Fighter of the Year (2008)
Before I unveil who I believe to be the 2008 Fighter of the Year, I figured I would run down the list of candidates who were considered for the award but fell somewhat short of their run for my prestigious (o.k. maybe not) award. Instead of just running down a top ten, I'll list the names and key victories which is why I considered them for the award. In compliance for my award, fighters had to have fought three times within the 2008 year or else they were not considered for the award. I don't think that fighting once every four months is too much to ask for in the grand scheme of things.
Thiago Alves: Holds dominant victories over Karo Parisyan, Matt Hughes, and Josh Koscheck. All three are top ten welterweights and arguably top five at the time of the fight(s).
Kenny Florian: Holds dominant victories over Joe Lauzon, Roger Huerta, and Joe Stevenson. He handed Huerta his first loss and stopped Stevenson a full round earlier than Penn.
Miguel Torres: Destroyed Chase Beebe, Yoshiro Maeda, and Manny Tapia en route to becoming the most dominant 135-pound fighter in the world today. Arguably the top fighter in the world.
Demian Maia: Submitted Ed Herman, Jason MacDonald, and Nate Quarry which established himself as a legitimate contender (and threat) to Silva's 185-pound crown.
Eddie Alvarez: Had some major wars in 2008. Defeated the likes of Ross Ebanez, Andre Amade, Joachim Hansen, and Tatsuya Kawajiri. Can really make a legitimate case for Fighter of 2008 if he beats Aoki on New Year's Eve over in the Land of the Rising Sun. And if he does beat Aoki, he'll be the 1B fighter in the Fighter of the Year talk for me.
But none of these guys could top what my Fighter of the Year accomplished. So, without further ado, here he is.
Gegard Mousasi: In 2008, Mousasi fought a grand total of six times. In all six fights, he came away victorious. It wasn't just the fact that he won six times, either. It's the fact that he finished five of those fights. All five of those fights that he finished, he finished in the first round. Three by knockout and two by submission. The kid is the total package at 185 pounds. His list of victims was quite well-known. They were Evangelista "Cyborg" Santos, Steve Mensing, Denis Kang, Dong Sik Yoon, Melvin Manhoef, and Ronaldo "Jacare" Souza. The last four guys took their losses to Mousasi in the DREAM Middleweight Grand Prix. Those four guys are not easy opponents either. Each presents different challenges and are stiff competition. And he defeated them without too much problem in the grand scheme of things. In the final night of fights, Mousasi steamrolled through Manhoef (by submission) and Jacare (by knockout) in a grand total of 3:43. In those six fights, he fought a grand total of 28:19. Or, basically, 4:43 per contest. Unless Alvarez steamrolls through Aoki, which is possible, this pick for the 2008 Fighter of the Year will not change for me.
The FanPosts are solely the subjective opinions of Bloody Elbow readers and do not necessarily reflect the views of Bloody Elbow editors or staff.
29 comments
|
2 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Beating Heath Herring and Randy Couture but losing to Frank Mir is not more impressive than anything Mousasi did. Or what the other five did.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
by FlyByKnight on Dec 26, 2008 10:25 PM EST up reply actions
I think going from a prospect with one career fight, to UFC HW champion, indicates a fighter of the year. But it really depends on what standards you apply.
by Michaelthebox on Dec 26, 2008 10:31 PM EST up reply actions
Winning more than 66% of your fights would be nice.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
by FlyByKnight on Dec 26, 2008 10:34 PM EST up reply actions
...
You’re gettting really defensive over this. He did not attack your point, he is merely saying that Brock Lesnar beat two very dangerous opponents and lost only to an opponent who is tailor made to beat him. He holds a share of the most important HW title in the game, and whether you like it or not he can make a legitimate claim.
That said I agree that Mousasi is very deserving of the moniker.
I’m actually not getting defensive. I actually thought of Brock numerous times in regards to mentioning him but decided against it seeing as how he lost. And I was one of the few saying he earned his shot.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
by FlyByKnight on Dec 26, 2008 11:34 PM EST up reply actions
Thats really not much of an argument. Becoming UFC champion would be nice too, but none of the guys you mentioned did it. It also isn’t hard to have a high winning percentage with three fights over a given year. In fact, I’d guess there are a hundred fighters around the world with that particular claim. Only five fighters gained a UFC championship.
If you want to automatically disqualify anybody who didn’t maintain a 100% winning percentage, feel free. But I think a lot of people would agree about Brock having an incredible year.
by Michaelthebox on Dec 27, 2008 4:31 AM EST up reply actions
Agree with Mousasi if Alvarez loses NYE
I can see why you’d pick Mousasi, but I would lean a little toward Alvarez because two of his wins were fight of the year contenders. With the Alvarez / Kawajiri fight being my choice for fight of the year. If he loses to Aoki (which is a real possibility) then I think you go with Mousasi.
That’s why I have Alvarez as a really close number two right now. Those two fights were so stellar that they’re hard to ignore. If he beats Aoki, he’ll be claimed as 1B for me. I was going to wait until the real end of the year but I wanted to get this up before I forgot. If Alvarez wins, I’ll post another one.
"A lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to get its pants on." - Sir Winston Churchill
by FlyByKnight on Dec 26, 2008 11:35 PM EST up reply actions
Rising Star of the Year...
would be a more suitable title. Based on this list I’d have to give it to Torres (for “Fighter of the Year”), since he’s the best in his division. Hopefully everyone else will get a chance to earn it in 2009 (that would require Mousasi and Alvarez to leave DREAM for a while). Also, I would add Lesnar to a “rising star” list, and if Evans wins, he’s up there too.
As for BEST of the year, I’d go with:
Fedor (just for being widely considered as the best, even without having fought the best)
Silva (for cleaning out his division in dominant fashion)
GSP (why not?)
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
Ehhh...
Fedor: didn’t fight enough… a 36 sec shilacking of Tim Sylvia doesn’t garner Fighter of the Year awards.
Silva: Considering all the Silva’s in MMA, I am pretty sure you mean Anderson Silva and the quality of his opponents wasn’t very good.
GSP: I’d agree with you in him being nominated for the award.
I am in 100% agreement that Mousasi deserves the honor… what that guy did this year was incredible. Miguel Torres is a very close 2nd. Outside of GSP, in the UFC… for as much crap as I will get for saying this… I think Forrest Griffin and Kenny Florian should be nominees. Both Griffin and Florian faced quality opponents all through 2008 and they disposed of all of them in an entertaining fashion.
No Affliction fighters should be in the running of a Fighter of the Year for 2008 unless its the Affliction Fighter of the Year for 2008 Award.
by Gunslinger20 on Dec 27, 2008 1:35 AM EST up reply actions
I take it back...
Fedor, Anderson Silva, and GSP are bad picks for 2008. Fedor & GSP haven’t fought enough and Silva would be the Fighter of the Year for 2007 & possibly 2009 (if he pulls his head out of his ass!).
I just don’t like Mousassi or Alvarez because they haven’t fought the best in the weight class (and they won’t till they leave Japan). Florian, Alves, and Maia have the makings for 2009 — 08 is a little early for them.
The winner is: Miguel Torres (he won the belt in 2008 & is clearly the best in his division — probably all the way through 2009)
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
What are you talking about?
Alvarez beat Kawajiri, Hansen, and has another fight with Aoki all three are top lightweights. Plus he has wins over Amade, and Ebanez both quality lightweights. That would be five wins ( 3 against top 10 opponents) in one year. That sounds like fighter of the year credentials.
by tylerdurden1 on Dec 27, 2008 1:54 AM EST up reply actions
Trust me — Alvarez would be a mid tier guy in the UFC. I don’t give a shit what the fucking Meta Rankings say!
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
Ah no I won't trust you
Your comment here explains why the previous comment was so ridiculous. If I would have known you’re one of those who only thinks MMA takes place in the UFC and that everything else is shit I wouldn’t have bothered replying to your last comment.
by tylerdurden1 on Dec 27, 2008 2:07 AM EST up reply actions
You are pretty quick to judge...
I actually believe that DREAM is currently the best and most exciting MMA platform in the world. I’ve said so on many occasions and have received a lot of shit on this site for it. Alvarez is actually modeled pretty well after the prototypical UFC fighter (good striking, good wrestling, and good BJJ defense), he just isn’t on the same level as the top 5 in the UFC. Aoki, for example, is my favorite fighter in MMA right now — he would get absolutely steamed rolled in the UFC (with UFC rules and scoring).
Mousasi, is a different story. He would be at the top. I just don’t think he could take out Silva, and I’d have to think that to give him FOY.
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
You still have said nothing to back up your laughable claim that Alvarez is a step below the UFC top 5. Alvarez has a better resume at LW than Sherk, Florian and whoever else you think is in that group.
I'm the one who is laughing!
If your goal is to incite me, you’ll have to do better than that.
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
GSP wasn't a bad pick
GSP vs Jon Fitch is in my top 5 fights of 2008…
GSP had a great year.
Mousasi and Alvarez fought quality opponents… their opponents just don’t have the notoriety to really justify all this praise if this were among “casual fans”. Hell, I don’t know of any casual fans that know who Mousasi or Alvarez are. Publicity is everything.
I agree with your praise of Miguel Torres, he had an incredible 2008… but I give the edge to Mousasi. What he did to Manhoef and Jacare just floored me.
Torres is going to have the same problem as Anderson Silva in 2009.. he’s just not going to have great quality opponents because the best bantamweights outside of himself are in Japan. I’d be more excited to see Kid Yamamoto vs Miguel Torres than Fedor vs Brock.
by Gunslinger20 on Dec 27, 2008 1:55 AM EST up reply actions
he only fought twice in 2008, and only once against quality...
That's just a big son of a bitch -- that's all there is to it.
Well...
He beat Matt Serra (I know, no great conquest) in front of his hometown crowd and he put on a clinic in that fight. Just the energy in the crowd made that fight incredible.
Jon Fitch… well that fight was a war and the fact that Jon Fitch took GSP the full 5 rounds taking the beating he did, Jon Fitch should just win Toughest Man of the Year in 2008… or dumbest.
by Gunslinger20 on Dec 27, 2008 2:07 AM EST up reply actions
I would say…
BJ, impressive wins over Sherk and Stevenson.
GSP, beating a guy that KO’d you is no small feat and then dominating Fitch.
Brock, deserves some talk for what he accomplished.
but I would give it to…
Alvarez. He won , won against top guys, had 2 of the FOTY candidates and will destroy Aoki.
Eliot Marshall: Bader won. Like I said in the episode, I'm not going to make any excuses. It's my job to be able to deal with when somebody's doing that. It's not his job to change up his tactics.
http://eliotmarshall.com/
Lesnar- soley because of the pub surrounding him. It would be fair to call it the year of Lesnar.
Having said that, I guess it’s fighter of the year, not most publicized.
Eddie Alvarez would get my vote. Came from no where and what a bad ass. Plus props to anyone that still participates in tournaments.
Mousasi and GSP are also worthy candidates.
i totally agree with everyone you have listed
I would like to add these 2 fighters
1. Satoru Kitaoka is the winner of Sengoku’s lightweight tournement. his submission and wrestling style is very impressive. Only fight i didnt like was the final fight which he just went almost retardly keep pursuing for heelhooks. Very strong guy and it’s already proved that his submission is top notch, but not a surprise since he trains with Imanari (master of leglocks) and Shinya Aoki (master of submission with the help of rubber guard) only problem with that camp is they lack striking skill so much compare their grappling skills. Im looking forward to see him against Takanori Gomi (he was submission wrestling champ who went to distance with Caol Uno in a grappling match) early next year.
2. Jorge Santiago has have proven me that ATT is top camp without a doubt. He’s middleweight run in Sengoku tournement was very impressive. His submission skill is great and he goes for submission as soon as he sees the chance. ALWAYS TRY to finish the fight. He also has KO power on his hand as he proved in the final match against Nakamura.
You have to beat the legend, in order to become the LEGEND
-Melvin Manhoef (after his destruction of Sakuraba)
by chopstickthugz on Dec 27, 2008 10:18 PM EST reply actions

by 











