Seriously, Can Diego Sanchez Beat BJ Penn?
After a string of injuries and disappointing main events, the UFC is looking to turn things around this Saturday at UFC 107, which features BJ Penn vs. Diego Sanchez in a headlining lightweight championship match.
Let's break down one of the most anticipated matches of the year.
While he has a mixed record at higher weight classes, Penn is the most dominant 155-pound fighter in the history of the sport. At lightweight, BJ sports a record of 10-1-1 with notable wins over Sean Sherk, Joe Stevenson, Takanori Gomi, and Kenny Florian.
BJ's history at lightweight is even more impressive when you consider the following:
1) BJ debuted in the UFC and so he has only fought top competition. BJ has never been given an easy opponent, though his second fight with Pulver was clearly a mismatch.
2) His only loss at LW (Jens Pulver) came very early in his career and was later avenged in brutal fashion.
3) In his 10 wins at lightweight, Penn finished 9 of his opponents.
BJ's strengths are well known to most MMA fans. He is an amazing grappler with a brutally-efficient top game and a very slippery guard. He is also an excellent boxer with serious punching power. BJ also possesses some unique physical characteristics - namely his flexibility and balance, which contribute to his uncanny takedown defense. God even blessed BJ with a strong chin and tough skin, all the better for absorbing strikes.
BJ's fatal flaw has historically been a lack of motivation and focus. While he has looked good in recent fights, he has clearly come into some past fights without the proper preparation.
Diego Sanchez sports an overall MMA record of 23 and 2. After going 6 and 2 in the UFC's welterweight division, Diego dropped to 155 to pursue his goal of becoming a UFC champion. Diego's losses to Josh Koscheck and Jon Fitch were a clear indication that he just wasn't big enough to compete with the 170 pound division's stable of powerful wrestlers.
At lightweight, Diego has had two fights, earning decision victories over Joe Stevenson and Clay Guida. His notable wins at welterweight were decision victories over Nick Diaz and Karo Parisyan, and a knockout of Joe Riggs.
The Nightmare is best known for his cardio, aggressiveness, and fighting spirit than technical acument. He is, however, a fairly strong wrestler and grappler, having been awarded his BJJ brown belt by Saulo Ribeiro. Most importantly, his desire to win can't be questioned. Even if Diego falls behind early against BJ, there is little chance that he'll break mentally as some of BJ's past victims have.
But is Diego's heart and desire enough to take down The Prodigy?
The answer is no. Here's why.
Diego will come into this fight in fairly good shape and should have a cardio advantage over BJ.
However, look at Diego's two recent performances against Clay Guida and Joe Stevenson.
Diego didn't look bad in either fight, but ask yourself this question - if he's really good enough to take out BJ Penn, shouldn't he have been able to finish, or at least dominate fighters like Joe Stevenson and Clay Guida? Both are quality fighters, but not nearly as technically sound or dangerous as BJ. I'd also argue that Diego's gas tank is just a bit smaller at lightweight.
Technically, BJ is just far more dangerous in every position, standing or on the ground. If Diego comes out swinging the way he did against Guida, he's going to get hurt very quickly. He just doesn't have the punching power to stand and trade with the iron-chinned Penn.
And if Diego manages to overcome BJ's patented one-legged, hopping takedown defense, he won't be able to deliver much damage on the ground. BJ is very good at defending from his back and getting up to his feet. And If BJ takes the top position, Diego is going to take some punishment. BJ ate Kenny Florian and Joe Stevenson for breakfast on the ground. Diego may be trained by Saulo and Xande Ribeiro, two of the best grapplers and BJJ practitioners in history, but BJ's MMA grappling skills are far more advanced.
Diego may come into this fight in better shape, but I'll take the guy who is :
1) Better at everything from a technique perspective except offensive wrestling
and
2) Has fought, beaten, and finished better competition.
My Prediction: Penn by submission, round 3.
The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.
33 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
BJ wins...
by removing 1 or 2 limbs and beating Diego senseless with one, while Diego chases him around the ring yelling, “come back here, I’ll bite your ankles off!”
good post
I feel like this is going to go 5 round decision in favor of Penn. Once BJ is able to get in that comfort zone like he did with Sherk he will just pick Diego apart. I don’t think Diego will be take BJ down and keep him down.
Truth
Once BJ gets Diego’s timing down and finds his range, it’ll be all Penn. Diego may have improved striking, but he was outboxed by Koscheck, and got tagged quite a few times by Joe Daddy.
I say BJ drops 1 round at the most, and wins a dominant decision. Because Sanchez is a tough dude, has heart, is well conditioned, has a chin, and has good sub defense.
Supporting all Las Vegas MMA. Xtreme Couture FTMFW.
'09 is the year of the FW's.
by ElliotMatheny on Dec 9, 2009 3:34 PM EST up reply actions
if he’s really good enough to take out BJ Penn, shouldn’t he have been able to finish, or at least dominate fighters like Joe Stevenson and Clay Guida?
that’s weird MMA math there…
…..and who knows, maybe he can eak out a decision again? With both guys hard to finish, if Diego stays competitive with BJ, he might be able to win a close decision by winning the later rounds. I’ve seen weirder things in MMA.
Who voted for Sanchez by KO?
Really? St. Pierre can’t knock him out, Machida, etc. but Sanchez is the guy to do it? Not hating at all, just curious as to the thought process there…
GSP didn't knock him out cold
but as penn said himself, he couldnt remember a thing between 3rd and 4th round cos he was borderline KO’d
Making the world a better place, one dirtbag at a time.
Strange that BJ gets credit for his chin, yet Diego does not.
BJ doesn’t have a long history of knocking guys out on the feet, and Diego also has an iron jaw. BJ has a boxing advantage, but I’m not sure why Diego striking at all with BJ is supposed to lead to a quick KO.
I wonder how Diego will react, if when he loses.
J mackin Roe 623
by JRO623 on Dec 9, 2009 2:31 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
No.
I don’t think there’s one aspect of MMA that Sanchez is superior to Penn in, save cardio. Diego has great heart and a nonstop motor. But it won’t be enough.
in response to the title
ONLY by decision. Bj cannot be flash Ko’d by diego, like someone said already, machida and GSp couldnt do it, so diego wont.
But diegos frantic pace for 5 rounds COULD wear down BJ a BIT and get the later rounds, or we could see a Shogun/machida decision…
But in all likelyhood, BJ has it wrapped up
I want to see if BJ would survive an enslought like Diego threw at Guida…including that head kick. I’ve never seen someone get after BJ like that, and I’d love to see it.
"You guys are jerking eachother off with some pseudo deep bullshit." - Kid Nate
ever seen the GSP fight?
seriously if Diego did that “enslought” on BJ, hed end up knocked down…because strangely enough, when bj exchanges he actually hits his mark! not to mention he has more KO power than diego…
Visit my new blog at http://mmacesspool.wordpress.com/
by Hendo_One-Shot on Dec 9, 2009 7:01 PM EST up reply actions
Diego hasn’t been knocked down before, has he?
Why are we sure BJ would knock him down or KO him on the feet? He may, but this doesn’t seem like it’s a foregone conclusion.
by Hardcharger on Dec 10, 2009 10:34 AM EST up reply actions
BJ would never get caught in that position, dropping his hands trying to lurch forward like Guida was. His striking is way too technical for that. Using the Guida or Stevenson fights as a gauge of Sanchez’s striking is a bit misguided. They’re both terrible strikers. Stevenson had a terrible gameplan, if he had one at all, and decided to stand and trade for 3 rounds. Guida got him down a few times, but couldn’t do anything from the top besides try to break Sanchez’s elbow with the top of his skull.
BJ will probably win this fight
But I"m Cheering for Diego. LW division will be more fun if BJ loses.
CAN diego win?
Sure he could. He’s not a can or a paper lion. Obviously, BJ holds many of the advantages in this fight, but there are reasonable paths to victory for Diego. Diego is probably the bigger fighter here, which has caused BJ some problems in the past. Although BJ’s cardio is better, that has been his alleged weakness and it is Diego’s strength. I think this is one of the best challenges Penn has had in a while. It will make for a compelling fight and a great finish for what promises to be an interesting PPV event.
yeah
although I think there’s a small chance diego would win, it’s not even close to a situation where a thread like this is needed lol.
Visit my new blog MMA Cesspool
by Hendo_One-Shot on Dec 11, 2009 12:28 PM EST reply actions

by 



















