I love Randy, but Fedor would finish him before it even got to the cage. He would straight up out-strike him. And if it did, Fedor would probably take him down anyway. Fedor would win. This is a moot point because Randy will probably be fight at lightheavy for the rest of his career.

Now let me dismantle your Lesnar argument. I see no reason as to why Fedor can take 5 solid shots against Rogers off his back but will be KOed by Lesnar’s little hammerfists. Not going to happen.

Someone that could care less who he is, that is beyond full of themselves, and truly think they are going to win could be dangerous. While I can’t stand the Brock antics Brett Rogers, that is him.

Hey look, it fits perfectly. Rogers thought he would win. He couldn’t give two ****s about what Fedor did in the past.

I don’t know about Randy, but I certainly don’t think Fedor would survive the gauntlet the UFC would throw at him without sustaining at least a couple losses.

Fedor would have to fight guys like Brock, Carwin, Dos Santos, Velasquez, Mir, and maybe even guys like Anderson Silva and Lyoto Machida….all in succession!!

I’m not trying to be insulting in saying he should stick to fighting mid-level competition if he wants to keep that mystique. Rogers was not doing anything overly impressive, he started to gas heavily, and he still gave Fedor a hell of a fight.

good, fair and REALISTIC write up. the title is a bit misleading and i’m not sure about randy being able to beat fedor, but you just posted and said what alot of fans and writers are afraid to do, in fear of the fedor fantics who claim you to be a troll, which couldn’t be farther from the truth. FEDOR IS BEATABLE! might have made a beter headline. iv’e seen most of your post ’s somwhere on SB nation at one time or another and you are someone that i would consider very PRO-FEDOR and anything but a TROLL.
last night was a great victory for fedor and alot will take exception to anything but total praise of fedor, instead you chose to write you thoughts on how you really felt, even as a fedor fan.
Well done.

The heavyweights now are for the most part essentially super heavyweights. The nature of fighting in the cage gives a decided advantage to a bigger man to bully and trap a lighter opponent against the cage. The combination of the cage, Rogers being a larger man, and Fedor not being able to deliver head kicks to his downed opponent all worked to Fedor’s disadvantage. Fedor took a few more hits when he was on the ground than usual. The broken nose, now that was a bit of bad luck.

But, as always, Fedor stayed calm, made the adjustment, and KFO’s Mr. Rogers. Until proven otherwise, Fedor is the best. And the thing that makes him the best is that thing between his ears. He is the smartest fighter I have ever seen, with the exception Muhammad Ali. I am not saying he is unbeatable. I am however saying that I just don’t see anyone out there that can beat him.

Fedor looked beyond beatable last night, I was just cringing when Roger’s got a hold of him up against the cage and was picturing what Brock would have done to him. Even worse when Rogers was on top dropping punches on his face, there is no doubt in my mind anyway that Brock would have mauled him last night.

He’s too big, fast, and too good a wrestler and now that he’s learned to stay away from subs he would be the heavy favorite too bad it’ll never happen. It’s funny how all the Fedor fanatics are on hyperbole overdrive after last nights peformance it’s like there were 2 different fights one in where Fedor dominated Rogers and the other in which he won a fight after getting whooped on bad.

Either way it doesn’t really matter there are clearly 2 camps of people the Fedor worshippers and the one’s who see that Brock is the best HW in the world and last night just cemented that opinion to me anyways.

http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/2889/fedor2.gif

http://img509.imageshack.us/img509/9520/fedor4.gif

http://img301.imageshack.us/img301/1540/fedor3.gif

The more people that think like this the better, if Fedor vs Lesnar ever happens it will just make betting on Fedor more profitable.

It’s never going to happen, M1 can’t risk their golden ticket getting mauled by Lesnar. It’s funny how oversensetive the Fedorites get, you can never seem to have a reasonable conversation with them everthing out of their mouths is hyperbole. The worst were the threads made about how even if Fedor loses he’s still the greatest HW ever or Rome already making excuses as to why the Brock/Fedor fight should never happen.

Whenever Fedor is called out on alot of his suspect moves since 2005, they love to go on rants and talk about wins he had 3 or 4 years ago to somehow justify his greatness. I get that people are fans but being a fanatic should never cloud your judgement, i’ve been as hard on some of my favorite fighters than anyone because being a fans doesn’t involve drinking the kool-aid like many of you have.

Yep he’s not ready for UFC elite. I mean he’s only beat Arlovski and Silva who were top level in the UFC. Not to mention he beat the piss out of Nog. but I guess he is just some nobody.

Big Nog just beat Randy and Fedor destroyed Nog twice when Nog was in his prime. I don’t think Randy could beat Fedor