Bloody Elbow: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Edgar Renteria is a San Francisco Giant Bar-right-arrows



Brian Stann and BJ Penn Agree About the Guard

How do they agree? They both believe being on your back is a guaranteed way to lose a fight with the judges in modern MMA (Penn's comments are in his book):

“I am completely comfortable to go to the ground in a fight,” he said. “I use my takedown defense because I have a better chance to end the fight using my hands. And if I’m going to go to the ground, I’m going there on my own terms, not on somebody else’s terms. I mean, I don’t care who you are, I don’t care if you are a BJJ black belt and a world champion at it, you do not want to be on your back in mixed martial arts anymore. Statistically it’s the worst place in a fight to be, the judges view it as you losing the fight regardless of what’s going on. So I’m not going to let somebody put me on my back, I refuse to do it. But I have no problems going to the ground whatsoever. If the fight does go to the ground I think people will soon realize the level of my jiu jitsu.”

As for Stann's jiu-jitsu, we'll see. But as much as it pains me to admit, he's right about how judges view being on your back and the guard. Even if you're throwing up submissions attempts and making it impossible for your opponent to pass, they view the back to the mat as a priori defensive position. To some extent it is, but I cannot erase from my memory the absolute robbery of Renato Verissimo in his fight with Matt Hughes. What I worry about is that even if judges become more competent about the intracacies of the guard and jiu-jitsu as a whole, fighters will follow Stann's path and alter their game so as to never be on their back as long as they can help it. I'd hate for a unique dimension of the game to be avoided because of a legacy of incompetent judging.

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Read Related

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

As MMA judges become more savvy about the subtle movements, both offensive and defensive, that happen when a fighter is in guard, perhaps scoring will change. But, yeah, the way the game has changed, a lot of fighters seem to favor working in their opponents guard, or attacking from mount or side control. The thing that made the guard effective in the old days was lack of time limits, which made it easier for Royce Gracie to wait for an opponent to make a mistake, then spring a submission from his back. The guard is still very effective, but it takes a master to finish the fight from his back, especially with the time limits, and the pressures of booing fans who want to see slugfests.

by Cmad77 on Jul 30, 2008 5:27 PM EDT   1 recs

Great post Cmad.

It’s definitely changed. I hate when the crowds boo. If two guys are standing up and not throwing a punch, a kick, or trying to shoot, then I understand. Most of the time they are on the ground working for something. Most of the crowd though are drunks who don’t give a crap about the sport, they just want to see someone get beat up.

Rob Dib
http://www.break-your-face.com

by Rob Dib on Jul 30, 2008 6:08 PM EDT   0 recs

I think things are getting better, both judges and fans are developing more of an understanding of the submission game.

More work needs to be done, but it is better than in the past.

Personally, I think more seminars should be done for judges.

by Lynchman on Jul 30, 2008 11:29 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

"All men are frauds. The only difference between them is that some admit it. I myself deny it." -- H.L. Mencken

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Bloodyelbow_small
Lorenzo Fertitta Talks to The Atlantic
Covershotf4a1
TUF's Controversy Sends Wrong Message About MMA
Small
Diego Sanchez: I'm dropping down to fight at 155???
Bloodyelbow_small
"S-Cup 2008" Shootboxing Tournament Gifs
Small
Why New York Matters

Recent FanPosts

Small
Station Casinos to File For Bankruptcy?
Benzeidler_thumbnail_small
Lyoto Machida Interview
Photo_43_small
Dana White to Appear on NBC's "Momma's Boys"
Small
Enzo Maccarinelli interested in MMA
Blackgoldfist_small
Dana White: Lyoto Machida Is Anderson Silva's Successor
Bloodyelbow_small
WEC 37 Undercard Results
Blue_you_small
PENN vs PIERRE II in Links
Sam_knife_mo_small
Finalized TUF 8 Finale Card

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Meter