Details of Fedor Emelianenko's Affliction Contract and M-1's Consulting Agreement
Note: All information in this post was obtained via Affliction's motion to dismiss filed on November 6, 2009. It is all public information and can be obtained through the Pacer system.
David Wolf of MMA Payout broke the story earlier today that Affliction filed its motion to dismiss in response to the M-1 lawsuit I discussed on Bloody Elbow last week. Needless to say, a motion to dismiss is just a standard response in a lawsuit by the defense. I will have more thoughts on the motion to dismiss next week on Bloody Elbow, but my initial thought is that I'm baffled as to why a 12(b)(6) focused so much on the facts instead of the law. A 12(b)(6) motion is a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim for which relief can be granted, it is not a motion related to factual disputes.
The most interesting part of the filing is Affliction's disclosure to the courts of its agreements with Fedor Emelianenko and M-1 Global. They disclosed the promotional agreement as well as the "consulting agreement." According to the initial M-1 filing there was a third consulting agreement related to the M-1 Challenge TV show, but as far as I can tell that agreement hasn't been disclosed.
Below I'll go through the promotional agreement's essential terms and add my comments in italics where I feel anything additional is warranted.
The Promotional Agreement.
--Fedor is to be paid a $300,000 purse per fight.
--The contract arranges for four first class tickets and three coach tickets from St. Petersburg to wherever the fight is. It also arranges for four first class hotel rooms for up to five nights, round trip transportation on the ground, and meal allowances. This section is more extravagant than equivalent UFC contract provisions for its top stars.
-- The contract calls for three fights under the Affliction banner, and makes Affliction the exclusive home of Fedor fights in the United States. However, the contract states that any fight between Fedor Emelianenko and Randy Couture is excluded from the contract and can take place elsewhere. It's clear that when this contract was signed Fedor and M-1 were still shopping around a potential Couture fight incase he ever got out of his contract. This also further confirms that Affliction never had the rights to this fight.
--The contract states that it ends on the earlier of two dates: March 31, 2009 or after Fedor's last fight, unless the contract is extended. This will be a serious litigation battleground; M-1 will argue that Affliction extended the contract by promoting a third show. I find this argument fairly convincing.
--Affliction agreed to make all efforts to feature a M-1 logo on the mat. Fedor was allowed to choose any sponsor as long as there was no conflict with Affliction.
--Fedor Emelinaenko reserved all rights to distribute and exploit his bouts in Russia and Asia. He had the right to retain all revenue from the sale, license, or any other exploitation of his reserved rights to market the broadcast. There are other specifics regarding Affliction's responsibility to provide Fedor and M-1 with a high definition feed. The rights include streaming rights, and extend beyond Fedor's fights to the undercard and preliminary fights. You can imagine the UFC would never agree to such a term.
There are a number of other important and interesting terms, but those are the essential ones.
The Consulting Agreement
--M-1 was to provide consulting on all the following topics: International bout consulting, international television, fighter scouting, location for future bouts recommendations, television-related opportunities, international sponsorships, and bout tourism.
--M-1 was also required to fully cooperate and assist in the advertising and promotion of each fight.
--In exchange for these consulting services, Affliction agreed to pay M-1 a consulting fee of $1,200,000 per fight.
--Affliction was required to promote the M-1 Global brand through promotional activities including: Articles in event programs, M-1 Global's logo incorporated into Affliction advertising, M-1 logo recognition with event advertising, public address announcements during the bouts, the airing of M-1 videos announcements during events, and the creation and sale of co-branded M-1 and Affliction event posters.
I believe there is still one more consulting agreement out there based on my reading of M-1's lawsuit, but Affliction did not disclose it here. Just counting these two agreements, Fedor Emelianenko received $300,000 per fight while M-1 Global received 1.2 million. Fedor Emelianenko is a 20% owner of M-1 Global.
4 recs |
195 comments
|
Comments
ima go out and drink now, but when i come back i expect the comments section to be on fire…
BE master-debaters, assemble!
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
Fedor made $300K per fight and M-1 made $1.2 million? If Fedor is a 20% owner, that means he got an additional $240K from the money M-1 made? Did Fedor get any additional compensation, like from the revenue? That’s messed up, considering Fedor is taking all the risks in the cage. Or am I reading this wrong?
I love me some Sexyama!
You’re potentially reading this right. It’s a 64/36 split if you consider his percentage in favor of management.
But lots of UFC guys get paid in this kind of way. A purse amount and then a sub-letter agreement paying more. But rarely is it paid to a separate entity like M-1.
by Michael Rome on Nov 12, 2009 9:18 PM EST up reply actions
What I’m wondering is if a lot of fighters get paid this way, are they lop sided in favor of management? I think Fedor’s situation is not the norm.
I love me some Sexyama!
I’ve never heard of any instance in which management was paid more than a fighter (in MMA).
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
I agree...
They weren’t just management, as they are their own separate promotion who have put on multiple shows overseas.
However, the $1.2M is nothing more than a, “Hey, let us have Fedor,” fee.
As much as the guys appear to be leaches, you can’t really blame them can you? They have the “golden goose” right now and it’s really the only fighter than can be used to go up against the UFC (outside of Gina Carano). He’s not even close to mainstream at this point, but the highlight reel KO of Brett Rogers certainly gave him a good push. That and the fact that Dana keeps reminding the public of who Fedor is…which is both good and bad to a certain extent. Any smaller organization that’s having to pay that much money to a “consulting” company to get Fedor to fight for them is putting their organizational lives at stake. We’ve seen Bodog go down, then Affliction, I guess time will only tell if Strikeforce is going to follow.
Everyone argues that Dana should just shut up about Fedor and quit giving him free publicity, but I think it’s all part of his plan. These smaller organizations and start ups can’t afford to be throwing that much capital towards a fighter with a limited draw at this point. The more the public becomes aware of Fedor, the higher his price tag goes up. The UFC can afford to shell out the cash, and they can afford to run an organization without Fedor, due to their significant brand recognition. Only time will tell what’s going to transpire…
Contributing writer for MMA-Analyst.com
by Joe Schmitt on Nov 12, 2009 10:18 PM EST up reply actions 5 recs
That’s not counting how much he potentially made from the rights to distribute his fights in Asia and Russia, which isn’t disclosed here, I’m sure. Correct?
He made=20%
Seems to me that his equity in M-1 actually cripples his income.
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
Very true. We have no idea how much M1 global was able to take in distributing those fights in Russia and Asia. Could have been substantial.
Giving Shogun his props. I had the fight 48-47 Machida but Shogun put up a monumental performance and I am honored to have seen it in person.
Still
It’s all on the back of Fedor’s signing. M-1 was doing him no favors, they’re his management.
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
Thanks for that
Super productive.
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
It’s called synergy. And there are two possible approaches you can take to judge synergy:
1. nobody does anybody any favours (it’s business, baby)
2. everybody does favours to each other (they are helping and benefiting each other)
Pick yours. :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
Everybody does favors for each other?
I don’t remember Finklestein doing any favors for Pride (Inoki Bom Ba Ye scandal), BodogFight (Clash of Nations fiasco), Sibling Entertainment (the first iteration of M-1’s North American operation),or Affliction (lawsuit).
If the Fink was so magnanimous in his dealings with others, how come he has a trail of failed business partners in his wake? Vadim didn’t even bother to slow down and throw them a life preserver. He just cranked up the throttle and went looking for his next victim … er …. business partner.
Hardly
Thanks for playing, though.
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
by Blackout612 on Nov 13, 2009 10:42 PM EST up reply actions
It could have been substantial, but it can’t be that much if they need Affliction to pay around 2 million per fight.
If they were raking in dough from those deals, they wouldn’t need to partner with Affliction, they could have just paid Sylvia to fight in an M1 branded show.
by Phildo on Nov 12, 2009 10:36 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
That’s nonsense. The whole point of co-promotion is to have a synergy. Meaning: combining strengths and to have a better result than the direct sum of two by their face-values. If it would be beneficial to do everything alone, outsourcing and partnering wouldn’t be as popular as it is. The whole corner-stone of the economical efficiency is “do your own core-business, the thing that you do best, and outsource everything else, that is not part of your core-competence”.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
Promoting a fight card isn’t the same as outsourcing a building’s housekeeping staff or a company’s tech support call center. The whole point of co-promoting in MMA is to be able to do something you can’t do alone, Affliction needed a headliner and wanted Fedor and M-1 needed someone with deep pockets to make it rain, that was the “synergy” here. This is the entertainment industry not manufacturing and you can’t apply the popularity or reasoning behind general industry outsourcing to two companies working on the same MMA event that simply.
It doesn’t mean that Fedor gets an additional $240k, it just means the enterprise of which he is a 20% owner gets $1.2 million. Consider EliteXC. If they took in $1.2 million at the end of their run, would a 20% owner have walked away with any $? No. They’d still be a 20% owner of a company that’s under water. I’m not saying that the deal wasn’t valuable to Fedor, just that he didn’t necessarily take any cash from the consulting fee.
I’m in my final year of law school at Berkeley. Not a lawyer…yet.
by Michael Rome on Nov 12, 2009 9:18 PM EST up reply actions
geez man, how do you have time for it all? I’m a 2L and drowning! Do you plan on applying the law degree to entertainment/MMA?
I’m doing everything I can to find a way to apply the degree to MMA, but I’m very picky about what I’m willing to get involved with. There are a few potential opportunities I’m pursuing that I have to keep confidential for the time being, along with non-MMA opportunities. When I do decide what to do after school I’ll disclose it on the site.
by Michael Rome on Nov 12, 2009 9:49 PM EST up reply actions
Lemme Guess, Is plan for you is to be the Scott Boras and Drew Rosenhaus of MMA?
by The Bronzeville Bully on Nov 13, 2009 12:35 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
Fedor should be your first client when he decides to sue these crooks.
by mmalogic on Nov 13, 2009 4:34 AM EST up reply actions 3 recs
While I don’t mean to steal your thunder in the least or unearth anything you need to keep confidential, would it be possible somehow for me to pick your brain re generally what opportunities exist in MMA for someone with a law degree? I’ve kicked around idea a time or two before but really don’t know where to start, as seems to be the case with many legal careers.
where are lawyers used in MMA? there mostly the “agents/managers” because fighters cant afford to pay a lawyer separately to read the agreements and an “agent” in this business is not the same as one in any other busines… there’s no need for a “jerry mcguire” here. We’re talking about less than a handful of options for a fighter.
Sounds like a promising career, hopefully you stick around here in the future and become our legal insider for all things MMA related.
Also is it true lawyers are evil?
The ability of BE to look at legal stuff like this from guys like Rome is a huge part of why I come here.
I love me some Sexyama!
by pud333 on Nov 12, 2009 9:35 PM EST up reply actions 2 recs
As another aspiring lawyer I’m also impressed by the analysis, it’s very appropriate and helpful. Agree w/ Day Man that lawyers are mostly assholes.
I know a few lawyers
And they started out as assholes…then once they got paid like a motherfucker they moved on to noble causes.
BOOSH
Um, lawyers are assholes, but they're also the shit
In the town where I go to school the cops fucking hate all the students and want to fine us for whatever the fuck they can. I got popped for an open container earlier this year when I didn’t have an open container, and it was a tricky situation, but I had a lawyer who got that shit turned into a parking ticket.
Lawyers are the shit.
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 5:49 AM EST up reply actions
I work with lawyers on a regular basis
75% of them are pure and utter assholes, when it comes to winning. But after they leave “lawyer mode” they’re cool. Most do pro bono when they can, and they tend to pwn when it’s for a good cause.
"Never underestimate the predictability of stupidity." - Bullet Tooth Tony
@deowade
Lawyers are the asshole AND the shit?
That’s covering a lot of ground.
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
glad someone caught the pun.
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 3:51 PM EST up reply actions
Yes
Stuff like this, Judo Chops, analysis of network ratings and PPV numbers, and other insightful and informative content is what keeps me coming back to this site constantly. The generally cordial and often constructive comment discussion is a big plus too, and I’m sure we can partly thank the comment moderation for that.
"I want to tell me what you see, let's go ahead and see by in the fight, what you saw, in the ring." - Tito Ortiz
by CasualMMAFan on Nov 13, 2009 1:57 AM EST up reply actions
^ my thougts
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 5:50 AM EST up reply actions
So if Fedor’s $300,000 plus his 20% from M-1 only adds up to 540k and this is all he got, then Tim Sylvia earned more in his base pay (800k) in their fight.
While thats nutty, the fact that Fedor doesn’t really care about money and would rather just see his friends get paid for him fighting kind of quiets any of my outrage.
Not that I condone facism or any ism for that matter. Isms are in my opinion, not good. A person shouldn't believe in an ism, he should believe in himself.
I quote John Lennon, "I don't believe in Beatles, I just believe in me". Good point there, after all he was the walrus. I could be the walrus. Wouldn't change the fact I have to bum rides off of people.
As another poster mentioned he doesn’t get 20% of the money paid to M1. He owns 20% of the company that brought in $1,200,000 in revenue.
Giving Shogun his props. I had the fight 48-47 Machida but Shogun put up a monumental performance and I am honored to have seen it in person.
It’s hard to imagine Fedor taking an active part in M-1’s management. If he doesn’t, the profitability of his share of M-1 depends entirely on his co-owners. And there are a million ways for an unethical co-owner to siphon cash away from the business.
Based on this contract information and what M-1 is getting in comparison to Fedor, all I can think is, If it looks like shit, and smells like shit…
I love me some Sexyama!
…lucky we didn’t step in it?
Not that I condone facism or any ism for that matter. Isms are in my opinion, not good. A person shouldn't believe in an ism, he should believe in himself.
I quote John Lennon, "I don't believe in Beatles, I just believe in me". Good point there, after all he was the walrus. I could be the walrus. Wouldn't change the fact I have to bum rides off of people.
by SamCupitt on Nov 12, 2009 10:26 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
I don’t think you could consider tapeworms as “friends.”
I love me some Sexyama!
by pud333 on Nov 12, 2009 9:45 PM EST up reply actions 4 recs
I’ve heard that Fedor also has a side-contract/personal services contract with M-1. Anyone know the truth to this statement? I assume since they’re a private company that this information isn’t readily available (those sneaky Russkies!), but if he’s getting $300k + 20% ownership in the company + PS contract with M-1, maybe he’s not making as little as we’re assuming.
Thoughts?
I am the bastard love child of Junie Browning and Diamond Dave Kaplan.
Aside
When Wayne Gretzky was playing for the Edmonton Oilers in their heyday he was making a publicly disclosed player’s salary (around a couple million iirc), but he also had a private personal services contract with Pocklington on the side that paid him many millions more. I know this for a fact.
So the idea that Fedor might have a similar deal – while it may sounds a lot more suspect than the locker room bonuses, is actually quite possible.
I am the bastard love child of Junie Browning and Diamond Dave Kaplan.
If they had a side deal like that then it would be likely to of been presented by Affliction here so it’s doubtful. Randy has a separate personal service contract with the UFC that came out in his lawsuit, heck it was that contract that was the actual sticking point for a lot of the issues. The issue here with what Fedor got goes back to what was in his M-1 contract (not only is he a part owner he is contracted to them), his “other pay” would come out of what Affliction was paying M-1 Global. Heck for all we know they got the $300k too and Fedor only got what his M-1 Global contract was for.
I can give you 49% of a company that does 5 million in revenue (about how much Fedor generated with the affliction contract) and if I owned or controlled 51% of that company and I didnt want you to see one penny of that money you it would be very easy to do.
I can create salaries for all my relatives… farm out work to some other companies I own and inflate the invoices… and there are tons of more complex ways to do this.
So when Josh Gross says Fedor and M1 are no different than Oscar and Goldenboy he’s a moron. Oscar owns and controls the entire company this small detail makes a world of difference.
You would be right, if Fedor wouldn’t have a separate contract with M-1, which guarantees him minimum payment. So in a sense, that’s the same type of arrangement, that Randy/Lesnar (and whoever else, who gets % of PPV) have with the UFC, except that Fedor actually owns the company.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
No… the difference is Randy, Brock, etc… get 100% of the money paid for their services and then they pay around 15% to their management and do whatever they like with the money left over.
The deals that are negotiated primarily for Fedor’s services… the majority of the purse goes somewhere else and the deals are structured in a way where the rest of his purse is subsidized by license fees M1 gets.
Strikeforce is paying around 1.2 million per fight plus half of the gate, and giving M-1 overseas rights to the shows.
400k goes to Fedor… the rest (800k plus half of the gate, and whatever overseas licensing goes to M1).
Yeah sure.. M1 has “the minimum guarantee” you’re talking about… Guys like Monte Cox and Attencio already know about it. So before it all comes out please dispute the fact that Fedor gets less than 50% of the value paid primarily for his services.
But you can also protect yourself by stipulating that an outside accountant will go over the books to limit any chicanery.
Not so true…that’s a pretty generalized and incorrect statement. While I’m not up on my Russian corporate law – is there any? I do know that (minority) shareholders have a powerful weapon known as an oppression remedy available to them where the majority shareholder is acting unfairly or prejudicially towards them, which is the example you just gave.
So sure, it would be easy to try – but you’ll have a tough time getting away with it.
I am the bastard love child of Junie Browning and Diamond Dave Kaplan.
Company Practices in Russia: The protection of minority shareholder rights
remains a key concern for many (international) investors considering investing
in Russian companies. Powerful owners/managers often pay little or no heed
to minority shareholders. On the other hand, shareholders themselves are
often passive, reflecting the lack of a shareholder culture among Russian investors.
This comes as no surprise since citizens (often former employees of plants
and factories) became shareholders practically overnight during the privatization
phase, typically without having invested (material) funds before or having been
educated about their rights.
From The International Finance Company, The Russian Corporate Governance Manual, Ch. 7—An Introduction to Shareholder Rights (2004).
I also read through a translation of Russia’s federal company law and didn’t see anything about remedies for oppression and it could be included in another law. I could have missed it since I skimmed. I’m better informed on Caribbean company law.
Does anyone know the form of business M-1 uses in Russia?
Very good stuff, this is why I come to BE. Rec’d.
Also, Fedro, I hope you’re saving your money.
'Ello G'vnor!
sounds like affliction got completely buttfucked on this deal. seriously what the fuck were they thinking?
I would have consulted them for half that amount.
by casey manrique on Nov 12, 2009 10:04 PM EST up reply actions
um they werent? Atencio thought Fedor would be the demolishing force to UFC. All organizations seem to believe the answer to the UFC is Fedor vs Couture. (BoDog)
"What do you want from me?..... A Slap?"
by xtremecouture on Nov 12, 2009 10:21 PM EST up reply actions
BoDog was nothing of the sort or failing that a very tertiary point to the entire venture.
Calvin Ayre formed BoDog – (a) as a vehicle to promote his BoDog betting sites, because “ultimate fighting” was the new trendy thing, (b) to shamelessly self promote himself and © maybe make some money since he was a money mark and (wrongly) thought “everybody else is making money, so can I!”….seems like there’s a lot of people who lost money with that line of thinking.
I am the bastard love child of Junie Browning and Diamond Dave Kaplan.
Any one still believe that the UFC could have done anything more (in a reasonable matter) to sigh Fedor. If Fedor and M1 are used to this sort of treatment since I bet Bodog would be similar than of course they wouldnt want a legit company with legitimate contracts controlling Fedor?
With that said I hope Mousasi gets smart to M1 and signs with the UFC under new management.
"What do you want from me?..... A Slap?"
this article makes me remember why
by Anton Tabuena on Nov 12, 2009 10:25 PM EST reply actions 9 recs
I know its not a popular opinion… but they have balls and I respect that. Its up to the partnering entity to protect their interests. Coker is smart enough not to get burned.
I’m hoping that they’re learning from their mistakes in terms of produced products but it takes a bit of ruthlessness to come up. I think SF might be a great balancing factor/grounding effect.
Just like listening to commentary in a fight, I think a lot of sentiment that swirls around M1 is Millen… granted he’s a douche but Fedor also owns a large part of the company… I’m all for a Fedor enterprise to succeed.
Dana is sending Tom Atencio and his lawyers gift baskets
Agree xtreme. To be fair what has been written before is the Fedor is paid his purse plus an additional payment from M-1. Who knows, maybe M-1 pays Fedor $600k and keeps the other $600k. I doubt it, but possible. The way I understand business works in Russia, Fedor is probably getting $100k from M-1 and told to like it.
If I were M-1 I would give a hefty chunk to the Orthodox Church Fedor goes to. Secure his loyalty through his real passion. My point is the contract really doesn’t shed much more light on how much Fedor took home personally, but it sure does shed light on the shady contract structure M-1 evidently prefers. These guys should be underwriting mortgage derivatives their structures are so shady.
Rome put down wills and estates for a minute… How does the M-1 contract compare to a co-promotion in boxing? Is a fighter’s promoter paid a consulting type fee and he pays his boxer?
The way I understand business works in Russia, Fedor is probably getting $100k from M-1 and told to like it.
You don’t need to undermine your comment’s credibility like that.
Also, I don’t believe Fedor’s loyalty to M-1 is in doubt at this point, making a donation seemingly uneccessary. I do agree about the UFC being delighted with this release of information, and wouldn’t have been suprised if they knew beforehand that this was going to come out given their re-established relationship with Affliction.
'He built his whole reputation as a waffle house chef. They’ve been serving him up ham and eggs with a side of canned tomatoes' - Don Frye on Fedor Emelianenko
by Well Read Idiot on Nov 13, 2009 4:36 AM EST up reply actions
My comment stems from a friend of mine who grew up in Mascow, served in the army during the 80s and later fled the country to find a better environment to set-up a business in. I might not be credible, but he sure is and he’s the source for my comment.
There is also a subtly lost when the business environment in Russia is not considered. From what my buddy tells me someone in Fedor’s position must appear loyal to his management no matter if he loves or hates them. Its just the way it is. Fedor’s victory speech as a shout out to the members of his Church community, not his handlers. If his handlers are smart they give patronage to what is important to Fedor and then are allowed to continuing taking the lion’s share of his winnings. For better or worse, the you scratch my back I scratch yours, but we never acknowledge it, is how it tends to work.
Bottom-line is that what is business as usually on the other side of the world is not here, and vice versa.
Fair enough
It came across to me as a generic ‘Mother Russia’ cold-war propaganda influenced comment initially, so apologies for jumping on you.
I would be interested in reading what our new resident Russian ‘Mikser’ has to say on this matter.
From my knowledge of dealing indirectly with Russian businesses, they generally are not too subtle about showing their strength and would not care at all if you thought they were exploiting and manipulating something. Hence it doesn’t make too much sense to me that they would be trying to hide the fact they are exploiting Fedor, if that is what they are doing.
'He built his whole reputation as a waffle house chef. They’ve been serving him up ham and eggs with a side of canned tomatoes' - Don Frye on Fedor Emelianenko
by Well Read Idiot on Nov 13, 2009 10:13 AM EST up reply actions
Agreed, Russian strong suit is not being subtle. Other than the contract previously being kept private, I think M-1 is doing exactly what we should expect; not only are they exploiting and manipulating the contract situation with their client for their own benefit, they memorialized it in writing.
Let me put it this way, I can’t imagine any fighter sitting down with a potential manager and saying, “Okay, we’re gonna get ours up front, none of that show/win crap. I win all the time so it really doesn’t matter. I earned it, they need to pay it. Let’s ask for $1.5 million. See how they like that shit. And oh yeah, make sure they pay you 80% of it, I only need to see 20% directly.” This isn’t the 80/20 rule I learned in business school.
So its reasonable to believe the contract was M-1’s idea (I know Fedor’s a 20% owner, but don’t forget he is 80% of its assets) and its in writing. Nothing hidden about it. Take your 20%, free ice cream, and your own personal line of sweaters and like it.
I have read that he has an employment contract with M-1 as well, (Swear I saw it in a quote somewhere from him/Vadim)
For all we know that contract is huge and M-1 would fold without most of Fedor’s ‘Purse’ going to the company so they could pay up to Fedor.
Haha while I’m on this train of thought, FEDOR could be bleeding M-1 dry! They do all this co-promotion to get the fees to pay him or else they go under…
Sorry it’s Friday arvo and I am literally killing time at my desk by playing minesweeper…
'He built his whole reputation as a waffle house chef. They’ve been serving him up ham and eggs with a side of canned tomatoes' - Don Frye on Fedor Emelianenko
by Well Read Idiot on Nov 13, 2009 11:42 AM EST up reply actions
I might not be credible, but he sure is and he’s the source for my comment.
You have some real sources – that’s very delightful! (no joke)
There is a huge problem with it, though. It’s called “a time-machine effect” (or “time freezing effect”). That is the effect, when the person leaves the country/city/place/people/company, he remains to keep the old version of the country/city/place/people/company as the real one, despite all the changes that happen all the time. The person is not able to understand the changes, because he is not witnessing them and is not able to understand their importance.
The people who changed the work place, moved to another city or even country or continent – will understand what I am talking about.
And the longer the time-span – the bigger the difference between perceived and reality. I worked in one company, then I left it, but still had good connection with people there. A short time after I left, everything we talked with my old collegues made total sense. But then everything started to change: new people came in, new projects were opened and closed, new organizational changes were made, etc… After a few years I had to finally realize, that the company was completely different from what it used to be and that I have to stop judging or viewing the actions through the outdated perception.
With things like countries, people and culture, everything is much more difficult because it’s so much complex and uncertain. Maybe situation X was just a fluke or maybe it tells about the real change in behaviour… This complexity problem is worsened by not having enough current information about what is going on. Meeting few relatives a year, reading newspapers, watching TV, and relying on the word-of-mouth can hardly be considered as a trustworthy source of reliable information…
The thing with Russia is that it underwent a HUGE transformation during the last decades. Even a few years difference can be crucial in understanding what is really going on.
If you are really interested in the subject, talk with the Russian/Soviet immigrants, who left at different times. You will be amazed at the difference! People from 70s will talk about the all-mighty KGB and will never believe that somebody would vote for Putin, let alone that there is so many people, that he would win the elections. People from 80s will talk about the lack of food/products and a strong feeling of something bad approaching. People from early/mid 90s will talk about a general despair and a lot of violence and crime. People from mid-90s to the 1998 will talk about a little spark of hope. People from 1998 to 1999/2000 will talk about confusion. People from 2000 to…. etc etc etc…
Listening to the people from the different eras is interesting in understanding what was going on on that moment, valuable in capturing the feeling of people (and this is much better idea, than to ask current Russians how did they feel 20 years ago). But do not make a mistake by judging the situation from one time-era by using the information from completely different era.
For people who still don’t believe that things change very fast, please read this very interesting research paper “Lazy Japanese and Thieving Germans – Are Some Cultures Incapable of Economic Development?”.
The mafia and crime problems were huge, especially in early 90s. If you want an excellent view at how the whole living felt like at that time, I would highly recomment the mini-serial Brigada ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0337898/ , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brigada ). It is excellent at capturing the feeling of that era.
But make no mistake, the current situation is completely different – has been for 10 years now. Now the mafia is gone (from the lives of usual people) and corruption, government officials and lawyers are a much bigger problem.
Everything also depends on the people/companies one works with. Gazprom/Rosneft are very different from Lukoil. Small-businesses are extremely different from these huge oil and gas companies. Alcohol and (money) gambling industries are very different from (PC and console) game development. The type of management plays a huge role as well – that’s why I was pointing out, that Vadim is an European type of businessman.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
On an unrelated note Do only two stories load on the front page of BE for everyone else all the time? I have to catch it off guard or some bullshit because only rarely do they let me see all the stories and the fanposts.
Not that I condone facism or any ism for that matter. Isms are in my opinion, not good. A person shouldn't believe in an ism, he should believe in himself.
I quote John Lennon, "I don't believe in Beatles, I just believe in me". Good point there, after all he was the walrus. I could be the walrus. Wouldn't change the fact I have to bum rides off of people.
Go into your user settings and set the amount of posts you want it to display..etc.
Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
MMA Editor - SBNation.com
by Brent Brookhouse on Nov 12, 2009 11:04 PM EST up reply actions
If you want to know the reason why the Fedor/Lesnar fight didn’t happen, it is this right here.
Fedor, although he is the #1 ranked heavyweight in the world, the casual fan doesn’t know that. Ergo, Fedor doesn’t have a huge draw in the U.S.
Therefore, with these demands(from greedy Russian managers), greedy Dana feels he wouldn’t be making enough money to warrant a Fedor fight with Lesnar, especially since there is a chance Lesnar, UFC’s big draw at the moment, would lose, only to have Fedor most likely leave the UFC after becoming the undisputed champion and pretty much doing everything he could with his career.
Then, Dana would be out the $$$ he paid Fedor, and M1, and be out of $$$ because his stallion Lesnar would no longer have the draw he does now.
However, now another organization has Fedor and Dana, who is used to getting whatever he wants, doesn’t. So naturally, because of this factor and that Strikeforce is his (albeit small) competition, Dana continues to rain verbal shit all over them and Fedor and M1.
I think your wrong here. The UFC marketing machine is amazing. They can take anyone they wanted to can make them look like awesome and look like the #1 guy and make them marketable. What makes Fedor/Lesner great for the UFC and why they wanted that fight is that they already own all the rights to his footage which they would take and make him look like superman. Thats one of the big issues that Strikeforce had. If they could have put that fight together they would have made a ton of money. … but I think the UFC will do even better now that he is getting more exposure to the states and when Strikeforce goes under or just cant afford him anymore the UFC will pay him a huge amount of money to get him on board with the UFC (minus the co-promote ofcourse), because once strikeforce goes they will be no one else state side to pay him huge money…and he wont be go to DREAM once he’s raking in a ton of money here
I think you missed the point.
UFC and Dana would not want to do the all the work to build up a man that is a stranger to the domestic MMA populace, especially if…
1. The aforementioned “unknown legend” named Fedor has a big possibility of beating a man that is already a household name and the “new direction”, the “evolution”, and “next BIG thing” of the sport of MMA.
2. The UFC would have to co-promote and pay out big bucks to a shady Russian fight empire.
3. The UFC would lose viewership and legitimacy as THE premier fight organisation and have to find a new big draw in a talent pool that is already shallow.
The only reason Dana wants Fedor, is so Brock can beat him. That’s the only why he wants it and thats the only way he would make any considerable moeny off the encounter and he wants it under his own stipulations.
Think about it, if Fedor actually made a deal and fought Lesnar and won, why would he stick around to fight anyone else? There is no one else to beat. He would just go back to Russiua and leave UFC high and dry and Dana knows this. The only other person Fedor may fight would be Couture but that would be it and it would have been way too late to matter anyway.
Remember
A loss doesn’t necessarily stop someone from being a draw. Lesnar has already lost in the UFC. GSP has lost in the UFC. Randy has lost in the UFC. Chuck has lost in the UFC.
It is all about the spin, which would undoubtedly be first class coming from Zuffa.
Fedor in the UFC is money for EVERYONE no matter how you look at it.
'He built his whole reputation as a waffle house chef. They’ve been serving him up ham and eggs with a side of canned tomatoes' - Don Frye on Fedor Emelianenko
by Well Read Idiot on Nov 13, 2009 4:42 AM EST up reply actions
Also, with the growing UFC HW division...
there is no reason to think that Fedor’s first fight would be with Lesnar. One or two build up fights just get him “introduced” to the world through the UFC and then a title shot would be just about right.
A loss doesn’t necessarily stop someone from being a draw.
True, but it stops Lesnar from being the heralded, future and new king of the sport. Which would hurt a lot being beaten by someone not a lot of people know.
Multi fight contracts, champion’s clause.
Fedor wouldn’t be going anywhere.
Pretty sure any contract UFC, M1 and Fedor would make would end up being special. The title wouldn’t even have to be on the line. But, anyway, at the most they would sign a three fight deal. Which brings me to…
One or two build up fights just get him "introduced" to the world through the UFC and then a title shot would be just about right.
True, he could fight Nog again, UFC could buid that up and show the past footage from Pride. I’m sure Fedor would beat him though. Then the legendary Couture fight would be huge, which, I’m sorry, I still think Fedor would win. A couple of years ago it would be a great fight but now, I have to side with Fedor. Then it would be Lesnar. And if Fedor beat Lesnar, why would he stick around to fight anyone else?
He would retire and everyone, even though they begged for these three huge fights, would say Fedor fought old guys passed their prime and would nit pick however he won the fight. Unless, he made Brock give up or knocked him out, then they would say it was punchers luck.
Fedor really loses either way.
The mainstream doesn’t want Fedor to win, and are not interested in a stoic, quiet champion who doesn’t talk shit and do things out of character. Couture has some of those traits but he is American, “The Natural”, a good ol’ boy, he speaks out language and is charismatic. Which is why he is so well known.
Dana would rather chew off his own foot than let Fedor fight for a title, and not have him locked up.
The co-promotion and the one off deals are unacceptable terms for Zuffa.
Keep firing Assholes!
I am the King of Rome, and am above grammar. -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor
I don’t think, if it got to that point, that it would even need to be for a title.
So much stuff has to change and go down for this fight to even have the mere chance to happen.
Dana only wants it if Fedor stays “undefeated” as well. So that has to happen and then, probably, we’ll have to wait for Strikeforce to go under so Fedor really just has no place to go. Then, one person, either Dana or M1 would have to budge on their demands. And after all that, and subsequent fights leading up to Lesnar/Couture, Lesnar may not even be the camp anymore.
True, but it stops Lesnar from being the heralded, future and new king of the sport. Which would hurt a lot being beaten by someone not a lot of people know.
No. GSP was heralded as the next dominant WW champ. Then he got Serra’d. Few wins later, he’s once again heralded as the next dominant WW champ. You’re only as good as your last fight. Fans and the media are fickle. If Brock lost to Lesnar, all he’d need are a couple dominant wins and he’d be back better than ever. A loss to Fedor right now could be spun as Lesnar not being as experienced, blah blah blah.
Pretty sure any contract UFC, M1 and Fedor would make would end up being special. The title wouldn’t even have to be on the line.
If Fedor was coming to the UFC, I’m pretty sure there would be an immediate title shot. No way the UFC lets him walk away with the title. Definitely going to be the champs clause in there. Dana and co. are huge fanboys, and they let their fanboy idiocy get the best of them when they tried to get Fedor, but they’re not crazy.
I love me some Sexyama!
Rome, or some other lawyer type.
In M1’s lawsuit it said
On or about October 20, 2009, Plaintiffs, in writing, sought Affliction’s stipulation to disclose the terms of the Fight Agreement in the context of litigation between the parties due to confidentiality restrictions contained in the Fight Agreement. Affliction did not respond. As a result, Plaintiffs plead only those terms essential to put Affliction on notice of the claims against it and those terms already a matter of public knowledge.
Were they claiming that the contracts were supposed to be confidential (similar language was used at least in one other spot in the contract), and did Affliction sort of preemptively release everything as a sort of FU? Letting it out before a judge told them they couldn’t? Or am I reading it wrong?
It sure seems like it
They don’t want to give Dana White ammo to say ‘See! I told you so! They wanted me to do all of that and more! I’m not going to pay M-1 to sit on their asses!’.
I’ll take a quick crack at it, without having read the whole thing:
M-1 asked Affliction in writing if they could disclose the terms of the contract that were protected by confidentiality restrictions insofar as they were pertinent to this litigation. I’m not sure if this happens in actual cases a lot (most law schools teach you a lot more about the thought process involved in analyzing law rather than the practical duties/functions of being a lawyer) but this sounds like they just sent Affliction a letter asking for permission. I imagine most parties to a lawsuit won’t respond favorably to such requests. The other road M-1 could have gone down (and likely still may) would be to file a motion to compel production of the agreement; this is turned into the judge and is like saying “look; we need this thing to move forward. Make them show it to us and the court.”
I don’t think Affliction released the info as an ‘FU’; while they may want to send M-1 such a message, that kind of sentiment shouldn’t dictate legal strategy. (well, at least not too much). My guess is they wanted to disclose the portions of the contract most vital to their defense in the suit and wanted to do so on their terms.
Those vital parts? I think clearly it’s the March 31, 2009 end date of the contract and some of these exorbitant fees paid to M-1. Maybe the exorbitant fees can be used by Affliction to say “we were in such dire straits financially, we had to cancel our third show and didn’t do so to get out of paying Fedor/M-1,” but I’m not sure about that yet. This would go towards the impossibility defense of contract law (there’s a famous example where some kind of performer tries to sue her promoter for cancelling her show, but the show simply can’t happen b/c the venue has burned to the ground).
Question
This wasn’t clarified:
—In exchange for these consulting services, Affliction agreed to pay M-1 a consulting fee of $1,200,000 per fight.
Key words being per fight. Did this only involve consulting on Fedor’s fights? Theoretically that could have involved anyone else under the M-1 banner correct? Say if Baby Fedor fought under the M1 banner, M-1 would actually get the $1.2 million from that?
AWmusic - mp3 blog.
http://twitter.com/awmusicblog
Well it was Fedor’s contract so anything in it would apply only to his fights.
by ufc4 on Nov 12, 2009 11:27 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
I’m guessing just Fedor’s fights because I would think Affliction would have folded 1/2 way through Banned if they were forking over $1.2 million per M-1 fighter.
Actually I looked it up, pretty sure baby Fedor was only other M-1 fighter to ever fight on an Affliction card. There were 3 slated to fight on Trilogy. If I were Affliction and facing $1.2 million per M-1 fighter Fedor would be only fighter ever on my cards.
Makes more sense its just Fedor fights.
Probably makes more sense
for Affliction if it was just Fedor. Though financially for Fedor if it was $2.7 million to host a Fedor fight that actually seems well within the realm of possibilities. It also makes even more sense that Kiril Sidelnikov was on the main card in a fight he probably shouldn’t have taken.
It could have played into Affliction’s decision that $3.9 million + advertising for M-1 likely wasn’t worth it with Josh Barnett out of the picture. Could be one of the main factors and I’d say it would be. It say went from 1 fight to 2 fights to 3 fights… so there is a progression of M-1 having a stranglehold on Affliction.
Banned, only cost Affliction $1.5 million which I would say is a reasonable price tag. So the only time where the money actually gets out of order is the event they actually canceled.
AWmusic - mp3 blog.
http://twitter.com/awmusicblog
…oh. neat
Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
MMA Editor - SBNation.com
by Brent Brookhouse on Nov 13, 2009 12:22 AM EST up reply actions 2 recs
same here, 300k or a million dollers is something i will never have, so yeah, i dont care either.
Everyone has a game plan, untell they get hit.
You will never have 300k?
Maybe it’s time to change fields?
"I’m sorry. I didn’t drink last night, so I’m not funny today."
-Sakuraba
If you ever want to retire I certainly hope you have that much when you get ready to retire, as real estate equity if nothing else.
"I want to tell me what you see, let's go ahead and see by in the fight, what you saw, in the ring." - Tito Ortiz
by CasualMMAFan on Nov 13, 2009 2:09 AM EST up reply actions
You COULD care less?
So that means you actually do care? I’m confused.

'Ello G'vnor!
by IHateMMA on Nov 13, 2009 1:36 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
As soon as Fedor retires M-1 will fall off the face of the earth. This Fedor shit will be looked apon as the first real Management screw job to a fighter. I think fedor is kept away from any thing that has any chance of letting him know just how blinded he is to what M-1 are doing, also he may not care. I mean proof of him being kept on pretty good lock and key would be his piece in fight! The guy who wrote it was told he would get an hour with Fedor but once Fedor showed up with 20 or so handlers he was told that “fedor was tired” and said he was kinda hurried. These guys are not fans of the american media having one on one time with Fedor
Not much new in these details
I guess it’s confirmation on a few details.
Well everyone knew Fedor’s base pay from Affliction was only $300k.
by ufc4 on Nov 13, 2009 8:18 AM EST via mobile up reply actions
Question:
Aside from the consulting fee, was M1 suppose to get anything from the co promotion if Affliction I & II did make profits?
I am. I think. I will. - Ayn Rand
I still dont think Fedor
knows what he actually makes. M1 pays for his log cabin, sweater, icecream and Fedor gets to fly coach on a plane. All is good in mother Russia, Fedor is happy but broke. After operating costs, 20% of M1 is like owning a lemonade stand.
Basically
As long as Fedor is able to live his lifestyle without any questions asked (which would be pretty easy considering how much money M-1 makes) then I think he’d be ok with staying with M-1. Fedor seems like a pretty simple guy. He’s just content getting on with his life.
It’s going to be sad if there needs to be a BE Fund for Fedor when he’s 60 though. It’s going to be a good few years before we know just how badly the Fedor got screwed.
Is the Strikeforce/M-1 agreement similarly structured?
Now that this info has been released I’m extremely curious to know if Fedor/M-1s agreement with Strikeforce is similarly structured. And…
If it is, can you imagine the additional demands they’ll want once Fedor becomes Strikeforce HW champ? Wow.
I can completely understand why the UFC wouldn’t want to do business with M-1 under their conditions. Especially since Eurasia seems to be an area of future expansion for the UFC so owning content outright will be very important.
Strikeforce is basically complicit in this entire scheme.
Imagine if Monte Cox (manages Tim Sylvia and a bunch of other guys) went to strikeforce and said "listen UFC is offering 500K per match for fighter “X” but if we can structure things in a way where a bunch of the money comes to me and I secure other revenue sources through you then I can convince him to sign with you and It will only cost you 200k per fight."
Biggest untold story in the business about how the best fighter in the sport is being shafted.
Fedor gets paid less than 50% of the deals that are negotiated primarily for his services… and if you factor in taking the “less money deals for Fedor” because it’s “better structured for Vadim” he’s being fucked out of more than 75% of his monies.
People can speculate all they want about how good or not good Zuffa’s offer was… but the fact is Dave Meltzer… the guy who gets quoted more than any other in this business confirmed the scope of the deal.
So when they say the strikeforce deal was better… IT’S TRUE. What they don’t tell you is that it was better for VADIM.
by mmalogic on Nov 13, 2009 1:26 PM EST up reply actions 2 recs
Agreed. Any way you cut it, Fedor is getting screwed. Fedor is the guy putting everything at risk in the ring, and his management makes more money off his fighting than he does. That sort of thing is unheard of as far as I know. Anyone that tries to defend this kind of management is a) works for M-1 b) stupid c) out of their minds, or d) all of the above.
I love me some Sexyama!
That 1.2 million consulting fee is worth every penny. Just look at the in depth knowledge, business savy and professionalism that Millen and Finkelstien bring to the table.
Keep firing Assholes!
I am the King of Rome, and am above grammar. -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor
by Ubernoober on Nov 13, 2009 8:02 AM EST reply actions 8 recs
Agree and rec! Affliction would have been much worse without the help from M-1.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
I'm fairly certain
he was being sarcastic…
by WestbergIDFC on Nov 13, 2009 10:36 AM EST up reply actions
I know. That makes my comment even funnier, doesn’t it? :))
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
Supremacy already has this not getting the sarcasm angle covered.
A man should never waste an opportunity to keep his mouth shut.
Some sarcasms are hard to catch, but that one was pretty easy. :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
you really do work for M-1. Those are probably the only people on the planet who could actually believe that.
I don’t work for/with them. :) The only relation we have is that I once went to their M-1 Challenge event and spoke there shortly with Jerry Millen.
As for your statement, there is an excellent George Bernard Shaw quote I think fits your behaviour perfectly:
THEODOTUS: Caesar: you are a stranger here, and not conversant with our laws. The kings and queens of Egypt may not marry except with their own royal blood. Ptolemy and Cleopatra are born king and consort just as they are born brother and sister.
BRITANNUS (shocked): Caesar: this is not proper.
THEODOTUS (outraged): How!
CAESAR (recovering his self-possession): Pardon him. Theodotus: he is a barbarian, and thinks that the customs of his tribe and island are the laws of nature.
Please, stop pretending like everybody with a different opinion than yours are lunatics. I used “pretending”, because I don’t think that you really think so. Only stupid person would think that way! (I hope that the layers of my sarcasm are not totally unbearable) :)
But now, on a more serious note. So you really think that Affliction’s production would have been better without M-1? Care to argue?
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
by mikser on Nov 13, 2009 2:25 PM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Did you watch their last M1 show here in the states? M1 didnt do shit for affliction. Everything from production to promotion Affliction had to get someone else to do it.
M1 doesnt even have a promoters license.
You mean M-1 Global Breakthrough, the one which had a huge amount of problems and was at the last moment moved from California to Kansas? Yeah, I watched it. It was pretty much a production FAIL. But here is the thing:
1. it was a miracle that the event even took place. Instead of cancelling the show, they had to move it far away, without proper preparation etc.
2. Breakthrough’s production is much WORSE than the production of M-1 Challenge events, which are all the time organized in places all around the globe. So I claim that judging M-1’s production by looking at M-1 Global Breakthrough is the same as judging the popularity of UFC by the huge amount of free tickets UFC gave away for their LA show.
Like the commentator crew for Affliction2, which they got DIRECTLY from M-1? :) And unlike for the Strikeforce/UFC crews, I didn’t hear anyone complaining about their job. Yeah, M-1 did nothing… :))
Promoter’s license? The Bernard quote is very accurate, indeed. :) What you don’t understand, is that M-1 Global doesn’t work that way. It’s one of the advantages of co-promoting. Did you know that Affliction didn’t have a promoter’s license either? Sure you did, so why asking?..
It’s UFC who wants to do everything by itself. And they don’t even have their own PPV providing services, but are forced to buy it elsewere! What a bunch of loosers, aren’t they? :o)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
So the failure of M1’s last show is compared to Dana giving away tickets to a show that had a 1.8 million dollar gate?
Yeah I know Affliction didnt have a promoters license… isnt that where co-promotion makes sense? WITH SOMEONE WHO HAS ONE?
You’re comparing M1 not having a simple promoters license which even the smallest shows in the country have to the UFC not owning iNDEMAND Networks or a “Direct TV”?
I guess now I realize why you value M1 so much… you think having a promoters license is the same thing as owning DIrect TV.
isnt that where co-promotion makes sense? WITH SOMEONE WHO HAS ONE?
Both Affliction and M-1 handled “the problem” without any problems, so what’s your problem? :)
You’re comparing M1 not having a simple promoters license which even the smallest shows in the country have to the UFC not owning iNDEMAND Networks or a "Direct TV"?
Actually this makes it even worse for the UFC (from the standpoint of your argument). Because nobody buys a match factory if they needs only a few boxes of matches (going through the hell of getting a licence to organize only one event, if there are easier and better ways to get officially sanctioned by the partners). But when the UFC tries to control everything, but fails to control the PPV channel, which makes them hundreds of millions – then that’s a huge problem. At least compared to the “problem” of not having a promoters licence.
Anyway, just admit, that your argument was stupid and we won’t need to continue this “strangest allegories and arguments ever” contest.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
That is still a very bad comparison no matter how you try and put it. Having a promoters license is something that is easily available for a relatively low cost (even the smallest and poorest of local promoters have very little problem getting a promoters license and they just aren’t that hard to get) but a PPV distributer is a vastly larger and fundamentally different industry than MMA promotion, hell it’s normally a secondary department of the major tv service providers. Your comparing the act of filling out a handful of paperwork to creating a separate vast entertainment conglomerate. It’s a extremely ridiculous comparison that doesn’t even make sense on the most basic of levels. It’s not comparing apples and oranges it’s comparing one Apple to the Orange growing industry. Reading your post on this makes me wonder if you are actually understanding the subject matter in this particular area at all?
So what is required in getting a promoters license? Well in Nevada it’s not that complicated(and it should be similar for all State Athletic Commissions):
NAC 467.052 Application for license as promoter: Requirements; investigation; payment of costs; fees. (NRS 467.030, 467.100)http://www.leg.state.nv.us/NAC/NAC-467.html#NAC467Sec052
1. A person applying for a license as a promoter may be required to appear before the Commission and be prepared to prove his:
(a) Integrity;
(b) Financial stability; and
(c ) Knowledge of the responsibilities involved in the promotion of contests or exhibitions.
2. The applicant, or a person he has designated if approved by the Commission, must provide all waivers necessary to the conduct of the Commission’s investigation of the applicant’s suitability, including, but not limited to, providing consent to investigate the background of the applicant.
3. The Commission will require the applicant to pay any costs related to an investigation conducted pursuant to this section and may, when deemed appropriate by the Commission, require a deposit of money by the applicant in advance against those costs.
4. The fee for a promoter’s license is $500 per year.
5. The fee for an amateur boxing promoter’s license is $25 per year.
[Athletic Comm’n, § 168, eff. 4-25-78]—(NAC A 12-13-82; 11-2-88; 1-12-94; 12-2-97; R090-07, 12-4-2007)
Seems to me that there are only a couple of reason for not getting licensed if you are planning on promoting MMA events in the US and the one that sticks out the most is worrying about not being able to pass the background check.
by who me on Nov 14, 2009 11:45 AM EST up reply actions 1 recs
Pygmalion is the shit
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 3:55 PM EST up reply actions
The quote was from “Caesar and Cleopatra”.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
I know, Shaw is one of my favorite playwrights. I don’t expect to see too many Shaw references on the internet unless I go digging for them, so I’d thought I’d chime in on Pygmalion ;)
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 4:20 PM EST up reply actions
Don't forget
Todd Beard in some unofficial capacity. If I recall correctly he was the one that drove Randy back to the UFC (okay one reason Randy returned) and was the one going nuts on the call with Zuffa in late July. Great pick-up M-1.
M-1 sure knows how to pick the people to work with them. I wonder if Millen and Beard were not in the picture if things go down differently…
What does Fedor spend all his money on? Ice cream and sweaters only cost soo much?
for all intents and purposes, just consider all my posts as works of satire.
by Bandaka on Nov 13, 2009 8:15 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
Im gonna take a shot in the dark and say Fedor dosent really care about the money. Case and point, his house.
^ So much stupidity in the comments above, that I won’t even dare commenting all these “M-1 are crooks, Fedor is poor” kind of shasse… (Some of) you guys made me really sick!.. :(
Just a few important points:
1. M-1 helped Affliction a lot. Guys from M-1 have a decade long experience in MMA. Provided help definitely benefited novice Attencio (the T-shirt guy). This so called “consulting help” also included things like providing the commentary crew (they did it for Affliction2 and people were happy with the job they did; extremely low level of whining after the event).
2. M-1 has a separate contract with Fedor, according to which Fedor gets paid no matter what. And that contract is worth millions.
And now we come to the cultural stupidity ignorance.
3. Everybody in Russia live in apartments. Including the elites. Buying “a home” has connotation as buying “an apartment”. If you ask a “Why don’t you live in a real house” question from some Russian person, he would probably get offended and say “Who the hell do you think I am – a freaking peasant to live in a house in a village”. Village = house, city = apartments. As simple as that.
4. Apartments cost A LOT, even compared to the American or European prices. For example the cost of the highest end apartments in Moscow is more than $100k per square meter… Fedor doesn’t live in Moscow, but the general costs may be even more than in Moscow.
5. Russian apartments have their own type/style of design. Two of many characteristics include:
a) toilet and bathroom are separated (just to give you a little taste of the differences)
b) there are refuse chutes in every house on each floor
c) kitchens are very small
Therefore crying about “look at the size of Fedor’s kitchen – he must be living in a real shit-hole” is extremely far from the truth.
6. Fedor lives pretty well, as he can sustain his own family (housewife-culture is very often in Russia), gives money for his ex-wife and a child, and additionally to this, was able to buy his own apartment as well as to buy one for his mother! And I didn’t even got to financing his training, training partners, couches, sweaters, trucks of icecream etc…
This M-1 and Vadim’s bashing makes me real sad. :( Well, I wouldn’t mind if there was some kind of truth behind it, but all I hear and read is a BS level of arguments. And all this, despite the fact that Vadim is a real self-made businessman (unlike the majority of the rich people in Russia, who got their wealth by stealing and corruption: Khodorkovsky, Berezovsky, Prokhorov, Abramovich, etc), is an honest and down-to-earth man (according to everything that I read, know), who made much more for the development of MMA in Russia than what Dana did for the American MMA. And you can say whatever you want about “Vadim’t stupid lies about co-promotion”, but he really believes in it and acts accordingly as well. He helps other Russian promoters all the time, despite being a much more dominant leader than UFC is in the USA.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
by mikser on Nov 13, 2009 9:42 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
From whatever revenue M-1 Global has (consulting, TV-deals from all around the world, merchandise, PPV, live events, sponsors, etc etc). Basically that’s M-1’s problem where to get these millions. So far they have been fulfilling their contract agreement with Fedor, Mousasi and others, so everything is good.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
I came up with a few good answers. Please, pick and vote for your favourite! :)
1. UFC generates so much, that they have to hire a fitness instructor for their manager, who can’t manage anything, not fighters (A. Silva) and not even his own mouth.
2. UFC generates so much, that they can’t even provide with a decent salary, and he has to work part-time as a stand-up-comedian clown.
3. UFC generates so much, that the owners have to put themselves in gambling!
Which one did you pick? :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
lol, ok you didnt address why if M1 does so much they cant even afford to have Fedor fight on one of their own cards. And instead you’re talking about a guy who created a billion dollar business. If being a former fitness instructor makes you happy fine.
The owners were always in the gaming business before they bought the UFC but why this has anything to do with the discussion is beyond me.
I don’t know if you are joking right now or what, but the whole point of me making these three answers using the logic and argumentation you use, was to show you how stupid your comment was by turning the situation around and making three similarly stupid claims.
I’m ok with arguing on whatever level people choose to. If somebody is respectful and has proof/sources to back up his solid logic, so am I. But if somebody makes a stupid remarks all the time (like “Vadim is not to be trusted, because he is from Russia, which means that he is a member of mafia”), then I might make the similar kind of stupid arguments (“Dana is a crook, because the UFC is owned by the Las Vegas casino moguls – the industry in a city, both of which have long been known for their ties to mafia”).
As to not addressing the issue, please refer to my three stupid claims – try to understand what is wrong with them (despite them based only on the facts and being as truthful as your claim). Then you will hopefully understand what is wrong with your claim.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
btw. The second one was about Joe Rogan.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
You are a troll right?
You can’t be serious writing all these things in this thread :D
http://www.mmarocks.pl
https://twitter.com/mmarocks_pl
No, I am serious. :) Obviously with the exception of a few comments, where I hit mmalogic with the same weapon/logic he uses, like the one above (with three different answers).
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
I can’t figure out if you just don’t understand what you are talking about or if you think you are smarter than you really are but you are hard to follow if you are being serious. mmalogic can be a real ass but he knows what he is talking about most of the time and his logic process is fairly easy to follow, you seem to be all over the place and dodging talking about simple and direct points other people are making.
I have no beef with Fedor or M-1. For all I care they can demand a trillion dollars per round and as many side demands as they want. And I have no beef with Zuffa for saying no thanks. I just find it odd that both promotions, Bodog and Affliction, that M-1 has most recently co-promoted with (or consulted with) are now insolvent in a very little amount of time. If I’m wrong about that fact I apologize. I hold no animosity or ill will for Fedor (who I’ve long been a fan of) or M-1. My concern is for Strikeforce. I’m trusting that Scott wouldn’t make a deal that would be a big financial gamble, that’s all.
If M-1 has a decade of MMA promoting experience, and was a great help, etc… why didn’t they consult Affliction about payroll when they were negotiating for bout agreements?
Keep firing Assholes!
I am the King of Rome, and am above grammar. -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor
by Ubernoober on Nov 13, 2009 9:56 AM EST up reply actions 2 recs
I don’t know, I am not an insider. There can be few explanations (including the one, that they did consult, but Affliction didn’t listen), but these “explanations” are simply speculations.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
I can back you up on the apartment price comment
It is just ridiculous what the ratio of house price to average wage is in alot of the Eastern european countries.
Generally poor populace =/= affordable housing by any means. I almost vomited when I saw what ‘normal’ citizens had to pay for their place
And Moscow has long been listed as having the most expensive apartments in the world per square metre.
I doubt the ice-cream and sweaters cost him too much though, unless it is Haagen-Dazs. That shit is a joke price wise!
'He built his whole reputation as a waffle house chef. They’ve been serving him up ham and eggs with a side of canned tomatoes' - Don Frye on Fedor Emelianenko
by Well Read Idiot on Nov 13, 2009 10:31 AM EST up reply actions
Milkser,
Since you are the only here with any experience on the Russian mma front, I thought i would ask you a few questions to help me clear up a few questions i have regarding m-1:
1) Do you have any knowledge concerning Fedor’s contract with m-1? I know he holds a 20% stake in the company, but what about the contractual agreement they hold with him as a fighter?
2) What is the state of mma in Russia, and all the former Soviet States for that matter? Is there a hardcore audience that follows the UFC, Dream, and other larger organizations? What is the potential for growth inside Russia?
3) How active is m-1 in Europe now? I know they hold a number of events per year, but I have no clue how big or small they are? Is there an audience for their product? At what level would you currently rate their events? If you are familiar with the US scene, are they more along the lines of a small regional player or are they bigger than that?
Thank you ahead of time.
There are a lot of questions here… :) I will reply to them in a few days (probably via a separate fan post). But now to the bars! :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
So what did you think about Alex (fedors brother) coming out and saying Vadim is ripping Fedor off and manipulates the reality of the deals when he explains things to him?
here:
Aleks, yeah… That’s an excellent example of what I was talking about… I mean, only few of you realize, that Aleks is a total opposite of Fedor, that Aleks is completely full of shit, like he showed in his interviews (I mean, did killing a bear with a fork, ring anyone’s bell?) and with his action over the years. It’s best to say, that Aleks is a weird combination of Tito Ortiz and Ken Shamrock… And that is not a compliment (except for the part, that Aleks is very business and money oriented just like Tito; I guess it can be considered a good trait)!
Another cultural thing: being a manager in Russia is a totally different concept than being a manager in the USA. I mean, Vadim paid for Aleks’s living for who knows how many years, even though Aleks hardly fought anybody during that time (because of his sickness)…
So for Aleks to tell some shit about Vadim simply shows once again what kind of person Aleks really is. He probably did it to get attention, to suck up to Dana and to finally get himself in the UFC.
I could elaborate with his PR stunts. Like crazy story how he defended one girl and kicked hooligans’ asses. Or when he told that he would easily kick Brock’s ass. Or what kind of explanations he give to explain each of his loss (making an impression, that he never really lost). Or telling everybody that he is a “four-time world MMA champion”. Or bragging about his results (like the one, that he was better than Fedor in stand-up; when the people who have trained with him say otherwise: about his lack of speed etc)
His latest stupidity I heard about (there are most probably newer ones I didn’t hear about) was after Aleks’s first real boxing match (draw) when he was giving the interview in a locker-room. He said that he felt good after the match and that he could go represent the Russian track and field athletics team if asked. When asked, in what kind of sport, he said that he can do anything, even run a marathon… Can you imagine, Aleks running a marathon for a Russian team?.. The journalists couldn’t either and there was a loooong silence after Aleks’s answer… :))
I could go on and on, to talk about the difficult relationship between the brothers (when Fedor said, that Aleks was making a lot of stupid things, acting like an ass etc), but that would be pointless. I don’t trust Aleks at all, just the opposite.
Only one final observation. After Aleks left the Red Devil’s team, he bashed Vadim saying that they are crooks. But regardless of that, he fully attended the preparation camp Fedor had for his bout against Barnett. Rhetorical questions:
1. If Vadim/M-1 would have been really screwing something against the agreement, wouldn’t Vadim/M-1 do anything to not allow Aleks to attend the camp and talk with Fedor?
2. Aleks attended the camp and had a lot of time to talk with Fedor. If Aleks would really have some kind of information that Fedor is being screwed, wouldn’t Fedor get that information and do something about it? And since we know that he would (he left his previous camp of Russian Top Team when this kind of thing happened) and we know that he didn’t – doesn’t it mean, that Aleks didn’t have any relevant information? :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
Fedor has 2 more fights left with M1… what do you expect him to do even if he wanted to do something about it?
React at least somehow. Tell about it, starting to find another promotion/manager, sue M-1. Or at the very least, be pissed off at M-1/Vadim. Nothing happened.
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
someone works for m1
freedomwatchonfox.com lp.org
by baldspot23 on Nov 13, 2009 1:12 PM EST up reply actions 4 recs
If so it would be a great addition around here. We already have people from Zuffa and Strikeforce.
by nottheface on Nov 13, 2009 1:21 PM EST up reply actions 6 recs
A lot of the people who used to work for Affliction got jobs working at M-1,
Keep firing Assholes!
I am the King of Rome, and am above grammar. -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor
by Ubernoober on Nov 13, 2009 1:24 PM EST up reply actions 2 recs
comment of the week
We're just a million little gods causin' rain storms, turning every good thing to rust.
by Anthony Pace on Nov 13, 2009 1:48 PM EST up reply actions
Yeah, it would be nice, wouldn’t it…
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
Someone does. But not me. I have my own company (no MMA) and happy with it. :)
- mixed, not shaken
Editor-in-Chief: All About Russian Mixed Martial Arts (Fedor Emelianenko, Aleksander, M-1 Global,etc)
1. We all know about that stuff, we aren’t stupid here. As far as the commentary crew, are you serious? That was the commentary crew that included TIto Ortiz, Scott Ferrall and Chuck Zito, it has been joked/complained about as much as any other broadcast group there has ever been. That comment is so out in left field it makes me think you may be trolling with that one.
2. Do you know the details of Fedor’s contract with M-1 global? If not then your just guessing like the rest of us. I can’t imagine that it pays Fedor more than M-1 is making off events though, heck if probably means that even his base pay from Affliction went to M-1 first and that he only gets what comes directly from M-1. As far as being worth millions, well that means nothing too, if it pays $200k per fight for 10 fights then it would be worth “millions” but Fedor would still be getting royally screwed.
3. And? This isn’t a comparison between apartments and houses it’s that for what Fedor should be making he should be living in a mansion like other big names in MMA do. He should be making millions of dollars off each fight (promotions are paying someone that kind of money), even if he had a “house” people would still be scratching their heads, they look at the pictures of where they live and see that his place isn’t as nice as most of ours and it makes people wonder.
4. That doesn’t seem like all that much for a luxury apartment in Moscow to me. Big city real estate is always expensive, of course Stary Oskol isn’t anything remotely near “big city” size and Fedor isn’t living in anything that could be considered “luxury” anyway. Not sure what the point here is?
5. Yes housing all over the world has it’s own different style but that doesn’t mean that people looking at pictures can’t tell the difference between luxury housing and average housing though. It’s not that people think Fedor is living in a “shit hole” it’s that for the money generated off his fights people expect him to be living at a much higher level by any country’s style.
6. My father has a good friend with a Russian wife (well he has a number of good friends in Russia being as he works there), they have an apartment in Moscow, a house in Kentucky and a condo in Texas and they regularly fly back and forth between Russia and the US (they also have numerous cars and motorcycles among other things), she doesn’t work and he makes around $200k a year. They live a very fine life on a small fraction of what Fedor makes per fight including having a very nice place in Russia (heck I think they may have two places in Russia). For a guy who generates the money he does living “pretty well” is pretty damn sad. Not sure why that doesn’t click with you? We know he prefers a simplier life but good grief the man should be a multi-millionaire off just the last year and he has been on top of the industry for a very long time.
i’ve said it before and i’ll say it again. i applaud fedor and M1global for standing their ground. most people would sell out to the ufc and get treated like sh*t by dana and co. don’t get me wrong, i enjoy the ufc shows and the quality production, but i feel there’s plenty of room for other promotions to prosper. competition breeds quality. war fedor!
by stray on Nov 13, 2009 9:42 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
Motions to Dismiss... Federal Rules of Civil Procedure... 12(b)(6) is NOT LIMITED TO ISSUES OF LEGAL SUFFICIENCY... Check your facts before you write an article
12(b)(6) motions to dismiss for failure to state a claim can refer to both legal and factual sufficiency.
If the claim does not meet the “plausibility” standard as set by Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly (antitrust case) and by Ashcroft v. Iqbal (extended plausiblity beyond antitrust)… the complaint (claim) can be dismissed by a Rule 12(b)(6) motion. The plausibility standard requires that the claim contain sufficient factual matter in order for the claim to be plausible at face value and proper under Rule 8 (Iqbal and Twombly interpret Rule 8 to include plausibility standard). A claim in plausible at face value when the amount of factual matter, if assumed true, provides a basis for a federal judge to infer that the defendant is liable to the plaintiff for the allegations set forth in the claim.
Legal Case
I don’t know anything about the legal case and I really don’t care but I looked up Fedor’s attorney and he clearly isn’t your normal attorney. He has his blackbelt from Marco Ruas, another black belt from Joe Moreira in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu. He’s also ranked number 3 by Grappler’s Questin the US in the executive division over 200lbs. Not your everyday lawyer to say the least.

by 






![Fabricio Werdum talks about attempting to stop a robbery and having a gun pulled on him [at the 3:25 min mark]
Strikeforce: Fedor vs. Werdum coverage](http://cdn3.sbnation.com/fan_shot_images/135721/2_small.jpg)













