I'm Sorry...
I've been a firm Kimbo supporter on this site. I've defended him and Elite XC as much as possible against the thought process that somehow this would be "bad for the sport."
And I am sorry for that.
I don't blame Kimbo for what happened. But Elite XC showed exactly the kind of organization that it is. The "chosen" fighter was obvious in almost every fight but nowhere was that more obvious than the main event.
Dan Miragliotta is either crooked or incompetent and if he is crooked then it would appear he isn't the only one. As posted earlier one of judges actually scored the second round for Kimbo Slice 10-9. This despite the fact that he was dominated for all but a few moments of the round and was on the verge of being stopped for over a minute.
Miragliotta managed to tell Thompson that he needed to do more and "work" while he was securing a crucifix, he stood the fighters up mere seconds after Thompson secured side control earlier in the fight, and he stopped the fight either because he totally misread the situation or because a bleeding ear is now of great danger to fighters.
Elite XC on CBS was not good for the sport. If we're lucky this will soon be forgotten, if we're not lucky then the most important fight in the history of MMA from an exposure standpoint looks to even the untrained eye to be fixed.
EXC is not a mature promotion and they were completely ill equipped to handle the stage they were given. The result is a show that failed the sport.
And I'm sorry that I failed to see that prior to now.
121 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Agreed
I don’t feel like posting right now because the sport that I have watched and supported for close to 10 years just got made a complete fool of. But I agree with you 100%
After Thompson’s ear popped, he got hit with a shot or two that made his eyes go all
googley and he was clearly out on his feet. This wasn’t the first time in the bout
either. That’s why it was stopped.
Sure, Kimbo was given more opportunities to win via questionable reffing, but he wasn’t taking much damage from the elbows. Thompson was playing patty-cake and that’s why he was told to work and why it wasn’t stopped in the 2nd.
Kimbo was placed...
...in a position where he could not defend himself. And he didn’t try to defend himself. He didn’t work to get out of the position, he just ate elbow after elbow and punch after punch. If he isn’t defending himself it doesn’t matter how powerful the strikes are. During the stoppage I think Thompson was able to defend himself much better than Kimbo was moments earlier.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:00 AM EDT up reply actions
Sheep
Just stop. Seriously. If that was a proper stoppage then the fight shoulda been stopped when the Thompson was owning him for a min straight. The ref was in on the Fix. He tried to stand the fight up every time kimbo was on his back. Just a horrid example of MMA to the masses.
Why didn’t the ref stop it in the second when Thompson looked glassy-eyed? Then he recovered and proceeded to pound Kimbo on the ground. The reffing was more than questionable.
by Cannon Jacques on Jun 1, 2008 1:00 AM EDT up reply actions
In total, Thompson was getting knocked silly each round and Kimbo was getting dominated and tired out. For a prime-time TV fight audience, the puncher wins. That’s the key here. With a national audience, it’s a slightly different game (and Kimbo just happens to be taylor made for that product).
Nope...
...the live crowd was made up almost entirely of casual fans. And they were booing slice after the fight. That doesn’t seem like a case of “the puncher wins” in the eyes of the casual fans to me.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:13 AM EDT up reply actions
Okay, Brent, you’ve cornered me into specifying that it’s “in the producers eyes” that I’m talking about. But don’t you agree that decisions are bound to be made to make the sport more palatable to the mainstream (even if some of those choices aren’t immediately popular)?
They’re selling the Kimbo product and he stepped up his game in a number of ways. If Thompson hadn’t been stopped, he probably would have eaten many more shots every time the fight was on its feet during that round and it would have been too gruesome for MMA’s network TV debut. It’s partially Thompson’s fault for showing up with that floppy growth on his head. A real distraction and seeing it pop was “as Mauro said” the beginning of the end.
thats weak
you don’t stop a fight if his eyes are “googley” while he is still on his feet period. If he is on his back ok but NOT when he is still on his feet !
The chicken-dance doens’t qualify as “not intelligently defending yourself”. However, BJ Penn was once in a crucifix for approximately 30 seconds, and I didn’t hear anyone bitching about the stoppage.
I imagine that has something to do with the people that watched the Kimbo fight probably have never seen BJ Penn and Matt Hughes.
Unfortunately, my DVR cut off just before the main event, so I have yet to see Kimbo v. Thompson.
As for media reaction, ESPNews just had their 30 second clip covering the main event, and they made it sound like everything was on the up and up, only mentioning that Thompson was upset with the decision to stop the fight, thus he pushed the referee.
Generally...
...you’re not going to get a major news outlet to say that something was fishy…especially this early on.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:01 AM EDT up reply actions
ESPN really doesn’t have a good handle on MMA yet, anyway. Anybody that knows anything about MMA knows this wasn’t right for one reason or another.
by Cannon Jacques on Jun 1, 2008 1:03 AM EDT up reply actions
That is the main reason why. Additionally, I’m under the impression ESPN didn’t have anyone covering the event, so like Brent said, it’s early for comment. A lot of this also has to do with the event not being as big of a deal as most of us would like to believe it would be.
It’s not completely fair to compare it to a big time boxing match, but what the hey. If De La Hoya v. Mayweather had been stopped under similar circumstances, and again, I’m going strictly off of a 30 second highlight reel of Kimbo v. Thompson, then you’d better believe not only would there be an ESPN presence at the event, but that Teddy Atlas, or Brian Kenny, or whomever, would be brought on to either crush the promoter and/or commission or explain to viewers why the issue is being blown out of proportion. America loves a good controversy, whether it’s steroids in Baseball or dirty refs in Basketball. The latter, of course, more directly comparable to tonight’s goings on.
I’d like to offer another possibility. It seems to me that the referees and ringside doctor(s) were instructed to err heavily on the side of caution in order to mitigate the inevitable columns decrying the horrible brutality of MMA. This, of course, is along the same lines as fixing a fight outright, and while slightly more palatable, it is wrong nonetheless.
Dana has been right all along..
Now its all clear why Dana wants control. Its clear now that CBS didnt want real MMA fights. Loaded with early stoppages, a fix in par with a TNA wrestling match and a ref that took a shady pay off.
I am truly disgusted, its like my dog died. Elite XC took the only sport I loved and in one 3 hour hip hop, go go dancing show… raped it.
The annoucing however was great, Gina, and the UFC alums did well.
Good article though Brent.
by lawdogk on Jun 1, 2008 1:01 AM EDT reply actions 1 recs
It might not of been CBS’ fault…but you’re foolish if you think they didn’t have a hand in how the whole thing was packaged.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 2:47 AM EDT up reply actions
Same thing happened with my DVR. Sux.
In the balance, I think the real story here is that we saw Kimbo fight like a real MMA fighter and he was largely successful. His cardio was a problem and doomed him to a couple minutes on his back, but he still came back and delivered the punching power that has made him famous. End of story. Who’s next for Kimbo?
Obviously...
someone with less of a ground game then Thompson
The site is running really well to be handling all of this traffic. Good for you guys at the Elbow. I hope this has stimulated your hits.
You know...
...sunshine through the storm clouds is that “hey, at least it’ll be good for traffic.”
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:09 AM EDT up reply actions
Brent, Step Back From the Ledge.
I think everyone obviously needs to sleep on this one for a night and resume posting when you are more level headed. From the tone of Brent’s post, I would picture him to be a weeping mess right now. This is not going to destroy our beloved sport that we have all been nurturing in our collective womb for so many years now. You are not going to see credible news outlets call this a fix without any hard evidence (except Yahoo! currently on their front page – anyone surprised?), and it’s pretty irresponsible for Bloody Elbow to announce such on their front page. Was this a controversial stoppage? Absolutely. Was it the most controversial stoppage I’ve ever seen? No. Was it the second most controversial stoppage I’ve ever seen? Nope. At the end of this event, 90% of fans are shaking their heads in disbelief of the officiating. So what’s new?
I think that once everyone, especially Brent, sleeps on it, people are going to be much less willing to declare this MMA’s “Donaghy Reffing Scandal.”
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
It isn't just the potential "fix"
It is everything that EXC showed. I really expected them to eliminate the dancing girls, and all the other horrible aspects of their production.
I am just sorry that I believed that EXC was capable of handling the stage they were given. I think they proved they couldn’t handle it.
Now let me go back to my corner and cry!
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:32 AM EDT up reply actions
Not only were the dancing girls horrible, but the appearance by Busta Rhymes was sooooooo lacking. Nothing says desperate like grabbing a washed-up hip hop star and shelling out literally tens of dollars on the the other filler “entertainment”.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 2:53 AM EDT up reply actions
Ewww
Collective womb? Seriously? Creepy metaphor, dude. :-)
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
Yea, I know. That was one of those “stream of consciousness” things that I looked back and was slightly puzzled myself. It does give you a warm feeling sort of… Right? Nevermind.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 10:17 AM EDT up reply actions
In defense of EXC
Bryan posted this on June 1st, 2008 @ 1:20:57 am
YouTube link to the Final Round [youtube.com]
I don’t really follow MMA because I think it’s sort of boring, but just from what I watched on YouTube I’m stoked that Kimbo is fighting. That was awesome! For once I was really “into” this MMA stuff. So much fuckin blood!!!
So while it may be “the worst thing that could have possibly happened for MMA” it’s the best thing as far as ad revenue goes, because I (and I assume many others) will DEFINITELY watch the next Kimbo fight! Dude was an animal!
It’s sometimes hard for people who are so involved in mma to see the outsider’s persepctive.
Hopefully there are a few million others who share my friend’s opinion.
I still think...
...that the fact that Kimbo was getting boo’ed shows that most people don’t feel that way.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:32 AM EDT up reply actions
These same fans were also booing after the first minute of the Lawler/Smith fight.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 1:36 AM EDT up reply actions
You’re using a Youtube comment by someone who’s probably 12-years old to further your argument?
Have you seen any of the other trash posted on those boards?
Between the idiots posting “first” or inflaming some sort of race war against just about every color/creed on the planet…that’s not a very credible place to look.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 2:58 AM EDT up reply actions
Well...
...I wouldn’t say the fight was stopped just because Thompson’s ear was popped. He got beat standing and couldn’t get the fight back on the ground.
Early stoppages, late stoppages, yadda yadda.
So did anyone expect this to be the next UFC event? The fights were good for what they were.
Exactly.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 1:46 AM EDT up reply actions
Uh
The Carano/Young fight wasn’t lousy. The drama beforehand, sure. But they fought like warriors – too bad they were given so little respect that they had to fight 3-minute rounds. Gina might have gassed, or Kaitlin might have been KO’s in a real match, and now we’ll never know.
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
Well
You can’t blame the fighters for that – it’s management making that decision. And I agree that it’s bullshit.
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
Sad sad sad
This is how the mainstream media viewed the fight. Un fucking believable.
“Kimbo Slice manhandles Thompson in bloody EliteXC TV showcase”
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2008/mma/05/31/elitexc.primetime/?cnn=yes
Amateur hour: On top of everything, DVR cuts off Kimbo
Having returned from a night out, excited to watch MMA’s debut on CBS, I feel betrayed that my DVR cut off before the main event. UFC allows for long fights by showing undercard bouts. Several fights were first round KOs, yet my DVR cut off the main event. Clearly, CBS needed to allow more than a two hour window (what would have happened if a few of those early fights went into deep water?). Overall I agree that all the stoppages were early and I chalk it up to being afraid the mainstream audience would freak out. I wish I could comment on the Kimbo controversy, but CBS didn’t care enough to schedule their night properly.
Come on now...
...if you were watching live and got an extra 30 mins you’d have been happy right (I ask because I am always happy to have more fight time than less)? That’s what the “this event is live…would you like to add time?” feature is for on DVR’s.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:44 AM EDT up reply actions
Look at it from a marketing standpoint
The most hyped fight of the night got cut off on DVR. Yes, I’m an idiot for not recording the next show in case it went over—I foolishly believed CBS had its act together and that it would be like UFC, with enough time built into the scheduled broadcast just in case not every match ended in a one minute KO. But believe me, I’m not the only guy in America that went out this Saturday night and missed the Kimbo fight because of the poor scheduling. And if you’re trying to get EliteXC over, losing a decent percentage of the audience on the main event doesn’t help. Sorta reminds me of the debacle when UFC’s pay-per-view cut off.
It went past the next show, too. I normally allow a half hour for stuff like this. I still would have missed the second half of the fight had I done that.
Is your Tivo all filled up with episodes of Sponge Bob or something? Record an extra 30 hours if you must. Just don’t bitch about missing it because they ran over their contracted block of programming.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 3:02 AM EDT up reply actions
Dude…it’s called a LIVE sports event. That’s why you add another hour or more to the end of the recording. Did you just hook up your Tivo this morning?!? Jesus!
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 3:01 AM EDT up reply actions
To me, what makes this such a controversial stoppage, was not the actual end call in and of itself, although it is definitely controversial. It’s the reffing from start to finish. The stand up from when Thompson gets side control, to the constant berating of Thompson to improve his position when he’s getting the crucifix, to the non stoppage when it was clear, for a full minute or more, Kimbo had NO idea how to get out, and was eating elbow after elbow.
I don’t know what was in Miragliotta’s water before the fight, but either he’s A) An incompetent referee. Or B) He’s crooked. Either way, doesn’t look good for him.
There’s no actual proof of fight fixing, but the shit-ass reffing and the wacky scoring on the second round makes me think something is definitely wrong here.
Say what you want about Dana and the UFC, but they put out a quality, honest product. When you have casual fans at the show booing the winner of the main event, that’s gotta tell you something.
I, like many people, wanted this card to be good. Heck, I wanted this to be decent. I knew EliteXC was no UFC, but c’mon. Maybe I’m letting the debacle of the main event overshadow the rest of the card, but I think this was just terrible.
correct me please
when has mma judging ever been consistent or logical?
the same judges judge all the fights. Can’t blame exlite xc for that.
Same with the reffing. After almost every card, theres at least 1 questionable stoppage.
Yeah, the judging can be off at times, but a 10-9 round for Kimbo in the second? C’mon. Even my friend who knows nothing about MMA felt Kimbo got beat that round, especially in the end with the crucifix. Thompson had him down for a full two minutes, the last minute of which he had pretty much secured the crucifix. Kimbo had no answers. He wasn’t intelligently defending himself. Just laid there and took it. In my mind, if they were gonna stop the fight, it should have been then. Should have never been a third round.
2nd round
Not saying I agree but I can understand the 2nd round going to Kimbo. Thompson was 2 seconds from getting KTFO in the middle of the round. I actually said, hes going down in 10 seconds while I was watching it. That said he did recover and control the rest of the round. Still if I had to base the round on who did more damage, I can see giving it to Kimbo. The love taps on the ground were close to doing any damage.
I’d still give it to Thompson, since damage isn’t everything. He had control, take downs, the crucifix… But yeah, I thought Thompson was going down early in the second. If anything, I was actually really impressed with Thompson’s chin tonight. Kimbo laid a couple bombs on him. Usually Thompson goes down if there’s a strong wind in the room.
PrideXC?
I think it’s that some people think there was some money floating around for people who helped the fights go a certain way. I’m not so sure yet because there’s nothing concrete, but there’s always shady business in sports.
What? I thought Santa Claus oversaw all of this?
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 1:56 AM EDT up reply actions
Nope…you’re mistaken. It’s the Easter Bunny that’s in charge of this stuff. If he’s unavailable, only the Tooth Fairy can step in.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 3:05 AM EDT up reply actions
Tonight would have been a good night to do “Any Given Saturday.”
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
AGS...
...will be back tomorrow after WEC and I’m sure Luke plans on covering this event.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 1:56 AM EDT up reply actions
Was anyone else chuckling when ...
Thompson appeared to have a kimura locked in, then he just let it go. It looked like he was thinking to himself, “hey look at this arm here. I think I’m supposed to grab his wrist and them put my other arm around this way. Wait …. now what I’m I supposed to do? Ah screw it.”
Haha. I saw that too. I actually saw it a few times from both of them. Kimbo looked like one of these new MMA fans you see at bars wearing the TapOut shirts that get in a fight and try to apply a submission on the other guy.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 2:15 AM EDT up reply actions
Sloppy fight--looked like something on YouTube and in a backyard
OK, I got a chance to see the Kimbo fight thanks to the miracle of the internetz (no thanks to CBS). It was stupid and sloppy all the way through. Did Kimbo really try a “DDT”? What’’s next, jumping off the top rope? Kimbo had no guard whatsoever (Bas Rutten should be ashamed). In the second round, when Thompson is raining elbows in a crucifix, the fixer … ahem, ref … says “Nothing going on.” Huh? Neither of these slobs had the cardio to go beyond the first couple minutes; they trained for a gong and dash and that’s it. No fighter should be allowed to enter the ring with an ear like Thompson’s. What’s next, Kimbo fights a guy with a broken arm? Or a dude without a mouthpiece? If a tomato can like Thompson gives you trouble on the ground, imagine how Kimbo would fare against a fighter who actually had a modicrum of jiu-jitsu and wasn’t hand picked because he likes to charge across the ring into his opponent’s fist. I think this fight clearly exposed Kimbo as someone who will never be a legitimate MMA contender. Thank you, Brett, for this post—it takes a big man to admit when he’s wrong.
2nd round
To me, this was a ridiculous fight to score. No real takedowns, poorly executed submissions, and zero power from JT.
So where did that leave me? With Kimbo’s power shots.
I had Kimbo winning on that basis alone. Sorry, but one big, damaging strike counts more in my eyes than fifty tippy-tap elbows and punches.
In no way should the fight have been stopped in the 2nd round. JTs “assault” was laughable.
I think what we saw in the stoppage was not “let’s protect Kimbo”, but rather “let’s not let this get to brutal on CBS prime time”.
So in that sense, I just don’t see network prime time being the place for mma. The fights should not be affected by the broadcasting situation, which is what i think we saw tonight.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
Bloody Good Prognostication
I think you guys called it earlier. Looks like Kimbo finally earned a shot at Butterbean.
by swarmofkillermonkeys on Jun 1, 2008 2:54 AM EDT reply actions
CALL TO ARMS
ok, ok, ok….the fight was rigged yes that is obvious. so now what, what are we as a fan base going to do. this is not a polite suggestion, this would be more of a warning call to all of those who have claimed that they love this sport and would like to see it grow. i for one will not be watching this organization’s events. this will do nothing but hurt the growth of MMA. MMA is to young of a mainstream sport to handle or even validate this type of corruption. Kimbo slice may have won, but the sport lost. this, unfortunately, was predicted.
That would be great. Of all of the possible impediments to MMA growth, I bet no one would have expected to see its fans block it. Easy there with the neighborhood watch organizing.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 3:24 AM EDT up reply actions
Of course, another way to put that would be to say “be sure to support the other non-UFC and organizations to ensure a healthy diversity of MMA events and promotions instead”.
by swarmofkillermonkeys on Jun 1, 2008 3:32 AM EDT up reply actions
I’m going to try and be an optomist and hope the next show is a marked improvement over this one. I’m sure a lot of organizations first few live shows were as messy as this one.
Kimbo was clealy exposed, but maybe he’ll gett better as a result and start training with other people besides baas rutten. Maybe some time at team quest or pat militich’s team will improve his game. Maybe he is just a flash in the pan, but maybe he can get better. I will give them another chance because i like to watch free mma fights. Call me an optomist.
Also, did it appear that kimbe tapped out for a second there when he was getting chocked out?
No, he was giving a thumbs up saying to the ref that all was cool.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 4:00 AM EDT up reply actions
Enough Already
no other organization has more bull sh*t fights.hey Luke this is why people don’t like him ok or we over him yet?.they could have avoided this if they didn’t make him the face of their organization.if they would have kept him on the under card where he belonged and not billed him as the second coming of Christ.they had so much hype it was almost laughable if it weren’t so pathetic.watching an elite xc event is like watching mad tv do a parody of mma and then trying to compare it to actual mma.people who have seen Thompson fight before know that he has won fights when he was tired throwing those zombie punches.also he was taking kimbozo down pretty consistently.what does it tell you when all those people who were booing Thompson turned on kimbozo by the end of the fight.
It’s called grammar and punctuation. Learn how to use it properly.
Adoptive papa to Omar...so basically I'm screwed.
by PacBellBoozer on Jun 1, 2008 4:02 AM EDT up reply actions
Awww. Someone likes the word “kimbozo”.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
by TheFightJournal on Jun 1, 2008 4:25 AM EDT up reply actions
Well...
...to be fair that seems a little pety. If he was called Kimbo growing up that kind of thing can stick with you.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 10:30 AM EDT up reply actions
A few conclusions...
Here are a few conclusions after saturday night’ show:
1) 99% probability CBS cancels Elite XC. This was already pretty much done as you can see the next shows date was canceled without any further notice. It doesnt matter what the numbers are the decision was already 90% made before this aired – call it buyers remorse from CBS. It went up to 99% because CBS is looking at a few fcc fines for the foul language that was aired.
- sponsors for the show are already getting emailed to stop sponsoring this show so imagine what CBS is hearing.
2) Dana White & CO knows something most of these bloggers and writers dont…
and that’s: MMA is not ready for network TV. It is better off on Cable and Pay Per View.
If you want MMA on network TV it will be watered down.
3) Elite XC is bad for the sport.
These ex-boxing promoter scum bags want to come in and corrupt our sport for a quick buck.
And most of these writers and bloggers (except for bloody elbow) seem to be giving them a pass… this is not fair to the legit promoters out there.
Where are the real journalists? All we see are cheerleaders who are making excuses for elite XC. Maybe because these geeks finally got credentials to a show?
Hey Josh Gross… get your four eyes in gear and write an open letter to Gary Shaw and tell him to get the fuck out of our sport.
This scumbag is bringing boxings disease to MMA.
I remember your hypocritical letter you wrote Dana on the steroids issue when you were the editor of a site who would continually cover promotions who never test and rank fighters who competed in these promotions.
This probably why Josh Gross won't write Gary Shaw a letter.
Josh Gross hid this corruption for years.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fdw2LMjRmoM
GO FOR THE NOKOUT NOT THE TAPOUT!
Brent
I gotta tell you, out of all the writers on this site I agree with your opinions the least. But you made a fan for life today with this article. It took a man to put this in print, and I admire you for it. Good job and I for one will look forward to reading you in the future.
As for EliteXc, I hope you get canceled and go far, far away. I will never forgive Gary Shaw for the damage he did to my sport. He set us back to 2004 in my opinion tonight. And one guy that deserves some heat but is usually untouchable in the hardcore fans eyes, Bas Rutten should be ashamed. He used his name and his clout to lend legitimacy to Kimbo, and it bit back hard tonight. Kimbo is not what they thought he was, he may be someday. but he was not ready for this type of responsibility. And as his trainer he should have stepped up and stopped this. Bas, you helped bring the sport to where it is, and now you helped bring it back to where it was. Thanks for nothing.
Just my two cents
It seems most of you who are commenting right now are avid fans of MMA (rightfully so), so I feel compelled to give you guys an opinion from someone who doesn’t follow it nearly as regularly. If you want to completely disregard my thoughts so be it, thought it can’t hurt.
First off, my background with MMA:
I find MMA very, very interesting and entertaining, yet I don’t find it something that I go out of my way to watch. If, flipping through the channels, I stumble upon it, I will more often than not watch it. I suppose part of that is due to my general lack of knowledge about the sport. I am an avid sports fan, I follow far too much (from baseball to soccer to cricket to etc etc), which I suppose prevents me placing too much focus on learning about it. So I have seen a fair number of UFC fights when cmpared to the general public at large.
I will also add before I get to my actual thoughts, that I was rooting for Kimbo to prove himself to be a legitimate MMA fighter. I caught wind of his youtube vids a while back and was enthralled by them. I thought perhaps that his methods would lend themselves to boxing (I freely admit that I could be very wrong there), but thought if he worked on his ground game he could be a fair fighter.
Anyway, enough of the prose, onto my thoughts
The pagenty surrounding the fights were ridiculous. Honestly, the dancers? I was tuning in tonight to see A.) Kimbo Slice B.) Some quality fights on the undercards. I didn’t need all that other nonsense.
As far as B.) is concerned, I was fairly impressed with some of the fights but disappointed by others. As others on the site have already gotten into, some of the stoppages were curious, though it may lend EliteXc some credibility that all the fights seemed to be stopped with them erring on the side of caution. Consistency in that regard helps, I reckon.
Now for A.) I’m still a bit confused by it all. First and foremost, I was definitely excited while watching it, though I realized that it was definitely not a well fought fight by say UFC standards. After Kimbo got up from his back the first time, I thought that maybe all his work on his ground game had paid off, but once he got tired it seemed that he regressed greatly. I can’t imagine the state of his ground game prior to this fight if he looked so poor and helpless this time out.
In the second round, I thought that the fight was going to be stopped for sure when Kimbo was prone for over a minute. I was rooting for the clock to wind down, thus saving his ass, but it was obvious (at least to the extent of my knowledge) that since he was prone, and didn’t even seem to attempt to get out that the fight should have been called. Hell, had it not been for the bell, Kimbo would still be catching elbows.
In the third, the ref may have stopped the fight a touch early, but had it not stopped there, I think it would have been stopped soon there after. In my eyes, at least, Thompson looked dazed on his feet and I’m sure Kimbo would have continued attacking his ear which would only increase the blood flow. I think the amount of blood coming out made the extent of the injury look worse than it actually was but considering it was on CBS I figure that had to play into the decision to stop.
Overall, I enjoyed watching the fights, but it left me wanting more. Not more in the sense of wanting to watch more MMA fights, but more out of those fights itself. I’m not sure how these fights will affect my future views of MMA, though I certainly value the quality of UFC far more than the sideshowish attractions of Elite, so I may not give CBS too many more tries. I probably won’t got out of my way to watch it on CBS again, unless they do a stupendous hype job. I’m disappointed that Kimbo didn’t acquit himself on the ground, but perhaps there is still potential there. If he turns around and gets pimped for another CBS fight anytime real soon, I probably won’t watch; maybe I’d watch highlights to see if he gets knocked out. If Kimbo though, takes time off to seriously train and work on his technique, etc then there’s a good chance I would tune in again.
I think I had more to say, but I ended up getting long winded so I’ll cut it here (well after this next bit). I think in the end, this set of fights piqued my interest in MMA as a whole a bit more than where I was at prior, but I don’t really have any faith in Elite or CBS. It’s UFC or bust if I were to get into this. I will qualify that statement though by the fact that I have gotten into boxing more in the past couple months, so it could be more a function of a greater enjoyment of combat sports, so the pique I mentioned could be independent of the fight.
So take my thoughts for what they’re worth. Cheers
-Jeeves Life in the Cell
agreed, ro, nice job jeeves.
The thing that stands out to me in his post, is, that as a casual mma fan, he made no mention of the nights “real” main event, Smith/Lawler. It was a title fight and an exciting war, yet he didn’t say a word about it directly.
I think this says a lot about where the casual fan is coming from and looking for, in this type of event.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
A Little Reminder of Difference Between Kimbo & GSP
5 oz of Pain – Kimbo & Brett Rogers tangle at post-fight press conference. And the best part – Kimbo’s “crew” got into it and were talking shit to Rogers.
Oh boy.
(the poster formerly known as holden636)
Brett Rogers will wreck him
I’m starting to question how much power Kimbo really has in skilled MMA fights. Tank is old and has been getting knocked around for a few years now. Cantrell tapped before he was even really touched. James Thompson has a notoriously bad chin and he was able to eat SEVERAL clean shots from Kimbo. He was a little loopy a few times from the shots. But Thompson is a guy who gets knocked out…a lot…and he was able to eat clean punches on the button from Kimbo and keep coming forward.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 10:34 AM EDT up reply actions
brent, are you really that impressed by Rogers?
not dismissing your statement, I truly am interested, because I have not been overly impressed by him.
I agree he probably would beat Kimbo, but he needs to stop running his mouth, imo.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
His striking is sloppy...
...but he is a tough dude and he hits like a truck.
In a division as weak as the EXC Heavyweight…he is the kind of guy who could spend some time with the title.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 2:26 PM EDT up reply actions
Brent
Hey – be down on EXC, but not Kimbo. He didn’t build himself up as the second coming, and he certainly had problems with cardio and BJJ, but the guy really tried to fight. And he didn’t look that bad considering the short amount of time he’s been training on the ground.
What I worry about is his age – this might be too old for him to get good.
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
I'm not upset with Kimbo...
...as I said early on in the piece “I don’t blame Kimbo”
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 10:32 AM EDT up reply actions
1,000,000% Spot-On
People can slam Dana White and the UFC all they want, but last night’s event was a joke. All the main event needed was for Jim Ross to be doing play-by-play and it could have just as easily have been a WWE show. It certainly wouldn’t surprise me to find some of those who are new to the sport lumping it into the same category after this.
Kimbo tapped at 2:47 of the first round. Watch it for yourself!
http://www.mmatko.com/kimbo-slice-vs-james-thompson-fight-video-elitexc/
He was signaling the ref
Yes he was..yes he was!!
I thought he was tapping also, but it became clear that he was signaling the ref afterwards.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
Seconded
That’s a thumbs up, not a tap. The graining internet video is unclear.
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
Side effect--
You know, we can bash, defend, analyze Kimbo and EXC all we want, BUT one thing I’ve noticed in the last 12 hours is…
When was the last time you saw this many people on the internet sharing their views on mma, Kimbo, Gina, doctor stoppages, testicle…I mean cauliflower, ear, strippers as cheerleaders and so on?
If nothing else it has created quite a buzz, which could turn out to be a good thing…or not, we’ll have to wait and see.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
Wow.
If there have ever been more posts in a shorter period of time than this, I cannot recall. I agree with you 100 percent, Brent. While I have never been a Kimbo fan, I still didn’t expect anything close to what occurred last night.
But how amateurish did this whole thing feel after watching UFC 84 last week? Hopefully tonight’s WEC will make me feel better.
“But how amateurish did this whole thing feel after watching UFC 84 last week? “
What great timing for the UFC to have their best card in a while.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
But
What lousy timing for the UFC to have their next card be one of the most disappointing in a while. I haven’t missed a PPV in I don’t know how long, but I might just skip 85.
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
Hughes, who I don’t care for, is still a draw, Werdum/Vera is interesting and I hope Davis smashes Swick.
But yes, I will be watching in a bar and saving my $$.
"They said you was hung!!"
"And they was RIGHT!"
Yeah
It’s the kind of fight where you don’t mind suffering through the drunken idiots if it means not paying. I may be going to Hooters again (blech).
Don't believe a word I say, I don't train BJJ.
I'd actually say right now is the perfect time..
In the weeks leading up we’ll have had a great “can’t miss” type UFC show, a free EXC show, and a free WEC event. I’d say it’s better to have a lackluster show now when it is very possible that people won’t order ANY PPV based on potential “casual fan burnout.” The next PPV may have drawn a bad number no matter what.
Contributing Editor - BloodyElbow.com - SBNation's mixed martial arts headquarters.
"The reason a lot of people do not recognize opportunity is because it usually goes around wearing overalls and looking like hard work." -- Thomas Edison
by Brent Brookhouse on Jun 1, 2008 2:30 PM EDT up reply actions
CSAC DEMANDS FIXED FIGHTS FOR LICENSE APROVAL
California State Athletic Commission is so out of control they use to demand to know who the winners are before the fight. All the inspectors are still on the commission.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fdw2LMjRmoM
GO FOR THE NOKOUT NOT THE TAPOUT!

by 















