesnar should do. His transitions are great so if he can transition to side-control that’s fine. Even north-south is good. Just don’t get stupid and stand in Mir’s open guard.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
It should be interesting whichever way it goes down.
Mir seems to be working on his standup so he does not get freaking drilled like he did last time, but I think Lesnar’s reach & ridiculous power will be too much unless he gets careless.
Arguing on the internet is like being in the special olympics, even when you win you are still retarded.
Mir’s going to need some solid counterpunching in this bout. We havent yet seen a flustered or dazed Lesnar, and it will likely take more then a few hard shots before we do. Both fighters should be much improved from their first bout, which is part of what makes it so tough to call.
by Graven Image on Apr 24, 2009 3:35 PM EDT up reply actions
Hey guys, sorry for letting the Sherdoggery run rampant in this post for a day-plus. The dead brain stem posts have been hidden and the offending party warned. If stuff like this (flagrant name calling, fighter bashing, personal attacks, etc.) comes up in the future and no staff members are popping in to moderate, just shoot me an email.

by 




















