What Couture vs. Lesnar Means for the UFC Heavyweight Division
Fronted by Luke Thomas.
This weekend has brought an absolute storm in the blogoland, with rumors flying of Randy coming back to face Lesnar at UFC 91, in what will almost certainly be a title match, as the first fight in a three-fight deal. This matchup, and the other rumors about Randy's return, suggest all sorts of interesting possibilities.
Scenario 1: Couture beats Lesnar
If Couture beats Lesnar, this sets up two possible matchups for Randy. First is the unification match with the winner of Nogueira/Mir. The second and more interesting matchup is the rumor of a fight with Fedor:
The long-rumored heavyweight superfight between UFC champion Randy Couture (16-8 MMA, 8-5 UFC) and WAMMA champion Fedor Emelianenko (28-1 MMA, 0-0 UFC) is currently being discussed for an as-yet-unspecified date in January or February of 2009.
I suggested in a previous fanpost that the matchup would never happen. Both my own and other people's analysis has been that the UFC would never build up Fedor just so he could fight elsewhere. But the UFC has access to better numbers than any of us. Its quite possible that they have run the calculus and concluded that the UFC is now untouchable by any upstart company grabbing top fighters: the cost of the top fighters would make it impossible to build brand equity and achieve break-even before going under. I figured it would be a few more years before this would be the case, but the struggles Affliction has encountered suggest that perhaps the day is already here. If it indeed is, the UFC doesn't have to worry about Fedor going elsewhere, because he costs too much for upstart promotions to survive his paycheck.
If a Randy/Fedor fight comes to fruition, the winner of Nog/Mir might be able to fight Werdum in the meantime. Afterwards, the title could be unified, or Randy's piece of the title could be retired if Fedor wins and then leaves.
Lesnar beats the crap out of Cheick Kongo in his rebound fight.
Scenario 2: Lesnar beats Couture
Lesnar's victory would propel him to the top of the UFC and a unification match against the winner of Nog/Mir. Either fight presents opportunities for the UFC. I personally think the Nog/Mir season of TUF will not be adequate to make Nog a star, as Mir simply isn't the right foil. A Lesnar/Nogueira fight is win/win for the UFC: either Lesnar beats Nogueira and legitimizes himself as an elite fighter, or Lesnar pounds the crap out of Noguiera and gets subbed at the last minute, and Nogueira becomes a superstar.
Alternately, the UFC gets a rematch of Mir/Lesnar. While this should do great PPV numbers, there is a real risk of Lesnar getting subbed again, which would put him in Rich Franklin limbo if Mir dominates the division for a while to come.
Stop laughing.
Couture's possibilities at this point become a lot more open ended. He could fight the loser of Nogueira/Mir. He could still fight Fedor as a superfight. He could drop down to 205 and have a fight with Rampage or a rematch with Tito, or another fight with Liddell. Potential money matches abound. Alternately, if he wants to stretch his career out a little further, he might take a rebound fight and draw the "demolish Cheick Kongo" card.
Regardless, this matchup suddenly saves what looked like a wasteland in the UFC HW division. Nog/Mir was a stopgap fight, which would be followed by a stopgap fight with a Werdum title shot, which would have been followed by. . . who knows. This matchup makes Nog/Mir a lot more interesting, and also pushes Werdum's title shot back while adding the possibility of Fedor sticking around. By the time the free-for-all settles down, one or both of Velasquez and Carwin should have reached contendership level, and Lesnar, win or lose, will be a top threat. What was a barren division a week ago suddenly looks ripe with possibility.
The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.
2 recs |
7 comments
Comments
I think the UFC has actually thought this through a bit and realised that however this plays out, it can’t be as bad as it is at the moment. What’s the worse case scenario – Couture loses to Lesnar, or Couture beats Lesnar but then loses to Fedor with Fedor then buggering off. Either of those scenarios leaves you with a champion in Nog, who isn’t really recognised as one and a fairly worthless heavyweight division/belt – pretty much the situation as it stood last week Having said that, the first of the 2 scenarios described, does have the upshot of making an even bigger star of Lesnar, and legitimising him somewhat). There’s also the upshot of these fights being huge, and excellent short term money makers, especially if they could get them on network TV somehow.
Obviously, the results could go in the UFC’s favour – in which case the potential benefits are tremendous.
by -Sam on Sep 2, 2008 10:26 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
winner of couture-lesnar will face winner of nog-mir…
There is only one possibility of couture fighting fedor… and that is if the deal between affliction and finkie was orchestrated only to get a signing bonus.
See Affliction only has a US exclusive if an org were to sign fedor to an anywhere but US exlcusive then there is a chance and only if finkie didnt give away first rights…
meaning if affliction only has fedor in the US IF he is not booked for an oveseas fight then you can pretty much negate that contract by booking him fights overseas whenever affliction wants to book him.
Its a long shot… but make no mistake UFC will not promote fedor unless he is locked up.
by mmalogic on Sep 2, 2008 11:55 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
If it indeed is, the UFC doesn’t have to worry about Fedor going elsewhere, because he costs too much for upstart promotions to survive his paycheck.
I still think it’s kind of dumb for the UFC to not lock in Fedor, but that being said, you make a good point about Fedor’s price point. He may eventually price himself out of reality for most MMA promotions, if he hasn’t already done so.
by pud333 on Sep 2, 2008 12:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
so if Fedor is signed to a no compete in the U.S. clause with affliction, doesn’t tha mean he could possibly fight on a UFC in england or somewhere else in europe?
by asmiley420 on Sep 2, 2008 1:17 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Josh Gross reported that Fedor’s deal with Affliction leaves him with a window to fight Couture in the UFC, no strings.
by Michaelthebox on Sep 2, 2008 2:04 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Fedor will never fight in the UFC unless he is locked in… you heard it here first.
by mmalogic on Sep 2, 2008 3:22 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
mmalogic has spoken the correct.
http://mma4real.net/
by Tha Realness on Sep 2, 2008 4:06 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 


















